Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“Great food for the locals and visitors. Amish/Mennonite cuisine providing big servings for decent prices. Baked goods are endless. Be ready to stand in line, it's that good.”
Customers` Favorites
“Very good little hidden gym in the middle of nowhere. I was suggested their pizza by a coworker, and I was not disappointed. Very very good. The staff was very friendly. They have lots of great items like Ski pop and candies you can’t find many other places. Definitely worth a try if you’re in the area. They also have a location in Bainbridge.”
“I work at a grocery store, but I buy most of my meat here. Everything I’ve bought here has been excellent! Their Eye of Round Roast and Country Style Pork Ribs are 5 star. I won’t buy Ground Chuck or Hamburger Patties anywhere else, very little grease and I don’t catch my grill on fire cooking them like other places 😂. The staff are attentive and very helpful even when they are crazy busy! Support local!”
Customers` Favorites
“Ben goes way above and beyond to get the top notch ingredients. The shop is clean and he puts lots of effort to improving and making things extra special . Highly recommend the chicken Alfredo.
Seriously go order today!!!! You won’t be disappointed:)”
Customers` Favorites
“Our pizza was awesome! I really wish I lived close because it is one of my all-time favorite pizzas. We sat on the patio which was great. Our server, Andy, was wonderful! This place is definitely worth visiting!!”
Customers` Favorites
“5/5 Stars – A Local Favorite in Bainbridge with Consistently Outstanding Food! Tucked away on Main Street in charming Bainbridge, Ohio, The Paxton Restaurant is a true gem of small-town dining—where every dish is crafted with care and the quality never wavers. Living just a few miles away, I’ve been here multiple times and keep coming back for the reliably excellent food. The menu celebrates classic American comfort food with daily homemade specials that always deliver. I’ve tried a variety of dishes on different visits, and each one has been very, very good—fresh ingredients, perfect seasoning, and that homemade touch that makes every plate special. Portions are generous, flavors are spot-on, and the consistency across the board is impressive. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming vibe, making every visit feel like stopping by a favorite neighborhood spot. It’s lively yet relaxed, with locals enjoying great meals and good company. If you’re anywhere near Bainbridge, The Paxton is a must. I always look forward to my next meal here! (Pro tip: Call ahead for the daily specials—they’re always worth it.)”
Customers` Favorites
“As an ex-DQ employee, just can say the blizzard was blended perfectly. We got a large superman blizzard. The cookie dough chunks and sprinkles were blended all the way to the bottom, but it wasn't over-blended. Good job guys. Also, the prices aren't jacked up like where I live. A large blizzard was only $5.89!”
Loading...
“Friendly staff, good food and reasonable prices.”