Weber’s Premium Custard & Ice Cream

Delicious and fresh as always!

It sure did melt fast!!! Flavors were strong. In a good way price was very good as well

Best Ice-cream I ever had!

Best ever Higbee/ May Co. Frosted Chocolate malt and lemon custard!

Big flavor can be found in the most unexpected places & if you like Ice Cream you MUST try Weber's. You'll be blown away by the amazing flavors, creaminess, and if you're into it, the history. I didn't expect much when I stopped in here and BOY am I glad we did!

One of the things Ohio has down is ice cream and custard. Maybe it is the long history of dairy farming, maybe it is the Midwestern expectation of a large waistline. Whatever the reason, there is a ton of competition here for amazing ice cream: Handles and Mitchell's in Northern Ohio (some of the creamiest, richest ice cream around), Jenni's in Columbus (no one does wild, modern flavors better), Graeter's in Southern Ohio (no one does chocolate chunks in a ice Cream better!). Well, Weber's is on that list of the best of the best, and a legit contender for the top of it.

This small-batch ice cream is amazingly flavored and many flavors are made the same way they were in the early 1900s. The list is long and the flavors are amazing. Literally everything I tried I liked, and I had to stop trying flavors because they had so many to choose from and I felt bad. 😆 You MUST try the frosted malt, it is to die for!

Speaking about the frosted malt, that flavor plays into the compant's amazing history. You should ask about it and the Higbee logo next to it when you visit. I also couldn't believe that they still made the old flavors using the old machinery with the old recipes and it tastes just like it used to. That's another thing you can read about on their website or ask them about when you visit.

TLDR: go here, get the frosted malt and sample some of the others. Ask about the company's history. Then come back and tell me how much you loved it!

We tried 4 different flavors, all were uniquely delicious!

PLENTY OF PARKING LOTS OF HANDI CAP PARKING ACCOMMODATIONS

Great quality. Unique flavors. There are a few flavors here that I absolutely love, and can't get anywhere else. (Cantaloupe and White House cherry).

Higbees chocolate malt custard is the perfect semi melty ice cream. Love the retro, authentic Clevelandesque “lost in time” vibe of this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Classic and historic. A great little place to get really good ice cream

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped for ice cream with my granddaughter, who is 17. I got chocolate chip custard in a waffle cone, and my granddaughter got vanilla in a cake cone. The girl who waited on us was having a hard time scooping the ice cream, and ice cream was falling on the floor. I told her she had put enough on my cone and could stop trying to add more. So we left the store and realized the custard was very tasty. Then I bite into my cone, and I realize she gave me a sugar cone instead of the waffle cone. It was stale. We pulled over and discarded both cones. One and done.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great place!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place!!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great frozen custard. Came to try the Higbees chocolate malt. Tasted as good as I remembered.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Custard

The best ice cream ever

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Butter Pecan