The pizza we got was disgusting and the service was even worse! Spend your cash elsewhere. & to add if they mess something up they expect you to repay for your order again. 👀👀
Sydney Schmied
I cannot speak to the goodness of the food, but the staff and cook were unable to tell us the allergen information. As someone with an anaphylactic peanut-treenut allergy, this is a serious issue coming from a food service or restaurant. We were unable to eat there because we did not know. Disappointed.
Mark Cantrell
Friendly and pizza was great with quick service.
Bill Schmitt Jr. Aka 420kidd
So fire!
Violet Crystal Treasures
So good
Jon Davenport
Love little italy pizza ❤️
BEN RICHARD KATZARA
The best hidden secret in Athens County!! Best pizza, calzones, Stromboli and anything you want that’s got melted cheese, toppings, sauce…. Cannot say enough about this business! Truly a gem. Please support Mary and her staff. Never disappointed!!
Elijah Skele
Always great food and friendly staff
Charles Riley
I have been eating Little Italy my whole life. Recently it seems that the quality has actually shot through the roof. Both of my visits lately have made me want to visit home even more.
Heather Hughes
I order from the New Straitsville location. The food is always good and the staff is always friendly. I also like having an option that delivers! Gotta feed my little pizza monster! 😆
My only complaint is the cost rising. But hey, #BidenOmics , whatdoyado... With that being said... This little Italy's branch is super near to my house. We have actually walked there and back on nice, sunny days all for the love of the piZZAS! I can't ever remember names , but the manager here is cool. He is always joking around. He is def a goof. Which nowadays, sense of humors are nearly extinct. def. Not much "Dark humor" left. Lame. But the guy down at this little Italy's is very patient also. My son(9yrs old) is essentially addicted to pizza. And he has asked the guy to cut the pizza certain ways... Special calzones to hook our picky a$$es up. We are plain and simple with our requests. So not hard to screw up our pizzas. But they always have amazing cheesy yummy hot pizza for us in the amount of time it is promised to b ready too! (I have actually been late before. Pizza is always still hot and yum yum.. ?) Oh! I also highly recommend a ham and swiss sandwich (toasted...). Not a sub... A sammich !? Yummy! But we love the Glouster Little Italy's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Sybil Chrzan
I have been coming to Little Italy's for years. They always do a phenomenal job, especially in consideration of my daughter's Celiac condition. Accommodations are happily offered by the staff, especially the owner. To my surprise when picking up some of their delicious subs, I found out they have HAMBURGERS and FRENCH FRIES! The hamburger was one of the best I have ever had, and I have eaten in many different cities. It was a work of art, with a bakery style brioche bun, fresh lettuce and tomato, and 2 pickles! The French fries were delicious as well; they appeared to be hand cut with some potato peel remaining as an extra crunch factor. I cannot say enough good about this place. They never disappoint!
Dietary restrictions: As I mentioned, Little Italy's goes the extra mile accommodating my daughter's diet restrictions, and they do so gladly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Sean Pittinger
Our favorite pizza place in town. The chicken bacon ranch is amazing! Flat crust or regular!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Lucas
I got a pizza two Sundays in a row, the first one the crust was doughy. So I thought I would try one more time but The second one the crust was tougher then shoe leather. Will not be wasting my time or money anymore.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Keanu Perrin
They tried charging us more than what they said on the phone, they put almost full bell peppers on our pizza. We asked for an extra large pizza and got a very small looking one. The pizza was halfway stuck to the top. When we called to ask about it the man told my husband to not let me order next time so our order won’t be wrong.
The pizza we got was disgusting and the service was even worse! Spend your cash elsewhere. & to add if they mess something up they expect you to repay for your order again. 👀👀
I cannot speak to the goodness of the food, but the staff and cook were unable to tell us the allergen information. As someone with an anaphylactic peanut-treenut allergy, this is a serious issue coming from a food service or restaurant. We were unable to eat there because we did not know. Disappointed.
Friendly and pizza was great with quick service.
So fire!
So good
Love little italy pizza ❤️
The best hidden secret in Athens County!! Best pizza, calzones, Stromboli and anything you want that’s got melted cheese, toppings, sauce…. Cannot say enough about this business! Truly a gem. Please support Mary and her staff. Never disappointed!!
Always great food and friendly staff
I have been eating Little Italy my whole life. Recently it seems that the quality has actually shot through the roof. Both of my visits lately have made me want to visit home even more.
I order from the New Straitsville location. The food is always good and the staff is always friendly. I also like having an option that delivers! Gotta feed my little pizza monster! 😆
Restaurantji Recommends
My only complaint is the cost rising. But hey, #BidenOmics , whatdoyado...
With that being said... This little Italy's branch is super near to my house. We have actually walked there and back on nice, sunny days all for the love of the piZZAS! I can't ever remember names , but the manager here is cool. He is always joking around. He is def a goof. Which nowadays, sense of humors are nearly extinct. def. Not much "Dark humor" left. Lame. But the guy down at this little Italy's is very patient also. My son(9yrs old) is essentially addicted to pizza. And he has asked the guy to cut the pizza certain ways... Special calzones to hook our picky a$$es up. We are plain and simple with our requests. So not hard to screw up our pizzas. But they always have amazing cheesy yummy hot pizza for us in the amount of time it is promised to b ready too! (I have actually been late before. Pizza is always still hot and yum yum.. ?)
Oh! I also highly recommend a ham and swiss sandwich (toasted...). Not a sub... A sammich !? Yummy! But we love the Glouster Little Italy's!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
I have been coming to Little Italy's for years. They always do a phenomenal job, especially in consideration of my daughter's Celiac condition. Accommodations are happily offered by the staff, especially the owner. To my surprise when picking up some of their delicious subs, I found out they have HAMBURGERS and FRENCH FRIES! The hamburger was one of the best I have ever had, and I have eaten in many different cities. It was a work of art, with a bakery style brioche bun, fresh lettuce and tomato, and 2 pickles! The French fries were delicious as well; they appeared to be hand cut with some potato peel remaining as an extra crunch factor. I cannot say enough good about this place. They never disappoint!
Dietary restrictions: As I mentioned, Little Italy's goes the extra mile accommodating my daughter's diet restrictions, and they do so gladly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Our favorite pizza place in town. The chicken bacon ranch is amazing! Flat crust or regular!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got a pizza two Sundays in a row, the first one the crust was doughy. So I thought I would try one more time but The second one the crust was tougher then shoe leather. Will not be wasting my time or money anymore.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
They tried charging us more than what they said on the phone, they put almost full bell peppers on our pizza. We asked for an extra large pizza and got a very small looking one. The pizza was halfway stuck to the top. When we called to ask about it the man told my husband to not let me order next time so our order won’t be wrong.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...