Pizza Cottage
$ • Pizza
Hours:
4065 Marlane Dr, Grove City
(614) 991-0108
About Pizza Cottage
Customers' Favorites
Pizza Cottage Reviews
Share your opinion about Pizza Cottage
On 8/24/25 after spending the whole day doing wedding prep or getting married, anyone after ceremony was invited to get pizza/dinner afterwards with us. We went to Pizza Cottage, as it was the closest and best reviewed pizza place.
I was not first at the business because we were the last to leave the farm.
Despite the waiting for the entire party to arrive… my husband was the last to arrive… the staff was friendly and accommodating. They made sure the refills...read full review
Pizza was delivered and it looked like it was dropped or carried like a book. I'm done with this restaurant.
Pizza was delivered and it looked like it was dropped or carried like a book. I'm done with this restaurant.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 10PM |
Pizza Cottage is a restaurant that serves good food with a focus on pizzas. The restaurant offers a thin crust pizza option, which was praised for being "over good" with spicy pepperoni. Customers have ranked Pizza Cottage as the best among five different spots in Grove City, especially enjoying the delicious pizza. One popular choice is the cauliflower crust supreme pizza, which is gluten-free and known for its tasty flavor. The staff can be friendly and prompt, with some reviews highlighting great service from the waitress. However, experiences with the management may vary, as one customer mentioned difficulty in processing a credit card order over the phone, indicating that better training for managers could be helpful. Besides pizza, the menu includes other items like the popular sub and jalapeño poppers filled with cream cheese. Overall, many customers highly recommend Pizza Cottage for its tasty food and friendly service.