The atmosphere is so friendly and attentive. I will come back because I felt welcomed with it being my first trying their food. I had a personal pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms with light sauce. The pizza itself was good, the pizza was cut into squares (which thats my favorite pizza cut), the cheese was okay it kept sticking to the other cheese so it kept coming off on some of the slices. But the pizza was pretty solid at a good price. Good job⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Kimberly Hott
Was very surprised by the quality and taste of this small town pizza. The size alone is crazy, and the flavor was amazing! Owners are very personable.
liz mcmahon
Thanks for the amazing pizza, wings and cheesy bread. Fed 4 teenagers and 2 parents and it was delicious! The chicken bacon ranch pizza is so good! Wings are huge and a great price. Thanks, Teafords.
Daun Ditty
Love the subs!!
Rick Marker
Best pizza Ive had in a long time. We picked it up.
Matt Bruns
Truckers listen up. I know we don't need a healthy out here on the road but guess what. This place has one of the biggest cauliflower crust pizza there is when I picked it up. It was the heaviest one yet. I felt it was the highest price one I paid for you but Like I said, it's the biggest one. They do have a military discount. It was roughly $16 and I ordered the deluxe version substituted pork products for chicken and beef.
I was headed east through town stopped in at the speedway to get a sugarless drink from the fountain machine for my refill price. That was the highest priced refill price. I had paid anywhere in Speedway lol $1.71 in Miamisburg Ohio I pay about $1.49 to $1.01 anyhow
Let's focus here I was able to make a complete right turn turn my flashers on without shimming. The truck was safely parked to pick my pizza up. Did not hinder traffic. Everyone was nice inside and we did the pictures for a nice review. I don't remember driving a big rig through Greenville. What a great pleasant experience it was it was even around 5 o'clock traffic time. Everyone was very nice. I really enjoyed the visit to Greenville and especially this wonderful place to eat a pizza it was perfect. Thanks again you guys God bless America. What would Paul Harvey say about this place? Probably the greatest things I'll be back as Arnold Schwarzenegger would say. He also says let's get to the chopper lol I guess my godson's working somewhere in the city I still have not found out where he's doing maintenance didn't even realize he had moved back here from Wisconsin. God bless America. My ancestors are from Coldwater and St. Mary's and I'm working right up the road. Thanks again you guys hope to see you soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terence Keaser II
Pizza doesn’t get any better of this. You have not had Teaford’s, then you really need to try it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
barbara urban
Was visiting my son in Greenville, and had to take 1 across 3 states and munch on it all the way home. DELICIOUS, on the list to return on my next trip which I may have yo move up for some more 🍕 soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Brickler
The pizza and breaded wings are exemplary- cooked to perfection every time!
Brian Steenhoek
If you are in or near Greenville, OH looking for some authentic, made from scratch, delicious pizza, subs, and more then this is a must stop. The location is made for pick up and delivery only. The location has been there since 1940's There is something for everyone from pizza, pasta, wings, subs, and more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Size 6 Inch Deluxe Pizza
No dine-in, but they deliver up to 10 miles and have the best pizza and subs in town.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Super Deluxe Pizza
jay collins
Don't be fooled by the look of the shop....this is a place of MAGIC. The pizza really is the BOMB!!! Skip out on Pizzahut or Domino's because they ain't got it. The pizza has just the right amount of bite, thin crust but not soooo thin that it is flimsy, the pizza isn't too oily like a lot of other places, the right amount of sauce and toppings to dough ratio....hard to get into all if the fine details but just know you will be getting a quality pizza made with LOVE. Enjoy!!! Oh and just so yall know...I don't even know anyone at the shop just chose the place because it was the closest to me while commuting for shopping but will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
freya supinger
Wonderful place
Ricky Davis
Trucker spending the night at truckstop. They had np delivering here for me. Was delicious. All meat pizza & chocolate lava cake. Good crisp & crunch on pizza. Cake was outstanding.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trent May, CHFC
We've never had a bad pizza from this place. You won't be disappointed.
The atmosphere is so friendly and attentive.
I will come back because I felt welcomed with it being my first trying their food. I had a personal pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms with light sauce.
The pizza itself was good, the pizza was cut into squares (which thats my favorite pizza cut), the cheese was okay it kept sticking to the other cheese so it kept coming off on some of the slices. But the pizza was pretty solid at a good price. Good job⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Was very surprised by the quality and taste of this small town pizza. The size alone is crazy, and the flavor was amazing! Owners are very personable.
Thanks for the amazing pizza, wings and cheesy bread. Fed 4 teenagers and 2 parents and it was delicious! The chicken bacon ranch pizza is so good! Wings are huge and a great price. Thanks, Teafords.
Love the subs!!
Best pizza Ive had in a long time. We picked it up.
Truckers listen up. I know we don't need a healthy out here on the road but guess what. This place has one of the biggest cauliflower crust pizza there is when I picked it up. It was the heaviest one yet. I felt it was the highest price one I paid for you but Like I said, it's the biggest one. They do have a military discount. It was roughly $16 and I ordered the deluxe version substituted pork products for chicken and beef.
I was headed east through town stopped in at the speedway to get a sugarless drink from the fountain machine for my refill price. That was the highest priced refill price. I had paid anywhere in Speedway lol $1.71 in Miamisburg Ohio I pay about $1.49 to $1.01 anyhow
Let's focus here I was able to make a complete right turn turn my flashers on without shimming. The truck was safely parked to pick my pizza up. Did not hinder traffic. Everyone was nice inside and we did the pictures for a nice review. I don't remember driving a big rig through Greenville. What a great pleasant experience it was it was even around 5 o'clock traffic time. Everyone was very nice. I really enjoyed the visit to Greenville and especially this wonderful place to eat a pizza it was perfect. Thanks again you guys God bless America. What would Paul Harvey say about this place? Probably the greatest things I'll be back as Arnold Schwarzenegger would say. He also says let's get to the chopper lol I guess my godson's working somewhere in the city I still have not found out where he's doing maintenance didn't even realize he had moved back here from Wisconsin. God bless America. My ancestors are from Coldwater and St. Mary's and I'm working right up the road. Thanks again you guys hope to see you soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza doesn’t get any better of this. You have not had Teaford’s, then you really need to try it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was visiting my son in Greenville, and had to take 1 across 3 states and munch on it all the way home. DELICIOUS, on the list to return on my next trip which I may have yo move up for some more 🍕 soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza and breaded wings are exemplary- cooked to perfection every time!
If you are in or near Greenville, OH looking for some authentic, made from scratch, delicious pizza, subs, and more then this is a must stop. The location is made for pick up and delivery only. The location has been there since 1940's There is something for everyone from pizza, pasta, wings, subs, and more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Size 6 Inch Deluxe Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
No dine-in, but they deliver up to 10 miles and have the best pizza and subs in town.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Super Deluxe Pizza
Don't be fooled by the look of the shop....this is a place of MAGIC. The pizza really is the BOMB!!! Skip out on Pizzahut or Domino's because they ain't got it. The pizza has just the right amount of bite, thin crust but not soooo thin that it is flimsy, the pizza isn't too oily like a lot of other places, the right amount of sauce and toppings to dough ratio....hard to get into all if the fine details but just know you will be getting a quality pizza made with LOVE. Enjoy!!! Oh and just so yall know...I don't even know anyone at the shop just chose the place because it was the closest to me while commuting for shopping but will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful place
Trucker spending the night at truckstop. They had np delivering here for me. Was delicious. All meat pizza & chocolate lava cake. Good crisp & crunch on pizza. Cake was outstanding.
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've never had a bad pizza from this place. You won't be disappointed.
Loading...