Bake Shop

27337 County Rd S, Fayette
(419) 237-2393

Recent Reviews

Sort by
D S

I happen to be working in the neighborhood (which means farmland) and decided to stop in here to get something to eat for lunch. I was met at the door by Kristy herself wearing a big smile. She had a variety of scones and cinnamon rolls ready to go. I bought some of each. The lemon blueberry scone is still popping in my mouth as I write this. Delicious!

Kristy has been making cakes for 45 years right next door to where she started out. Wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and any occasion cakes. She's even reviving themed cakes from the '70s '80s and '90s. She also has a large collection of cake platters many of which are homemade. Neat.

It's nice to see someone who truly love their work and you can see it in her eyes and smile as she describes how she started out baking with her mother at the age of 15.

Order cinnamon rolls for Saturday morning pick up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Haylee Cargill

First time purchasing from Kristy and she did an amazing job! I'm planning on buying from her again in August!

Andrea Schnitkey

Adorable cakes! And amazing fresh cinnamon rolls! Her decorating is top notch and she never disappoints!

Jessica Huff

Everything she does is amazing in looks and taste! She's an amazing baker and person...Been going to her for years.

Jessica Murray

Everything she does is amazing in looks and taste! She's an amazing baker and person...Been going to her for years.

Kyle Rondeau

Best cake within 150 miles

Brooke Wirth

Kristy is hands down the best in our area, not only does the cake always taste amazing she does great decorating too!

Yolanda Estrada

Kristy's work is amazing!!! Not only does the cakes look beautiful they taste delicious!!

Yolanda Perez

Kristy's work is amazing!!! Not only does the cakes look beautiful they taste delicious!!

Samantha Etter

I'm not a sweets person but when I went to a local bridal show and tried her samples- I was in love! We had a raspberry filled white cake for our wedding and it was amazing. Not too sweet and the texture was soft.

Samantha T

I'm not a sweets person but when I went to a local bridal show and tried her samples- I was in love! We had a raspberry filled white cake for our wedding and it was amazing. Not too sweet and the texture was soft.

Lynn Barnhart

Excellent cakes!

Loading...