Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

3901 Britton Pkwy, Hilliard
(614) 777-5868

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katie Vaughan

We ate here Saturday evening for dinner. We had John as our server! He was great!!!! :) The mac n cheese was really good, and so were the chicken tenders. My girlfriend got pizza and she said was okay nothing special, but I did like it.
Overall, the food was good and so was john!

Amber Krakauskas

We are visiting from Cleveland and needed a place to eat dinner, this restaurant satisfied all 4 people in my family including 2 kids (one very picky eater.) Everything we had was incredible! Our waitress, Stacy, was especially sweet and kind to us. Great food, great service, great atmosphere! We will definitely be back :)

aaron rhoades

We've been coming here somewhat frequently the last few months. We found the beer to be cold and refreshing. We take advantage of the half off appetizers during happy hour.

Tamera Frederick

The restaurant itself was clean. We did not have a wait. The food was good, but nothing spectacular. We did have good service and the restaurant was clean. The prices seemed a little high for the food.

jennifer hammel

Everything was great, no
complaints. Quesadillas were very good

Patrick Gargano

The food was good and the staff were very friendly and pleasant.

Victor Rand

Ny Strip, very good. Ordered it Med Rare got it rare but most places do 1 level under so i got what i wanted not what i ordered.

J Garcia

Fantastic service by both the waitress that was assigned to us & the man in charge Omar as he came out to make sure our service was satisfactory but we told him it was even better than that. We were sat in an area where we had a very pleasant breeze from the outside which added a very nice touch to dinner as it was a beautiful day out. We had the beef nachos which were very delicious, the salmon was cooked to perfection and we even had a margarita that was perfect in alcohol and sweetness level. The meatloaf is also very recommended as it’s some of the best meatloaf I have had in a good little while. Executive Chef Omar is doing a very good job with this Rusty Bucket location.

Matthew W

Great spot. Clean friendly, solid food and drinks. Will be back.

jodie

The salmon salad was good, but the portion small for the price. Cheesecake had hints of garlic - likely from absorbing other flavors from the freezer. Our server was attentive and efficient.

Wendy Vanover

I had the Cubano and fries and my husband had the chicken parm. He loves his chicken parm. I love my Cubano the only problem was the fries were a little over peppered. And one thing that gets me is my sandwich came in on a little tray aluminum tray that looks like something you'd get in school his chicken parm Cayman on a beautiful plate that was trimmed with red. I detest these little metal trays that restaurants are going to it cheapens the atmosphere.

Terry R. Spurlock Jr

Disappointed that they tools items of the menu, and pricing is rising, but still great food atmosphere and staff.

Rocky Nutter

Great service from Lupe. The El Cubano was delicious!

Dennis

4 people, 4 meals that were satisfying. The food was good, hot and served in a timely fashion. All 4 of us were pleased with our food - scampi, Sal on and 2 fish fries. Our server was really enjoyable and on top of everything. It was a nice night out for all of us.

Andrew Fodor

Food was great. They messed up some simple things on orders. Dessert menu was presented hand written and apparently there was only one copy. Worked out fine but was odd.

Loading...

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

3901 Britton Pkwy, Hilliard, OH 43026
(614) 777-5868