Erie Island Coffee Co.
148 Middle Ave, Elyria
(440) 412-4060
Customers' Favorites
Hammy Sandwich -- Scrambled Eggs Swiss Cheese Maple Dijon Sauce on Home Made Honey Wheat Bread
Blueberry Bagel Cream Cheese
Avocado Toast
E I C Classic
Iced Latte
B E L T
Soup
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This little cafe is so cute, the cook is amazing and makes the E.I.C’s to die for, everything is made fresh, the bagels are perfect and not hard to eat. The staff is sweet, sometimes there is only one worker and the wait can be long but it’s worth it. The lattes are very good!!
This is the best coffee spot around. I drive from Amherst because the coffee and food is that good. They have a ton of flavors to choose from. The food is fresh, flavorful and always perfect. The service is always incredible and everyone is always nice. The avocado toast is my favorite thing to eat and my favorite coffee is the pistachio ice cream latte. You really can’t go wrong with anything though.
This cafe is small, but cute and wonderful. I ordered the Hammy Sandwich, a plain bagel, a Nitro Reese's coffee, and a pack of their signature blend coffee. The sandwich was simple (buttered bread, egg, ham, and cheese.), yet delicious. The nitro had a standard coffee taste, with hints of chocolate and peanut butter, after breaking through a thick and creamy layer of foam on top. It was nice to be able to sit in the town center at a picnic table to eat, the area is clean...
You May Also Like
Hanini Subs - 346 Broad St
![]()
Sandwich Shop
Foundry Kitchen and Bar - 525 Broad St
![]()
American, Gastropubs, Pizza, Gluten-Free, Vegan
Taco Bell - 117 West Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican