Papa Johns Pizza

3644 Main St, Hilliard
(614) 777-4545

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Wright

I just ordered a pizza from here half peperoni half cheese and there isn't much cheese on i can see the bottom of the pizza. I ordered from this location alot I don't think I will be doing that anymore

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Pizza

Bailey

I know it must take a lot of effort to sauce “boneless wings”, should call them chicken nuggets, and this isn’t the first time I’ve received them this way.

Food: 2

Service: 1

David Willis

For the past couple orders, the "PapaTrack" feature says our pizza is on the way, and then an hour passes, and we have to call the store and say HEY? and then only then it shows up? the papatrack doesn't even track the pizza, it just shows you on google maps where the store is and your house is, what is even its purpose

i've given up on this location

Food: 3

Service: 1

Steven Alvarez

I ordered a pizza for delivery from this store. I received an email to watch the Papa Track to track my order. On my papa track page it said the pizza was on its way for 30 minutes. I walked away and left my phone and it turns out that the app will keep telling you the pizza is on its way, and show that it's still at the store, even if the pizza is at your front door. The person texted me once and then left because by the time I got out there 5 minutes later, he was gone. I called and they said I had to place another order and get refunded for the previous one. Then said that they called me twice, when I know for a fact all I got was a text. The mamager on the phone was rude and lied about their driver. Papa Johns has sadly lost my business tonight.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Qed Miller

The pizza was hot and delicious. Papa John’s has some of the freshest toppings anywhere. Tried the wings for the first time. Crispy and just the right amount of spice. Definitely be back soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas Wings

Christina Ragsdale

One of my 2 pizzas was made incorrectly, I called and spoke to Brie (who claimed she was the manager), she said I could either have a credit for the pizza or have it remade and delivered. I waited an hr exactly to call back to ask where my food was, I was told that the driver came and knocked on my door and no one answered. When I explained that was a complete lie because we are going in and out of the house moving furniture back in due to our flooring being replaced today and no one knocked on either of our front or back doors, she got an attitude with me telling me that I was wrong. When I attempted to explain again that no one was at my door, she told me not to yell at her l, which I was not at all. I was then hung up on! When my husband called back she immediately got an attitude with him as well, he asked if the GM would be there tomorrow she said no and said “he won’t be here for the next 3 days and if you want to complain about me you can do that on the website!” We opted to not have the pizza remade tonight and supposed to have a credit on our account. This whole interaction was completely uncalled for and completely disrespectful! We’ve never had any problems with this store before as we just had an order a week ago!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Christine Dangler

they should be called jimmy johns bc theyre freaky fast. pizza was delicious, thanks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Scott

Pretty good for what it's worth, the $10 carryout deal is hard to beat.

M A

Worst place. Don’t eat pizza from here. They didn’t make the pizza right and when I explained them they had no reason except to yell at you. Cody Miller the general manager and the staff is rude. Stay away from this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

John Downs (Jack)

I ordered a pizza but I was charged for 2. Clerk verified I only ordered one but there was nothing he could do. I had to pay for both. Said issue with their system. I said ok just give me a refund or the 2nd pizza. He said he was unable to do that. Said I needed to go to my bank for a refund. None of this made any sense to me. I didn't stop to argue it as I had my small grandkids in the car. Beware of ordering on line.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Sheri Lyn

I have been craving pizza for sometime now, and finally gave in. So Papa Johns was the answer.We use the APP which tells us accurately every step in preparation- and when it was ready to pick up (they offer delivery too, but we were going to be nearby).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ashley Bell

i ordered boneless wings, pizza, and bacon jalapeno cheese bread and received bone IN wings, pizza, and regular cheese bread.who knew ordering simple items could be so hard for some people. don’t recommend this location.

Food: 1

Service: 1

adam simpkins

Don’t order delivery from this location. It’s always at least 30 minutes past the time they say online. And you food will be cold when it gets to you. And don’t try to call because nobody answers. Rare chance they do answer, all they say is it’s out for delivery. Not to mention the your order will probably not be right. Get your location together.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Mohammed Fateh

Paid 5 dollars for ranch sauce and didn’t get any so I called them and the lady was very disrespectful saying you only paid for 2 when my receipt clearly shows 4. Never going

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rolando Alvarez Gonzalez

Ordered a pizza, and they delivered the wrong pizza. I called backto see if they could send me the right one, but they hanged up on me,very disappointed

Loading...