Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

5254 Franklin St, Hilliard
(614) 971-9161

Recent Reviews

Mama J

Great little spot for soft serve and Italian ice. We got the chocolate and vanilla swirl cones for our first visit, but after getting unlimited tasting spoons of their ices, we decided we would get those next time. The mango is amazing! Bright, clean, friendly and relaxed service. My 6yo son is a tough critic of new places, but he loved this place right away. We will be back!

kELLY tOMPKINS

The girls working were awesome with their help since it was our first visit. Everything was oh so yummy. Will visit again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oli G.

Hundreds of Italian ice, custard, and toppings combinations. This isn't your standard fare ice cream, powder mixed with water, or gritty mix in a plastic bag and thrown in a machine. The items here taste like they were milked fresh from a cow and churned in a barn on a farm like YOUNG's DAIRY near Dave Chappelle in Yellow Springs, OH. Stuff here is super yummy, buttery, whipped creamy textures that you can't stop eating. They've got some great looking ice cream sandwiches too. Also the customer service is EXCELLENT! This place is a MUST GO TO SPOT!

Rebecca A

This Rita's is in a great location with a small seating area inside. I love that this location has a seating area where you can enjoy good company & awesome treats! This location has hard dipped ice cream with changing flavors. I love getting a flight so you can have a taste of all your favorites! The staff is always very friendly & very patient while I try to make the tough decision as to what I want. 5 stars, keep being awesome Rita's!

Sandra Valdivia

For my very first time trying it delicious very refreshing definitely recommending to everyone it's definitely a must

Steven Bogedain

Quick service each time we go and I appreciate that they're open late. Great alternative to ice cream.

Hanna Coppel

Great place to get a treat with kids. Lots of flavor options and types of desserts.

Sarah hyatt

My coworkers and I are frequent ice cream buyers and we love coming here! Always great service, and they're patient with our large order Everytime! The flavors are delicious and they change daily!

Jenny Cromlish

The Italian ice was so thick and gross I'm not a huge fan... My boyfriend tasted it and even said he didn't like the blue raspberry flavor. Fazoli's has much better blue raspberry Italian ice.

Schlelia Gray

So many selections and each that we tried were absolutely delicious. Can't wait to go back!

Derek Schneider

Great spot for Rita’s. Staff is always friendly and quick. Thank you!

Yannick AchaMutah

Got me the Peach gelati with strawberry and banana custard. Taste so good I dreamt about it ?

Ms. Renee

The staff was friendly and my Ice cream was made just how I requested. The searing outside was nice and relaxing. I will be returning.

Pisa Sheet

Wasn’t a fan of the taste or texture of the custard. Not sure how else to describe it than “empty”? It wasn’t like any Rita’s custard I’ve personally ever gotten (much smaller, and didn’t have the dense texture that custard has). It was basically a soft serve ice cream cone.

Chris G

Mango or Black Cherry are good alternatives if you don't like all the kid type flavors.

Load More

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

5254 Franklin St, Hilliard, OH 43026
(614) 971-9161