pizzaBOGO

127 Prospect Ave S, Hartville
(330) 877-2750

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kristin Semegen

Ordered through door dash. 3 Sauces never sent with wings. Blamed door dash and made zero attempt to correct order when we called (wing sauce inc. for next time or "come through drive-thru and we'll give you some" would have solved it). Door Dash gave far more off our next order than the sauce was worth. Sometimes a cheap fix is a simple way to keep a customer. Or on this case, a way for BOGO to lose one. This owner/management is no better than the last.

Jamie Shock

Awesome chicken tender sandwich and the fries are great too!!!

J B

New Owners . Great food and great customer service.

Diane Kudlawiec

Our first time trying pizzaBOGO. We ordered 3 different pizza's they we all great and a big hit with the family. Would totally suggest giving them a try. Didn't disappoint. New owners were great very friendly and very knowledgeable of their product. ??✨️Diane K.

Matt King

It's a little more pricey than some pizza chains, but the quality shows through. Great pizza with some unique options and the chicken is second to none.

Mark Vaughn

Not often do I post negative, ordered 2 pizzas, 1 gluten free for my wife, that one was fine. I had thin crust, pepperoni & banana peppers, when I got home, it was wrong pizza, called & they said to come back & pick up my pizza, I did, still wrong one, closed at 8:00 so I missed getting the order correct. I gave better than a 20% tip first time at drive up window, no thank you, also no apology for wrong order. We have been going here since BOGO took over for Zeppe’s, bad food inconsiderate manager, will not go back

BeautywithEm XO

Ordered the pick three for $28.00, we ordered the pepperoni pizza 12", 4 chicken strips buffalo hot, and the three cannolis.When we got home the pizza didn't have any pepperoni just cheese. The pizza was ok the chicken was probably the best out of the meal. The cannolis were fair.

Brett Reynolds

Pizza was not done and this is not the first time. Was raw in the middle. Probably will not be back.

Charlotte Newman

I love this food but I was told I won a year of pizza for a comment I wrote on super bowl Sunday on facebook . Than he said I never ate there because my cell no did not show up so he took my free years pizza away. . I told him to check my photos out of Google map quests. My photos dont lie! I ate at his place and left a comment and gave him 4 stars. Now lets take away 2. Wink

karen burt

Great pizza delicious chicken. From IU endly staff!

Paul Tannish

Worst customer service on the planet. We use to enjoy the food here until they showed us how they treat their customers. Manager Jessica was the rudest person I have ever spoken to. They went to the wrong address not once but twice after me telling them they had the wrong address the first time. Had Jessica stopped yelling over me and listened, it could have easily been rectified. When the pizza came two and half hours later, it was the complete wrong order. I called back for the third time I was told they would send out the right order and hung up on. The order never came and the owner did nothing but offer a coupon?. We would never order from there again even if it’s free.

Debbie Yonders

Pizza BOGO Hartville is the Best! They have excellent customer service!?? The roasted garlic pizza is ?

Jamel Miller

Food was decent brownie pie was stale and old definitely won't be revisiting!

Melissa keiper

Trevor said they call when it was ready…they didn’t. Got there it was cold and not right. I had to wait for them to make two whole new half sheets

Eric Barnby

Someone told us about this place, and man did it not disappoint. Wings and pizza are definitely amazing.

Loading...