The food here is always good and you are always greeted with a friendly face when you walk in the door.Dietary restrictions: I am gluten free and Elm’s has been a life saver, their gluten free cheese pizza is positively delightful.
I really enjoyed the pizza. I was there working out of town so I had no clue what to expect. It is thin crispy crust with a nice crunch. Sauce was really good and tasted great. I was impressed for sure because I'm from Pittsburgh and in my opinion after a lot of travelling Pittsburgh has some of the best pizza places around.I'm in no way a pizza expert but I do love pizza and try local places any time I travel. It's not the best pizza I have ever had but I would stop there again next time I'm in the area for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Cruz Ventura
This was my first time eating here and also the last one. I ordered some cheesy garlic bread and it was just some slices of white bread with a bunch on tasteless cheese on top with no garlic flavor whatsoever, very dissapointing. The pizza was tasteless too, the atmosphere inside the restaurant is depressing, not even music and the table was greasy.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Joshua Roberts
Pizza is pretty good, though I honestly remember it being better in the past (about 10 years ago). I feel that it dropped in quality from what it once was. Also the "garlic" bread is just pieces of store bought bread with melted cheese. Again, not bad but no garlic and they're $8! They have an arcade machine and old memorabilia, including an old Coca Cola refrigerator which is pretty neat, but I'm honestly a bit disappointed with the quality. I also ordered a Philly chicken cheese which was OK but not great. No seasoning. Not terrible but I can't recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
michelle perez
First time ordering here. Have lived in the Newark area for over 6 years now. Decided to give it a try this evening.We were quoted 40 minutes wait time but that seemed fair for a Friday evening. After driving 15 minutes to pick up then 15 more home to eat we opened the box to big disappointment. The whole pizza BURNT ! with several pieces black and inedible.I called to report right away offering pictures but she said I didn’t need to show pictures.I wasn’t offered a replacement by delivery as I was told we were out of the “delivery area” and driving 30 minutes on my end wasn’t an option either.I was t even offered a refund to my form of payment (card) which was surprising. The only thing offered was a gift certificate by mail.
Elizabeth Parsons
This place was recommended by a coworker of my husband and we decided to give it try. Well we get the pizza home and it appeared to have no sauce on it! We got garlic bread as well, it was 4 pieces of sandwich bread. It was burnt too, we paid $5 for 4 pieces of toast ridiculous! Called the next day to ask some questions and spoke with the owner who told me that they buy texas toast and make the garlic bread themselves and told me they handsauce all the pizza so they couldn't give an amount that is put on each pizza. The pizza was super dry I might add. And my husband had to wait about 10-15 minutes inside for anyone to realize he was there to pick up our order. We definitely won't be ordering from elms again!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pepperoni and Banana Pepper Pizza
Martin Boden
Elms pizza is outstanding. The crust is super crispy. We had never tried the French bread pizza before, and holy moly.Outstanding service and a local feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Banana Pepper Pizza
J M.
The food wasn't ready for pickup at the time i was told. The employees were friendly, well the cashier was, the others were busy talking amongst themselves about current events. The pizza is just barely ok. Tasted like a cheap frozen pizza to be honest. The sub was just ok too - not over packed with meat or a decent size. I probably wont go back and have had better frozen pies quite honestly.
So so good, I used to go here when we visited my grandmother. Oh my goodness, it is still so delicious. Now, my husband is a fan. I wish we lived a little closer but, we will be back ☺️ it brought back some good memories!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Amanda K.
I have lived in Granville for more then 20 years and typically this was our number 1 place to get pizza. However the past year or two the service has been not good and the food not as good either. Highly disappointed with our most recent order. We got the pepperoni and cheese Stromboli - there was lots and lots of cheese but barely any pepperoni, the dough to the Stromboli was barely done as well. I think the most frustrating part to all of this was the way they communicated when I called to make the order. Just extremely disappointed.
Donald Pigman Jr
Nice small pizza place with very friendly staff and good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Strosnider
Excellent Ma & Pa Pizza Place. Staff was amazing and didn't complain one bit about a group of school kids coming in during lunch hours (10 kids plus 2 adults). Food was excellent and I will definitely be back! Pricing is good too! I will eat here over the chain companies anyday!Parking: More parking behind the building
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stromboli, Garden Salad
Sydney Hopkins
It's a ok places. Bad location with limited parking. Food is just average good crust on the pizza, but so similar to alot of other pizza spots. The lady that helped us was not friendly at at didn't even speak maybe 4 words and was rude. Saw maybe 4 teens just standing around talking doing nothing but maybe they weren't busy idk. Just the lady I'm her 30's with glasses was rude enough and the pizza avarge enough to not go back.Parking: Just a couple spots and shared with other bussiness also will be towed if you park just about any where eles around there if they couple spots they have are taken.
Best Stromboli I've ever eaten.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stromboli
The food here is always good and you are always greeted with a friendly face when you walk in the door.Dietary restrictions: I am gluten free and Elm’s has been a life saver, their gluten free cheese pizza is positively delightful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Stromboli, Cheese Pizza
I really enjoyed the pizza. I was there working out of town so I had no clue what to expect. It is thin crispy crust with a nice crunch. Sauce was really good and tasted great. I was impressed for sure because I'm from Pittsburgh and in my opinion after a lot of travelling Pittsburgh has some of the best pizza places around.I'm in no way a pizza expert but I do love pizza and try local places any time I travel. It's not the best pizza I have ever had but I would stop there again next time I'm in the area for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
This was my first time eating here and also the last one. I ordered some cheesy garlic bread and it was just some slices of white bread with a bunch on tasteless cheese on top with no garlic flavor whatsoever, very dissapointing. The pizza was tasteless too, the atmosphere inside the restaurant is depressing, not even music and the table was greasy.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Pizza is pretty good, though I honestly remember it being better in the past (about 10 years ago). I feel that it dropped in quality from what it once was. Also the "garlic" bread is just pieces of store bought bread with melted cheese. Again, not bad but no garlic and they're $8! They have an arcade machine and old memorabilia, including an old Coca Cola refrigerator which is pretty neat, but I'm honestly a bit disappointed with the quality. I also ordered a Philly chicken cheese which was OK but not great. No seasoning. Not terrible but I can't recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
First time ordering here. Have lived in the Newark area for over 6 years now. Decided to give it a try this evening.We were quoted 40 minutes wait time but that seemed fair for a Friday evening. After driving 15 minutes to pick up then 15 more home to eat we opened the box to big disappointment. The whole pizza BURNT ! with several pieces black and inedible.I called to report right away offering pictures but she said I didn’t need to show pictures.I wasn’t offered a replacement by delivery as I was told we were out of the “delivery area” and driving 30 minutes on my end wasn’t an option either.I was t even offered a refund to my form of payment (card) which was surprising. The only thing offered was a gift certificate by mail.
This place was recommended by a coworker of my husband and we decided to give it try. Well we get the pizza home and it appeared to have no sauce on it! We got garlic bread as well, it was 4 pieces of sandwich bread. It was burnt too, we paid $5 for 4 pieces of toast ridiculous! Called the next day to ask some questions and spoke with the owner who told me that they buy texas toast and make the garlic bread themselves and told me they handsauce all the pizza so they couldn't give an amount that is put on each pizza. The pizza was super dry I might add. And my husband had to wait about 10-15 minutes inside for anyone to realize he was there to pick up our order. We definitely won't be ordering from elms again!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Pepperoni and Banana Pepper Pizza
Elms pizza is outstanding. The crust is super crispy. We had never tried the French bread pizza before, and holy moly.Outstanding service and a local feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Banana Pepper Pizza
The food wasn't ready for pickup at the time i was told. The employees were friendly, well the cashier was, the others were busy talking amongst themselves about current events. The pizza is just barely ok. Tasted like a cheap frozen pizza to be honest. The sub was just ok too - not over packed with meat or a decent size. I probably wont go back and have had better frozen pies quite honestly.
The best pizza in Central Ohio. A+
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
So so good, I used to go here when we visited my grandmother. Oh my goodness, it is still so delicious. Now, my husband is a fan. I wish we lived a little closer but, we will be back ☺️ it brought back some good memories!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
I have lived in Granville for more then 20 years and typically this was our number 1 place to get pizza. However the past year or two the service has been not good and the food not as good either. Highly disappointed with our most recent order. We got the pepperoni and cheese Stromboli - there was lots and lots of cheese but barely any pepperoni, the dough to the Stromboli was barely done as well. I think the most frustrating part to all of this was the way they communicated when I called to make the order. Just extremely disappointed.
Nice small pizza place with very friendly staff and good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent Ma & Pa Pizza Place. Staff was amazing and didn't complain one bit about a group of school kids coming in during lunch hours (10 kids plus 2 adults). Food was excellent and I will definitely be back! Pricing is good too! I will eat here over the chain companies anyday!Parking: More parking behind the building
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stromboli, Garden Salad
It's a ok places. Bad location with limited parking. Food is just average good crust on the pizza, but so similar to alot of other pizza spots. The lady that helped us was not friendly at at didn't even speak maybe 4 words and was rude. Saw maybe 4 teens just standing around talking doing nothing but maybe they weren't busy idk. Just the lady I'm her 30's with glasses was rude enough and the pizza avarge enough to not go back.Parking: Just a couple spots and shared with other bussiness also will be towed if you park just about any where eles around there if they couple spots they have are taken.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza