O'Nelly's Sports Pub & Grill

I had a great time at O'Nelly's Sports Pub & Grill in Lewis Center! The wings are crispy, juicy, and packed with flavor—some of the best I’ve had. The atmosphere is lively with tons of TVs for sports, plus fun vibes with karaoke and live music. The staff is super friendly and attentive, even when it’s packed. Awesome spot to catch a game or hang out

Open mic night was fun

Really wasn't there that long it was just a watering hole to me

03/15/2025 - I recently visited O’Nelly’s Sports Pub & Grill located in Lewis Center, OH with family and met up with friends to celebrate Saint Patrick’s Day. The place with packed, full of color green, and everyone was having a great time. They have two bars, a stage, a pool table, mounted televisions for your entertainment, table and booth seating, and an outdoor patio. Nice draft selection, decent cocktail menu, and a small eating menu. Had some of their fries and they were good. Parking out front. Located within a plaza with other businesses. Nice and friendly staff. Enjoy!!

Enjoyed lunch with my honey here!

Went with a group of friends. There 8 people sitting at the bar and we were the only table seated, a couple shooting pool was going to the bar to get drinks. The bartender was waiting on us, we mostly ordered food. She was NOT friendly and demanded a card to start a tab from the two people who ordered a drink with their food. She was overheard making snarky remarks about our group to patrons at the bar. Our food was served in take out containers. I am sure there are people who think all of that is normal, I don’t.

The service was great! I got the Reuben, it could of had a little more sauce but still delicious. Love the cash discount setup!

Lyndsay is the absolute MVP of bartenders. O’Nelly’s gets packed to the brim, and somehow, she’s always three steps ahead. I never have to wait for a drink, and she remembers my order like it’s her job (which, I guess it is, but still impressive haha). Honestly, I’m starting to think she has a sixth sense for knowing when my glass is empty. O’Nelly’s wouldn’t be the same without her—she’s a total legend.

Very busy but did the best they could

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Pizza

Wings and Stromboli were excellent.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Wings, Chicken Wings

I vome here for the dolphins games and I have a great time with my girlfriend. The bartenders though seem to not like me and her at all and I do not know why. We try to tip nice and just seems like we are always ignored or just get treated very standoffish. I go here to enjoy my team with people of similar likeness. Not to be made to feel uncomfortable. Otherwise great place and a good time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Tater Tots

Such a fun spot!

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Awful food! It was cold and burnt at the same time. It took over an hour for 3 Rueben’s and we were the only table. We didn’t see any orders going out, either

The waitress was rude. We visited on 8/24/24. We will not go back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Really obnoxious loud place for the size like your not anything special Popeyes style food

The pizza box says shortys, but this isn’t consistent with the quality you get from shortys pizza. Quite unfortunate. Both times I have gotten a pizza, which was the same single topping pizza, it’s been different both times. One was piled with cheese in certain spots and the other had some other type of cheese that was added to it. The only thing that was consistent was the lack of pizza sauce on the pie.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5