Take out. Great sauce, cook pizza as ordered which is important. Not gooey wth too much cheese. Nice crisp crust.
Jeteia James
I really want to give 5 stars because USUALLY the pizza is delicious. I like the sauce and it’s always ready quick. HOWEVER, this time the pizza was burnt!!!! I don’t know what happened this time but I hope if we decide to try it again it’s back to normal.
Arnesha Phipps
Food is always fresh, hot, and cooked to perfection.
David Wallace
I've been wanting to try Romeo's out for a while. Ordering was easy, response in the store was great, and food was ready before promised. I'll be back!
Elena Parks
Yummy pizza and great sauce. You have to get a side of Capone sauce. Customer service could be improved, but overall it was a good experience.
Nathan
This is one of the sweeter pizza sauces in the area. It’s always delicious! I also appreciate the stuffed crust.
Kelly Newlin
Ordered on Uber Eats and the store cancelled my order? Never ordered from here before and definitely won’t again !
Camille Jellick
Only problem is when you order on line , once you select rewards you can’t change it. I wanted to change it to BOGO which would have been a better deal than my rewards and I couldn’t change it. Tried to go back, tried starting over , it would not change the order
Bob Marinellie
The sauce is fantastic! It's sweet but not overpowering. The Italian sausage is some of the best I've had in Columbus. The deep dish is great! Rivals anything I've had in Chicago
Siobhan Wolf
Ordered online for later pickup. Pizza ready at scheduled time. Easy process. Pizza was great!
The smell when we walked in was tantalizing. We had never had Romeo’s before but were pleasantly surprised all around
terry blazer
Love the thin crust pizza
Matt R
Don’t order well done lol. Very inconsistent quality
Tim Smith
Have to update my review. A driver of theirs was parked in the middle of the street for a delivery. Instead of driving around and leaving like anyone else would, he decided to back up a good 200 feet on a city road. Almost backed into someone trying to turn onto the road and almost hit me because of how wide of a turn they needed to pull the illegal maneuver. So I yelled and flicked him off. He came back to threaten me after pulling yet another illegal u-turn with cars around. Then proceeded to pull another u-turn and go at least 40 on a 25 mph street
I will not be a customer with employees like that.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Derrick Szarmach
Awesome Pizza! Has a sweeter sauce which is a nice break from other styles. Butcher Shop with Extra Cheese is the way to go!
Take out. Great sauce, cook pizza as ordered which is important. Not gooey wth too much cheese. Nice crisp crust.
I really want to give 5 stars because USUALLY the pizza is delicious. I like the sauce and it’s always ready quick. HOWEVER, this time the pizza was burnt!!!! I don’t know what happened this time but I hope if we decide to try it again it’s back to normal.
Food is always fresh, hot, and cooked to perfection.
I've been wanting to try Romeo's out for a while. Ordering was easy, response in the store was great, and food was ready before promised. I'll be back!
Yummy pizza and great sauce. You have to get a side of Capone sauce. Customer service could be improved, but overall it was a good experience.
This is one of the sweeter pizza sauces in the area. It’s always delicious! I also appreciate the stuffed crust.
Ordered on Uber Eats and the store cancelled my order? Never ordered from here before and definitely won’t again !
Only problem is when you order on line , once you select rewards you can’t change it. I wanted to change it to BOGO which would have been a better deal than my rewards and I couldn’t change it. Tried to go back, tried starting over , it would not change the order
The sauce is fantastic! It's sweet but not overpowering. The Italian sausage is some of the best I've had in Columbus. The deep dish is great! Rivals anything I've had in Chicago
Ordered online for later pickup. Pizza ready at scheduled time. Easy process. Pizza was great!
Restaurantji Recommends
The smell when we walked in was tantalizing. We had never had Romeo’s before but were pleasantly surprised all around
Love the thin crust pizza
Don’t order well done lol. Very inconsistent quality
Have to update my review. A driver of theirs was parked in the middle of the street for a delivery. Instead of driving around and leaving like anyone else would, he decided to back up a good 200 feet on a city road. Almost backed into someone trying to turn onto the road and almost hit me because of how wide of a turn they needed to pull the illegal maneuver. So I yelled and flicked him off. He came back to threaten me after pulling yet another illegal u-turn with cars around. Then proceeded to pull another u-turn and go at least 40 on a 25 mph street
I will not be a customer with employees like that.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Awesome Pizza! Has a sweeter sauce which is a nice break from other styles. Butcher Shop with Extra Cheese is the way to go!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Capone Sauce, Butcher Shop
Loading...