Spencer's Sugar Shop

9130 Faulkner Rd, Harrod
(419) 296-4838

Recent Reviews

Christina Zachariadou

My husband and I could not have asked for a better baker than April for our wedding on 10.28.2023!!! Not only did April's desserts taste delicious, she was also considerate of our wedding design and coordinated the desserts's colors with our wedding colors! Additionally, when she dropped off the desserts at the venue, she set them up so nicely that the dessert table looked like a work of art.Most importantly, April is the sweetest person to work with. She was extremely responsive throughout the wedding preparations, gave us a huge box for tasting and she was extremely receptive to feedback and changes to the menu. We strongly recommend her!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jaiden Johnston Ohio Realtor

Everything worked out great! Was able to grab a dozen for a party and also she prepackaged some for me that I can freeze to give away to clients!

Amber Lammardo

I am a wedding photographer, and I met April through networking in the industry. The first sample of cake I ever tasted was a vanilla cake with vanilla frosting. It might sound simple, but when I tasted it... the heavens opened up and the angels sang! It was divine. Since our first meeting, I've used April for all of my personal parties and dessert needs. When I photograph a wedding, I'll purposely try a dessert with the off chance I might find someone who is comparable and after almost four years in the industry, it has yet to be accomplished. Spencer's Sugar Shop is the bar that has been set for all other desserts, and has yet to be outdone.

Lisa Horman

Wow! April Spencer did an amazing job for our daughter's wedding. We wanted a cake on every table so she made 48, 8" cakes. They were all decorated so beautifully. I would recommend April for any event that you need desserts.

Allison Bingham

The most creative cake lady in the business! April is easy to work with and always has out-of-the-box ideas which make your treats stand out. The bonus? They taste amazing too!

Mackenzie DeNisco

The best treats around!! April knocked it out of the part for a little girls birthday party! She is the sweetest cake lady!

Madelyn Brown

I would highly recommend April for all things sugar! She was super easy to work with and helped me hone in on the right dessert bar look and treats for our wedding. Everything came out beautiful and we received so many compliments on the variety of sweets!

Shashi Kambhampati

I ordered from Spencer's Sugar Shop for a groundbreaking ceremony in nearby Wapakoneta. Working with April was an absolute treat! Coordinating with her was extremely easy due to how accommodating she was with design changes to the cookies, her responsiveness to questions, and flexibility in timing. The cookies themselves looked & tasted fantastic! I would highly recommend Spencer's Sugar Shop for your bakery needs!

Jessica&Bryan Dailey

We had the great pleasure of working with Spencer's Sugar Shop for our wedding. April exceeded all expectations for our wedding and we could not have been happier. Leading up to the wedding April was super responsive with any question or concerns we might have and was extremely easy to work with. We wanted to do something a little different and not have a traditional wedding cake for our wedding but instead wanted everyone to have the ability to try several of Spencer's Sugar Shop desserts that they offer so we elected to do a dessert bar. April knocked it out of the park with everything she was able to offer. As the groom I have an extreme sweet tooth and I was in love with all the treats April was able to come up with. April even went out of her way to provide a couple special treats upon our request that she doesn't normally do. We also gave April a lot of freedom on how to decorate the table and she made it all look so beautiful. April is a very sweet and caring individual that you can tell takes immense pride in her work and it shows.Speaking with her the day of our wedding as she was setting up I could feel how proud she was to be part of our big day and we were just as proud to have her.

Savannah Linn Photography

Spencer's Sugar Shop is AMAZING! April is a great cake artist with the best personality. She will go over the top to make sure that your next wedding or special event is perfect. I had the opportunity of photographing two of her beautiful cakes for a styled wedding and I couldn't stop staring at all of the details. You won't be disappointed when choosing Spencer's Sugar Shop! I seriously cannot recommend enough.

Ashley Stepec-Bibler

We were absolutely thrilled to work with April. The bones cookies we ordered fit perfectly with our themed party after giving her just a general idea of the theme. The cupcakes were so moist and flavorful. We received so many compliments throughout our event on how delicious and adorable everything was that April made. For any event your having, big or small…this is your woman! ?

Load More