Worst experience ever... Store is not answering calls. Pizzas were taken back to the store. Arrived at store and staff were unfriendly. Tried to refuse a full refund offering 10% off or full replacement pizzas. We didn't have time to wait for replacement pizzas and did not want the overcooked, and burnt pizzas. Eventually got the manager to call the owner and we got a full refund. We used to love Peppy's but this is unacceptable. Hopefully this is not the new Standard.
Spencer Hoeflich (Aries)
I grew up on Peppy's Pizza, and it's always been great. After about 50 years of enjoying Peppy's, I'm happy to say it hasn't changed much! Subs are great there, too!
Jennifer Pauley
If I could give a half of a star I would, The lady said 1 hour. We drive from Mount Vernon, stood in Peppys for 30ish minutes because the lady said 10 minutes on our wings. Almost 2 hours after our phone call to order. Still no food. I work in restaurants. If it’s gonna be 2 hours, just say that. Small restaurants are struggling. I get it. But don’t sugar coat and make stuff up. We walked out.
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza
Shane Kinton
Gotta get the deluxe sub.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Sub
Mckayla Wright
We loved this pizza the first few times we had it but the last 2 times we ordered the crust was thin and over done and there was barely any sauce. We ordered an 90 minutes before we wanted to pick up and when my fiancé got there he still has to wait another hour. No one seemed to care he waited so long. We won’t be back
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Four Topping Pizza
John Lambert
My first time there. Owner Jeremy was the perfect host who generously opened early to provide a welcoming spot to honor an old Freddie athlete and coach. This old Trojan couldn't help notice how much Freddie Nation reveres their own.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Justin Sander
Bosco sticks were great, but the BLT pizza advertised a "mayo base" which turned out to be miracle whip. If I'd known it was going to be miracle whip, I'd have purchased something else.
Laura Gillespie
Best pizza around! I had the BLT and Taco pizza. I bought the regular version, and it had so much cheese on it! I can only imagine how much cheese they put on the extra cheese versions. I also got the Bosco sticks, and they are my new favorite bread sticks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Breadsticks
Mary ALice Blanchard
Yum! They have really great subs and pizza! The owners are friendly. Staff is hard-working. It's a very pleasant place to walk into!
Cute small town eatery. Has a lot of Fredericktown HS sports memorabilia like letterman jackets and old year books that you can look through while waiting. Their wings are AMAZING too!
Great pizza with a sweet sauce and a flaky crust. Best pizza I've had in a while!
Legend Dennis
Meatball sub was excellent
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Erow
The best and affordable pizza place we have In fredericktown the other one sucks and the 3rd one is a greedy over priced price gouging jerk
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza
Deb Hoeflich Beach
It must be the owner because everything is much improved and it is delicious! The items we've had is like they were when the original owners had it back in the 70's! Soooo good! Love the delivery option. Wish you took checks tho.
Charles Woodgeard
Best pizza in knox county Ohio in my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: X Pepperoni Pizza, Ollie Cline Meat Pizza, Chicken Ranch Pizza, Large Pizza, Two Topping Pizza
Worst experience ever... Store is not answering calls. Pizzas were taken back to the store. Arrived at store and staff were unfriendly. Tried to refuse a full refund offering 10% off or full replacement pizzas. We didn't have time to wait for replacement pizzas and did not want the overcooked, and burnt pizzas. Eventually got the manager to call the owner and we got a full refund. We used to love Peppy's but this is unacceptable. Hopefully this is not the new Standard.
I grew up on Peppy's Pizza, and it's always been great. After about 50 years of enjoying Peppy's, I'm happy to say it hasn't changed much! Subs are great there, too!
If I could give a half of a star I would, The lady said 1 hour. We drive from Mount Vernon, stood in Peppys for 30ish minutes because the lady said 10 minutes on our wings. Almost 2 hours after our phone call to order. Still no food. I work in restaurants. If it’s gonna be 2 hours, just say that. Small restaurants are struggling. I get it. But don’t sugar coat and make stuff up. We walked out.
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza
Gotta get the deluxe sub.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe Sub
We loved this pizza the first few times we had it but the last 2 times we ordered the crust was thin and over done and there was barely any sauce. We ordered an 90 minutes before we wanted to pick up and when my fiancé got there he still has to wait another hour. No one seemed to care he waited so long. We won’t be back
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Four Topping Pizza
My first time there. Owner Jeremy was the perfect host who generously opened early to provide a welcoming spot to honor an old Freddie athlete and coach. This old Trojan couldn't help notice how much Freddie Nation reveres their own.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Bosco sticks were great, but the BLT pizza advertised a "mayo base" which turned out to be miracle whip. If I'd known it was going to be miracle whip, I'd have purchased something else.
Best pizza around! I had the BLT and Taco pizza. I bought the regular version, and it had so much cheese on it! I can only imagine how much cheese they put on the extra cheese versions. I also got the Bosco sticks, and they are my new favorite bread sticks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza, Breadsticks
Yum! They have really great subs and pizza! The owners are friendly. Staff is hard-working. It's a very pleasant place to walk into!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: blt Sub, Hawaiian Pizza, Meatball Sub, Three Topping Pizza
Cute small town eatery. Has a lot of Fredericktown HS sports memorabilia like letterman jackets and old year books that you can look through while waiting. Their wings are AMAZING too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza with a sweet sauce and a flaky crust. Best pizza I've had in a while!
Meatball sub was excellent
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best and affordable pizza place we have In fredericktown the other one sucks and the 3rd one is a greedy over priced price gouging jerk
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza
It must be the owner because everything is much improved and it is delicious! The items we've had is like they were when the original owners had it back in the 70's! Soooo good! Love the delivery option. Wish you took checks tho.
Best pizza in knox county Ohio in my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: X Pepperoni Pizza, Ollie Cline Meat Pizza, Chicken Ranch Pizza, Large Pizza, Two Topping Pizza
Loading...