Otie's Tavern & Grill

5344 Center St, Hilliard
(614) 876-1548

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robby Robinson

Awesome food with an awesome friend!

Tristan B

Went during lunch break, 10/10 service! The foods pretty good for the price, honestly will come back cause the server was nice, and on it! Only reason it's not 5/5 is the males bathroom needs some work.

Rhonda C.

Stopped in to check out Karaoke on Thursday. Super fun, friendly group! We'll be back soon!

Nora Boles

I always feel when due you should point put excellent service - we had a fantastic time, our drinks kept coming and the conversation entertaining - thanks Ali we had a great time and look forward to returning

Ed-Mina Miller

Great Pub Grub! Better than expected. Great Irish music live every Tuesday night.

Rick Grubbs

Slow bar service.

Barbara King

At 7pm on a Tuesday night a group of musicians can in to play Irish music.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Tomato Basil Flatbread Pizza

Nikki Smith (Theonlynikki)

Came with my folks. Barely anyone here but still shockingly loud. Service was at least prompt but none of us got what we ordered and the server could not have cared less.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Cindi Flanagan

Great burger and fried bologna sandwich. The waitress was great. Great older restaurant

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Fries, Fried Bologna Sandwich, Burger

Stergios Lazos

Overall a very nice place. Enjoyed the dip sampler and yero salad.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Gyro Salad, Craft Beer

Matt Forchione

Walked in and sat at the wide open bar. I asked the bartender why it was so quiet and empty with the adjacent bars being packed.
He said he didn’t know.
I came for a Gyro while the wife and 2/3 kids went to @centerstreetmarket, #crookedcan.
I ordered a beer and gyro with double meat and fries platter.
After 17-20 minutes I Worried about the family waiting for me I asked if my order was near ready. A few minutes later, the Bartender brought it out, while he went to get my tab I looked inside the clamshell.
Wrong order. Not a double meat gyro. Bartender asked me if I wanted my gyro. Well no shit I wanted it. He said he could get it in 5 minutes. Umm, no thanks, why couldn’t you get it the first time (right or wrong) order in 5 minutes. Half an hour in while family is outside finishing their dinner from Center Street Market.

I don’t wonder why this place continues to struggle and do no business! Meanwhile the place next door has 300-400 people eating and drinking.
All started with Jimmy V not paying for snow removal he requested year after he bought it from Otie.
Come on back Otie, bring back the charm and history that made Oties. These people continue to suck….might be my 4th bad review of this nightmare
Lack of customer service and desire to make anyone happy or provide effort.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dakota Stone

Great location atmosphere was amazing, the bartender was great I forgot his name I believe it was Kyle though. Food was ok it was a little salty for our personal preference but the overs experience was nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Craft Beer

Skylos Sobaka

A neighborhood bar. Great Greek desserts and salads. Awesome burgers. Live Irish music session Tuesday nights (disclosure, I play in the session ;) friendly bartenders. Perfect hangout.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tomato Basil Flatbread Pizza, Pub Burger Cut, Burger

Guido P.

We were a party of 10, all liked their food a lot. Prices were reasonable, the patio is cute and the service was great.

Parking: Parking close by for Hilliard downtown.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dave T Wave

Couldn't get waited on, tried to order food at the upstairs bar after waiting 30 min, female bar tender was mad about it. Went downstairs and ordered food. Really small portion of fries for 450.

Loading...