This was not very enjoyable. Meatballs were dry, sauce just mediocre, tiny dollop of ricotta and mozzarella not melted on top. To add insult to injury, 2 slices of wonder bread instead of “Italian bread” as described in the menu. We come every week for trivia. I’ll not spend my money here again. Thankful the young lady taking orders was friendly!
Food: 1
Service: 4
Estephany C.
The pizza here is amazinggggg. Crust is light and airy even though it's a pan pizza. The sauce is delicious and not overwhelming at all. Cheese is great quality. 10/10 recommend!!
Jason West
I imagine going To a place that specializes in meatballs and pizza. But The Staff would not put meatballs on a pizza….. Interesting concept. They also do not have gluten-free crust options. The pizza that I did order the sauce was fresh. The end crust was good. However, the middle was real soft and doughy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Rachel Edwards
A Youngstown-themed eatery. Stay for the subs and pizza.
Lynn K.
Great to see pizza from youngstown in this market. It certainly is lacking a real pizza pie with a great crust and soft doughy goodness to dip into sauce at the end of the cheesy slice.
Noah Newcomb
Love having a place here in town that reminds me of home! Great food and great people. Will forever be a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nicky Santoro Meatball Sub, White Pizza, Hot Peppers in Oil, Peppers in Oil
Tracey E.
Great pizza with the perfect amount of toppings! The staff is friendly, and the pizza comes out in a reasonable amount of time. Crooked Can, where this is located, is a great place to go as a group or an individual. They also have live music.
Sam D.
First of all, I'm never paid nor would I accept ANY favoritism when I review I'm just a dude with a dad bod who digs eating and honesty. Holy meatballs is this place off the hook! Delicious is an insult to the word "delicious" when describing their fare. Our top stop when at Crooked Can Brewery during the summer concert series on Thursdays as well as other times. Pizza's are full of flavor and the meatball subs are, well, the best I've ever had including samplings from New York, Jersey and Chicago on various trips. Portions are ridiculous but prices are well within norms considering two can feast for the price of one! Writing this review is planting thoughts of heading over this weekend. You'll love the atmosphere surrounding this place. I encourage anyone to head there and put your own money where my mouth is, so to speak.
Nikkolaus Spiert
A friend from Youngstown recommended this to "get a taste" of Youngstown... We now have plans to go to the Briar Hill Festival in Youngstown... The food here is phenomenal (try the Briar Hill pizza)! The staff is friendly and helpful and the service is quick. Thanks for the great experience. And of course... you have to try to meatballs!Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza!Wheelchair accessibility: It is located in a market center with plenty of accessibility
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nicky Santoro Meatball Sub
aquateen 28
Their Briar Hill pizza truly lives up to their "st Anthony style" claim. My body has been overwhelmed with multiple waves of goosebumps. It's so damn good you can almost taste the
We don’t usually get an all meat pizza but The Butcher was simply amazing!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh G.
Couldn't order garlic bread and pizza wasn't done enough. Tried to get one more well done and staff was unhelpful. One and done at this place!
Nikk Spiert
A friend from Youngstown recommended this to "get a taste" of Youngstown... We now have plans to go to the Briar Hill Festival in Youngstown... The food here is phenomenal (try the Briar Hill pizza)! The staff is friendly and helpful and the service is quick. Thanks for the great experience. And of course... you have to try to meatballs!Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza!Wheelchair accessibility: It is located in a market center with plenty of accessibility
Texas, Garth Brooks&Dunn
Had the meatball consigliere sub and it was average. Sauce overpowered the ricotta or else there wasn't much ricotta. Meatballs also seemed a little dry. Seemed like they may have been sitting in the sauce or a food warmer for too long.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Ashleigh L
The meatball sub is amazing! Very kind and patient staff as well. I’ve seen it get very busy!
This was not very enjoyable. Meatballs were dry, sauce just mediocre, tiny dollop of ricotta and mozzarella not melted on top. To add insult to injury, 2 slices of wonder bread instead of “Italian bread” as described in the menu. We come every week for trivia. I’ll not spend my money here again. Thankful the young lady taking orders was friendly!
Food: 1
Service: 4
The pizza here is amazinggggg. Crust is light and airy even though it's a pan pizza. The sauce is delicious and not overwhelming at all. Cheese is great quality. 10/10 recommend!!
I imagine going To a place that specializes in meatballs and pizza. But The Staff would not put meatballs on a pizza….. Interesting concept. They also do not have gluten-free crust options. The pizza that I did order the sauce was fresh. The end crust was good. However, the middle was real soft and doughy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
A Youngstown-themed eatery. Stay for the subs and pizza.
Great to see pizza from youngstown in this market. It certainly is lacking a real pizza pie with a great crust and soft doughy goodness to dip into sauce at the end of the cheesy slice.
Love having a place here in town that reminds me of home! Great food and great people. Will forever be a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nicky Santoro Meatball Sub, White Pizza, Hot Peppers in Oil, Peppers in Oil
Great pizza with the perfect amount of toppings! The staff is friendly, and the pizza comes out in a reasonable amount of time. Crooked Can, where this is located, is a great place to go as a group or an individual. They also have live music.
First of all, I'm never paid nor would I accept ANY favoritism when I review I'm just a dude with a dad bod who digs eating and honesty. Holy meatballs is this place off the hook! Delicious is an insult to the word "delicious" when describing their fare. Our top stop when at Crooked Can Brewery during the summer concert series on Thursdays as well as other times. Pizza's are full of flavor and the meatball subs are, well, the best I've ever had including samplings from New York, Jersey and Chicago on various trips. Portions are ridiculous but prices are well within norms considering two can feast for the price of one! Writing this review is planting thoughts of heading over this weekend. You'll love the atmosphere surrounding this place. I encourage anyone to head there and put your own money where my mouth is, so to speak.
A friend from Youngstown recommended this to "get a taste" of Youngstown... We now have plans to go to the Briar Hill Festival in Youngstown... The food here is phenomenal (try the Briar Hill pizza)! The staff is friendly and helpful and the service is quick. Thanks for the great experience. And of course... you have to try to meatballs!Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza!Wheelchair accessibility: It is located in a market center with plenty of accessibility
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nicky Santoro Meatball Sub
Their Briar Hill pizza truly lives up to their "st Anthony style" claim. My body has been overwhelmed with multiple waves of goosebumps. It's so damn good you can almost taste the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We don’t usually get an all meat pizza but The Butcher was simply amazing!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Couldn't order garlic bread and pizza wasn't done enough. Tried to get one more well done and staff was unhelpful. One and done at this place!
A friend from Youngstown recommended this to "get a taste" of Youngstown... We now have plans to go to the Briar Hill Festival in Youngstown... The food here is phenomenal (try the Briar Hill pizza)! The staff is friendly and helpful and the service is quick. Thanks for the great experience. And of course... you have to try to meatballs!Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza!Wheelchair accessibility: It is located in a market center with plenty of accessibility
Had the meatball consigliere sub and it was average. Sauce overpowered the ricotta or else there wasn't much ricotta. Meatballs also seemed a little dry. Seemed like they may have been sitting in the sauce or a food warmer for too long.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The meatball sub is amazing! Very kind and patient staff as well. I’ve seen it get very busy!