The New Old Horseshoe Restaurant and Tavern

Whatever half witted negative none sense these previous people are talking about, is insane! This is one of the best spots in the county! Not only is the food and drink spot on perfection over and over and over again, the service is top notch, attentive, friendly and amazingly accommodating! Anyone giving a poor review of this place or anyone working in it is simply having a bad day and taking it out on someone else! These folks are amazing and so is the food and drink! I love it here ! Thanks you guys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders

Horrible service. Horrible food. Would not bring my hard earned dollars here. Lady who picks up the phone was specifically bad

Went on wed night at 7, no wait, decent prices and scrumptious sweet potato fries. Also liked the hot chicken sandwich.

Very disappointing. While the interior is very nice, the food leaves a lot to be desired. The hamburger had absolutely no seasoning that I could tell. They are handmade Pattie’s but taste like straight ground beef without anything added. Only finished about half of my tasteless burger.While there were only about a half dozen people there around 3:30pm, the wait staff seemed to be more concerned about hanging out at the hostess area eating chips than keeping an eye on drinks etc.Finally I picked the worst table apparently. The lotto or keno machine next to my table meant burping drunks about a foot behind me and the terminal where orders put in right next to it. People constantly walking behind me, although I thought I had a table where my back was covered.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Unfortunately I took my sister who is from Mississippi. Hated it won't be returning. Service was horrible, food is too expensive for Johnstown.But hey, 5 ☆ for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Our first time at this establishment so we had high hopes. We ordered the Italian sub -- which was very dry; wings with their hottest wing sauce - had some heat but I'd have guessed it was med heat; and the pulled pork sandwich -- which was actually the best thing we ordered. The most disappointing item was the onion rings.. I ordered the basket of onion rings, which I was assured by waiteess would be large enough to share across the 3 of us. There were 9 onion rings in the order -- I actually counted them. When I mentioned that these were supposed to be a large order I was simply told they were. $7 for 9 onion rings that were not homemade. We won't be back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

We hadn’t been here for 5 years and have came twice lately. They switched owners over the years. The atmosphere is always fun and the building is very cool. It’s located in Downtown Johnstown which is such a cute town. The waitress staff were all very friendly and attentive. Our food was good too. The pizza was good which I wasn’t really expecting. The Italian sub was very good! They have parking in front and rear. You can get inside from both the front and back of the building. They have a small outdoor patio by the back entrance as well. They also have a bar and outside patio upstairs too! I believe they host trivia and have singers here on different nights too. It’s a casual fun family friendly place to have dinner and drinks!

Went for lunch today, had heard good things. Beautiful old building, great greeting and service. Chris was our server she was awesome! Food was excellent prices better than reasonable. We'll be back, thanks!

Parking: Easy free parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Potato Skins

The food was really good. Got the 12 inch pepperoni and banana pepper pizza and it was so good and the price is right. The staff made that place what it is. A large group of prom kids came in and took a lot of space. A cook had a family emergency and had to leave. Busy night and a staff member down and the entire team was friendly and the food was still fast. Staff was there when you needed but was over bearing. The music was the right volume where you could hear it but could easily tune it out. Will definitely be back

A delightful place to eat. Beautiful building and the food was delicious. Our server was extremely accommodating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My family and I stopped in on Wednesday afternoon. The service, staff, atmosphere and food was amazing. So glad we stopped! Thank you!!

Absolutely love this place! First time here. Great classic tavern environment. I have a large family with little kids. The Owner was amazing with my children. Food was great! We will be coming back. Keep some eggs on hand next time hahahah ?

Wow! My wife and I stopped here for the first time and I must say this place is a bit of a hidden gem. I ordered The Horseshoe burger and French fries; was not disappointed.My wife ordered the Santa Fe salad and she too was impressed. We ordered the Spicy pickle fries for an appetizer and washed everything down with unsweet tea that was superbly brewed. We will definitely add this to our list of favorite homegrown small town restaurant that delivers delicious food in a comfortable atmosphere with a smile.Thank you!

Staff and service were excellent! Pizza was a suprise, very good and a nice change from typical Columbus style bar pizza. If in Johnstown worth a stop.

Atmosphere is weirdly nationalistic/political, food isn't very good, and many of the other patrons were obnoxious. It's one of those restaurants that doesn't really do anything particularly well. The building itself is cool, though

Vegetarian options: Extremely limited choices for vegetarians & vegans