The New Old Horseshoe Restaurant and Tavern
65 S Main St, Johnstown
(740) 967-3663
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Tenders
Potato Skins
Menu
Photos
+18 photos
+17 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Whatever half witted negative none sense these previous people are talking about, is insane! This is one of the best spots in the county! Not only is the food and drink spot on perfection over and over and over again, the service is top notch, attentive, friendly and amazingly accommodating! Anyone giving a poor review of this place or anyone working in it is simply having a bad day and taking it out on someone else! These folks are amazing and so is the food and drink! I love...
Our first time at this establishment so we had high hopes. We ordered the Italian sub -- which was very dry; wings with their hottest wing sauce - had some heat but I'd have guessed it was med heat; and the pulled pork sandwich -- which was actually the best thing we ordered. The most disappointing item was the onion rings.. I ordered the basket of onion rings, which I was assured by waiteess would be large enough to share across the 3 of us. There were 9 onion rings in the...
We hadn’t been here for 5 years and have came twice lately. They switched owners over the years. The atmosphere is always fun and the building is very cool. It’s located in Downtown Johnstown which is such a cute town. The waitress staff were all very friendly and attentive. Our food was good too. The pizza was good which I wasn’t really expecting. The Italian sub was very good! They have parking in front and rear. You can get inside from both the front and back of the building....
You May Also Like
Uncle Johnnie’s - 65 S Main St
![]()
American, Pubs
Ghostwriter Public House - 49-1/2 S Main St
![]()
American, New American, Vegan
Henson's Pub - 48 S Main St
![]()
Bar, Pubs