Restaurants near Hicksville

“This place is a gem. Susan and the crew make the best fry pies. I’ve tried many other places, but this is my hands down favorite. The cheesecake ones are best nice and cold from the fridge. I haven’t had one I didn’t like yet. I’ve shared them with friends and family because everyone needs to have at least one! And everyone becomes hooked. I am now about 6 hours away and had pies shipped to myself and my family back home. They are THAT GOOD! Opening that package today was like Christmas. The only problem is trying to stop after one. They also freeze pretty well if you can’t get them all eaten. That’s never a problem at this house 🙂 but I have been known to hide one in the freezer before my kids demolish them all.”

“Staff is super friendly and helpful! Coffee is amazing!”

“The best cinnamon rolls be ever eaten.. I regret not trying them sooner!!”

“So delicious! I went for the first time earlier this week and have slreafy went back . I am planning on returning soon and bringing friends and family.”

“Pulled Pork sandwich and mac and cheese delicious!”

“Great owners and great food. Only complaint was I love to tip well for good service. Card machine would not allow me to tip and I had to go next door to the ATM to get cash. Birria tacos were fantastic. Support all local businesses. These people depend on us”

“Best pizza in Hicksville.”

“So many delicious choices! The food is always phenomenal! 🤤”

“I drove a distance today for the meatloaf special and it was amazing!! I will definitely be back! Our waitress was amazing also....great service! Thanks Magpies !”

“Great food, great desserts. Hardly ever much of a wait time!”

“Best pepperoni pizza! We had an errand near Hicksville, so took a detour for a take and bake. Incredibly delicious!”

“I’m from the Cleveland area and was driving past Hicksville for work. I must say this restaurant had the best Lo Mein I’ve ever had. 10/10 5/5 Iwish I got a large. Maybe next time!”

“Food was good. Service was terrible. Ordered unsweetened tea with lemon on the side = she brought me a water. Had 2 toddlers asked about regular lemonade = got pink lemonade in huge cup. Asked about Mt.Dew, she pointed out the drink section that said coke products, so got Coke and sprite only to see another customer get a Mt. Dew. Never checked on us to refill salsa. It was like pulling teeth to get waitress to talk. First time there and not impressed. Service was awful. Food was good. It's to bad because service means alot.”

“Addie is amazing and her customer service is 20/10, she is very friendly and makes us feel welcome and included. Her work ethic is beyond that of a $20/hr employee and she deserves a raise.”

“I love it 😻 they are the best”

“Excellent Food for our Anniversary 🫶 The Tipsy Hen is a Win!!🙌 Awesome staff super friendly!!! Thank You”

“the people. staff and customers are good people..great conversations old fellers giving the history around this neck of the woods.. LOL”

“Last week I mentioned something to the owner about my food allergies and not being able to have things mixed in on the stone. I said some other similar places used independent bowls for those with allergies. They went out of their way to purchase something to make mix in’s possible for those who may be allergic to other things that were on their mixing stone. Really wonderful experience!”

“Quaint little neighborhood bar with friendly service. I enjoy visiting for a late evening bite to eat. Chad and Stephanie are my favorites to visit!! Thanks for a great place to stop by when I just need a break.”

“Friday lunch. Walked in at 11:45 and my food was on the table at 12:07. Cheeseburger and fries exactly the way I ordered hot and tasty. Prompt and polite server. A+++ well done”

“Love this place! Love the food! Reminds me of when we went as a kid to one that was local to us! Highly recommend!”

“fun place to meet friends and family”

“Sometimes life reminds you that kindness and honesty are still alive—and I experienced that at this Subway.

After finishing my meal, I unknowingly dropped my wallet in the parking lot. Hours later—2 to 3 hours later—I realized it was missing. My heart sank with panic, because a wallet carries not just money, but your whole identity.

When I called the store, the staff reassured me right away: they had found it and kept it safe. That calm assurance was priceless in such a stressful moment. What touched me most was that they didn’t just ignore it or leave it lying there—they noticed it in the parking lot, took responsibility, and stored it safely until I came back.

A very special thanks to the manager, Jessi, who handled everything with so much care and honesty. The kindness and integrity shown by Jessi and the team turned what could have been one of my worst days into a reminder of the goodness that still exists in people.

From the bottom of my heart, thank you. You gave me back not just my wallet, but my peace of mind. I will never forget this act of honesty and care.”

“Only McDonald’s I’ve been to that still serves food on the tray when dining in not served in bag where you feel like they are telling you to get out.”