Stone Age Pizza

17653 Mahoning Ave, Lake Milton
(330) 557-1042

Recent Reviews

Mathew “The One True”

Very good pizza! Staff was friendly as well.Kid-friendliness: DinosaursWheelchair accessibility: Ramp and can be table side

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Log, White Pizza

Julie Watson

Great local pizza. Their thin pizza is really good - especially when a little crispy (you can ask for it). The pickle and meat pizzas are fantastic, and they deliver really quickly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carol Grzeschik

I am hooked! Their 3 cheese calzone is absolute heaven. I have never had a more delicious calzone.. the salads are plentiful and tasty. There pepperoni rolls are great too.The restaurant has plenty of booth seating yet I only see people take out or they get it delivered. I wish they had one section that were tables so you could combine them for larger groups can sit together. But I still plan to get my friends together soon and enjoy each others company as we munch down on Stone Age’s delicious cheesy goodness.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salads, Pepperoni Roll, Calzone 3 Cheese

Anthony Morelli

Ordered pizza and wings for delivery, only took about 40 minutes and the family has no complaints. Pizza and wings were both phenomenal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: White Pizza

Mary S.

Inconsistent. This place has good food and friendly owners. The NY style pizza is good and flavorful. The wings and subs are good. Unfortunately you never get the same thing twice. We have ordered "the boss" Italian sub multiple times. It only has about 30% reliability. The sub bread is great, but it's never the same size/width. Twice we have received ridiculously thick slabs of meat, actual overwhelming slabs. We asked the next time if they would be that way again, we were told no, they had a worker not making them properly. We received a great sub that time. Shortly after, another thick slab sub. You couldn't bit through, they were like ham steaks, etc. A couple times more we got Normal, good subs again, plenty of meat, cut like lunch meat, but Slabs. We thought they were back to quality after maybe some poor workers.This past Friday, we ordered 2 boss subs. Insanely skimpy on the meat. We ordered full sized subs. The meat was one slice each and didn't even fit the width of the sub. It was like eating a whole bunch of bread with almost no meat and cheese to even cover the width of the bread. And then they drenched it with Italian dressing. Soggy bread with tons of Italian dressing and almost not actual meat or cheese.Our wings were insanely greasy, also not consistent with what we received before.The pizza was flavorful but razor thin. Maybe they are skimping on Ingredients for cost purposes but we paid $40 for very mediocre food. I would say consistency is key. And they are missing the mark on that.

Valorie Landis

Bbq chicken had too much bbq sauce not enough cheese and toppings, stuffed crust was ok, if we go back will try different pizza.

James Scherer

Very nice place! Food was good, priced really well! The people there are really nice, they just need more help!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

RRRG17

The thick crust pizza is very good when hot. The Italian hot sandwich is really really good. The prices are very reasonable as well. I recommend this place as the pizza is ranked in my top five in the valley. The Italian boss sub is really amazing as well. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jeff Wolfe

Super nice people. We were in town from South Carolina, and a couple of places up there were not very friendly (brewery next door). Stone Age pizza was very friendly and accommodating. The food was great, too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B Rizzle

Walked in and got a pepperoni roll and a spinach roll. Had issues with the Google menu, but it isn't Stone Age Pizza's fault! They were delicious and filling!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jake Wilds

Alright, he's deal. The pizza taste was actually really good and so were the boneless wings. We got 5 toppings on our pizza, all were good. Just a couple small complaints. The sauce on the pizza was a little too thin along with the bottom dough. Those things combined made it to where the toppings, including the cheese, fell right off the bottom of the pizza. Also, our pizza wasn't cut all the way for any of the pieces, so we're had to re cut the whole thing, but it's not like that's hard. The boneless wings had good taste but, they sat in a watery sauce that could definitely be a lot thicker or a lesser amount. All in all, the taste is there, that's for sure. They just need to correct a few small things.The inside of the place was actually pretty cool. The lady at the counter was super nice and the whole place is decorated with dinosaurs and she even gave my 2 girls little Dino toys to take home.I would definitely try this place again with the understanding the smaller issues were fixed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jeff Webb

We really loved this place great food and friendly atmosphere and employees

Christy G.

The mango habanero wings are the only thing my family likes. Their pizza tastes similar to a little Cesar's or dominos. It's very greasy, with no crispy crust. We now drive to loves truck stop for pizza if were in the mood and don't want to pay Gioninos exorbitant prices. My dog will literally eat anything, even week old leftovers, but he refuses to even touch this pizza. I ended up giving 1 large pizza (minus two bites) and cheesy breadsticks to my chickens. Made a frozen pizza that was by far better than theirs

David S.

Great locally owned pizza shop. There giant pepperoni roll is really awesome and great for a party.

Jayson Shenk

This is my new favorite local pizza place. I get an order every week.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More