Romeo's Pizza

354 Chestnut Commons Dr, Elyria
(440) 366-5452

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andrea Crist

Love this place and the food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Wenowitz

The great ranch and potato pizza was one of the best I’ve had from a franchised pizza place in years. The crust was perfectly cooked, soft and crunchy with a touch of sweetness, the sauce creamy and rich with the right balance of salt, and the crunch of the almonds very unique! Keep up the great work everyone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bradley Cummings

Sweet sauce? Who knew this was a thing? Put a bunch of sugar into pizza sauce... you know how you add a little sugar to canned spaghetti sauce to cut down on the acidity? This place goes one step further to completely mask that wonderful complex taste of tomatoes to make it into some kind of candied tomato. My wife loves the pizza from here but I just CANT! I've tried subs, chicken wings, and most recently fried pickles (trying to find SOMETHING I can order when she wants pizza)... everything I've had has been disappointing. It's an unusual flavor and apparently popular with enough people to keep it open. Give it a try but be VERY open minded because...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Debbylynn Botos

It’s great pizza & the people on the Reviews who Complain About Customer Service & how they feel like they are not treated kindly or get What they want , like refund etc….or how the phone is answered
Cut it out good God your ordering a Pizza , get over yourselves!!!!!!

z nooh

Wouldn’t let me in for my pickup 20 min before close

Alvin Taylor

Got there 20 minutes before they closed, wouldn't let me grab the food. Bunch of lazy bums

Jillian May

The store closed 15 minutes early. Got to the store to pick up a doordash order and the store was closed.

Michael Rosa

Constant issues with this location closing early when orders are already placed for pick up. They lock the door 45 minutes before closing time and just walk customers.

L Diane

I had a delivery order which included a salad. Did not give a '5' for service, as I had paid for an extra dressing packet which was not included with my order when received.

Debbie Irvine

The sandwich was very good except that it needed to be toasted more

Scott Sorber

Went there on 4 /5/25 @6:30pm med pizza with pepperoni and x cheese. Cost was 16.98 crazy for a medium, plus it was terrible. It was like eating a pizza from Domino's. The only difference is that Domino's is half the price.

MaLinda Johnson

This is a true customer review. I was not compensated for it.

Wonderful variety of items, quick and accurate service, friendly people.

Capone sauce is Wonderful. I pair it with almost everything, even homemade food! Good with potatoes, on tortillas, chicken, sandwiches etc..

Much much better than their local competitors but no more expensive.

robin crane

Food was prepared exactly as ordered and everything was hot!!

Jim Barnes

Friendly staff, great pizza, no problems

Elizabeth Bailey

Rude to me as a customer and even more rude as a Doordasher. Won't be giving my business again, especially when their employees treat customers as an inconvenience and dashers are ignored. Delivery drivers are customers, too, and you just lost a regular.

Loading...