I am a truck driver and ordered to the rest area on 33 through uber eats. This pizza is fuggin AWESOME. I will make a special trip to your physical location to get it hot and fresh sometime. Thanks for making excellent pizza!
Jerimiah Johnson
Ordered it up online..was brought to the table...so fresh..crispy and hot !!! Took about 20 min from the order to table ..very good..highly recommend 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Crust, Kevin Bacon Pizza
Reynaldo Cordova
Sexton’s has been on my radar for some time. They have a Detroit style thick option but we went with the NY. I got a reg pep and the 614. (They have some really intriguing specialty pies). I live a but aways but the crust and taste held up fine. Crispy pepp, not much flop and a crunchy crust. Heaven. They are definitely worth a try and are a top 10 for Central Ohio
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Bentall
Anyone leaving a bad review because you are judging pizza on uber eats should go back to eating Pizza Hut and Little Cesars and leave the reviews to true pizza lovers.
This place is top notch quality pizza. Get off your couch and go eat the pizza in house and judge it. This place is the real deal. Keep up the good work.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luke Mattson
It was a great place for a quick date night dinner with my wife. We loved the Kevin Bacon and the Garlic Knots. We’ll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kevin Bacon Pizza
Bill Glover
Best pizza in Columbus. I personally love this authentic brick oven style char and Ezzo pepperoni is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pete Falzarano
First time there tonight and had the White pizza. It was outstanding. This place has ovens no conveyor belt pizza which makes all the difference. Reminds me of my Brooklyn, New York pizza back in the day. Highly recommend this place if you want food tasting pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jortney 2019
First time trying this after hearing reviews. We went with NY old style Pepp and cheese and then a white pizza with chicken and Parmesan . Both very good. Yes they are charred so if you don’t like crispy pizza it won’t be for you. I however love a good charred pizza top and bottom. Tasted great. Wish I could have tried more of the specialty pizzas. lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White
Emily Burns
AMAZING pizza. I live in Texas and when I come to Ohio, I always make sure to stop at Sexton’s. If you haven’t had their pizza, you’re missing out
PL Russell
First time visitor. Got the pepperoni pizza. It was excellent, nice char on bottom of slices, pepperoni nicely crisp and no extra grease on slices.
REAL New York pizza! (And I owned a pizzeria in NY). The crust, the sauce, the topping, a bit of a char on the bottom. This is what NY pizza tastes like. You only get NY style pizza when cooked in a gas fired oven, not on a metal conveyor belt! And yes, it’s cut in triangles, not squares. Is it pricier than others? Probably. But good food is worth it. Do not change anything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Enzo Pepperoni Pizza, Margherita
Carter Denny
Stopped here on a Saturday afternoon. The pizza was delicious in the exact style. I like there wasn’t notice on the door that says they frequently sell out so if you’re looking to order here, I would recommend doing so earlier. The atmosphere here was kind of retro. They had a record player and some big speakers and a lot of sports memorabilia on the walls. This is definitely a place. I’d recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tyler Clementi
Delicious, 5 stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wendy Worth
This was my first time ordering from Sexton's (via Door Dash) and I was looking forward to it based on the reviews. I got a Build Your Own Pizza NY Style and it was tough and inedible due to the burned/charred bottom. Definitely not what I expected, and I threw half of it out. Not worth $21 (Door Dash price) and Door Dash only refunded me $5. I try to support local restaurants, but never again in this case.
Food: 1
alex butler
Best pizza in town hands down. The crust is light and crispy. Just like in New York. Full of flavor. And the specialty are all killer. 100% would recommend
I am a truck driver and ordered to the rest area on 33 through uber eats. This pizza is fuggin AWESOME. I will make a special trip to your physical location to get it hot and fresh sometime. Thanks for making excellent pizza!
Ordered it up online..was brought to the table...so fresh..crispy and hot !!! Took about 20 min from the order to table ..very good..highly recommend 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cauliflower Crust, Kevin Bacon Pizza
Sexton’s has been on my radar for some time. They have a Detroit style thick option but we went with the NY. I got a reg pep and the 614. (They have some really intriguing specialty pies). I live a but aways but the crust and taste held up fine. Crispy pepp, not much flop and a crunchy crust. Heaven. They are definitely worth a try and are a top 10 for Central Ohio
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anyone leaving a bad review because you are judging pizza on uber eats should go back to eating Pizza Hut and Little Cesars and leave the reviews to true pizza lovers.
This place is top notch quality pizza. Get off your couch and go eat the pizza in house and judge it. This place is the real deal. Keep up the good work.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was a great place for a quick date night dinner with my wife. We loved the Kevin Bacon and the Garlic Knots. We’ll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kevin Bacon Pizza
Best pizza in Columbus. I personally love this authentic brick oven style char and Ezzo pepperoni is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
First time there tonight and had the White pizza. It was outstanding. This place has ovens no conveyor belt pizza which makes all the difference. Reminds me of my Brooklyn, New York pizza back in the day. Highly recommend this place if you want food tasting pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying this after hearing reviews. We went with NY old style Pepp and cheese and then a white pizza with chicken and Parmesan . Both very good. Yes they are charred so if you don’t like crispy pizza it won’t be for you. I however love a good charred pizza top and bottom. Tasted great. Wish I could have tried more of the specialty pizzas. lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White
AMAZING pizza. I live in Texas and when I come to Ohio, I always make sure to stop at Sexton’s. If you haven’t had their pizza, you’re missing out
First time visitor. Got the pepperoni pizza. It was excellent, nice char on bottom of slices, pepperoni nicely crisp and no extra grease on slices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Enzo Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
REAL New York pizza! (And I owned a pizzeria in NY). The crust, the sauce, the topping, a bit of a char on the bottom. This is what NY pizza tastes like. You only get NY style pizza when cooked in a gas fired oven, not on a metal conveyor belt! And yes, it’s cut in triangles, not squares. Is it pricier than others? Probably. But good food is worth it. Do not change anything!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Cheese Pizza, Enzo Pepperoni Pizza, Margherita
Stopped here on a Saturday afternoon. The pizza was delicious in the exact style. I like there wasn’t notice on the door that says they frequently sell out so if you’re looking to order here, I would recommend doing so earlier. The atmosphere here was kind of retro. They had a record player and some big speakers and a lot of sports memorabilia on the walls. This is definitely a place. I’d recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Delicious, 5 stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my first time ordering from Sexton's (via Door Dash) and I was looking forward to it based on the reviews. I got a Build Your Own Pizza NY Style and it was tough and inedible due to the burned/charred bottom. Definitely not what I expected, and I threw half of it out. Not worth $21 (Door Dash price) and Door Dash only refunded me $5. I try to support local restaurants, but never again in this case.
Food: 1
Best pizza in town hands down. The crust is light and crispy. Just like in New York. Full of flavor. And the specialty are all killer. 100% would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...