Sexton’s Pizza
943 E Johnstown Rd, Gahanna
(614) 269-7355
Customers' Favorites
East Village Pepperoni
Half Pep Half Cheese
Enzo Pepperoni Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Kevin Bacon Pizza
In Queso Emergency
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Cauliflower Crust
Bee Bee Q Pizza
Smokey Robinson
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
My bro and I made a pit stop for a pie, because, tradition - we're talking $8.10 review tradition, 😎 and I'd been pizza-less for three whole months thanks to my super restrictive diet, so this was kind of a big deal! Shouts out to InternationalDex for the invitation 🫡
This one was pretty straightforward.
Atmosphere is what you would expect out of a new York style pizza shop. Smaller, slightly dated, and “dingy” but not gross by any means. It’s exactly what I would have expected for what it is.
Service was good and the cashier was friendly and helpful. All smiles and didn’t seem to hate her job which was nice. Even accommodated half/half pizza for the kids.
For food we got the...
Atmosphere is what you would expect out of a new York style pizza shop. Smaller, slightly dated, and “dingy” but not gross by any means. It’s exactly what I would have expected for what it is.
Service was good and the cashier was friendly and helpful. All smiles and didn’t seem to hate her job which was nice. Even accommodated half/half pizza for the kids.
For food we got the...
I am a truck driver and ordered to the rest area on 33 through uber eats. This pizza is fuggin AWESOME. I will make a special trip to your physical location to get it hot and fresh sometime. Thanks for making excellent pizza!
You May Also Like
Mr. Wok Restaurant - 931 E Johnstown Rd
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
Sexton's Burger Bar - 921 E Johnstown Rd
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers
Jet's Pizza - 960 N Hamilton Rd
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian