So my mother and I stopped here per my request because I don’t live in the area anymore. This was my first time trying Mary’s in well over a decade and I had such high hopes. We got to the place early as we were picking up my niece from school in Lisbon, and the guy working the counter let us pay and said it would be at least 20 minutes. I don’t know if paying early is what ticked these people off but here we go; So we went and sat in the car for the time said, not a minute sooner. I walked in, guy gave me the pizza, and this is what it looked like. We got ONE pizza and waited over 45 minutes in total, which wouldn’t be an issue if it was actually cooked. So thank you Mary’s famous pizzeria for making me wait 20 more minutes for a pizza that needed to be put back inside the oven anyways. Was not worth the $15 I paid and definitely not worth the $5 tip I left. Save your time and go to Fox’s Den if you want COOKED pizza in Lisbon. I can’t help but think the pizza from Mary’s was undercooked because we got there too early for their liking. Or they genuinely didn’t care what they sell out the door. Either way, they saw what they put in that box. Really disappointed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Elizabeth Altomare
I married into an Ohio family and quickly Mary’s pizza became a favorite stop with every visit. This one of my favorite pizza’s in the country!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Weyand
Just ask Keith to make his special pizza and don't ask questions just order it and you won't be disappointed in his special pizza. It's very well worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bc S
Best pepperoni rolls I've ever purchased! Super generous size, and great flavor, with lots of filling.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiffany Melott
The best of the best pizza! Also has amazing focaccia sandwiches!! And my personal opinion the best wings around hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Logan McDonald
Always awesome pizza and service!!
Rachel Hershberger
Wonderful staff with delicious pizza!
Matt Bross
Drove 45 minutes and dined in. Mary’s is carry out oriented but there is limited seating to eat there. If you need a drink dining in they have a limited selection of 2-liter sodas.
When dining in they will serve you your pizza in a box, which is fine since most will eat out of the box when taking it home anyway. Cook time is usually 40 minutes for a pizza 12” or larger so we ordered 8” pizzas that were done in under 15 minutes, and they were great. Thick, cheesy and quality ingredients. Toppings are under the cheese, sauce is on the sweeter side but I still liked it.
Mary’s Pizza is as good as the best in the immediate Youngstown area, great quality made in their own original way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynne Logan
Incredible pizza like no other. We now live in MI, and whenever I visit family in Lisbon, it's strongly suggested I bring Mary's Pizza home with me. I buy it frozen and bake it at home. The sauce is delicious. The crust is delicious. It never disappoints. You won't be sorry! They're always busy. Allow some time and place your order about an hour before you want to eat.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deanna Seck
Always has been and always will be the best pizza ever! Meaty, slightly sweet sauce, tons of toppings and cheese. Thick crust that I could eat plain the flavor is so good. Always baked to perfection. Staff is fantastic. 10 stars if I could!
This is hands down the best pizza place in Lisbon their meaty pizza sauce is iconic the shop uses a traditional Italian family recipe and it's worth it in every way Their prices are fantastic for the size of the pizzas and the staff are always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leah B
Drove from Florida with this pizza in mind the whole way! I literally buy a couple to take along and my whole family has been obsessed all our lives <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Duane Doyle
Hey we just had Mary’s pizza for supper tonight and we bought a different one today, it’s called “Don’t Tell Grandma” and it’s amazing. Probably the best pizza I’ve ever had from there!! And we have been going to Mary’s for many years and tonight was amazing.
Thanks for doing such an awesome job.
So my mother and I stopped here per my request because I don’t live in the area anymore. This was my first time trying Mary’s in well over a decade and I had such high hopes. We got to the place early as we were picking up my niece from school in Lisbon, and the guy working the counter let us pay and said it would be at least 20 minutes. I don’t know if paying early is what ticked these people off but here we go; So we went and sat in the car for the time said, not a minute sooner. I walked in, guy gave me the pizza, and this is what it looked like. We got ONE pizza and waited over 45 minutes in total, which wouldn’t be an issue if it was actually cooked. So thank you Mary’s famous pizzeria for making me wait 20 more minutes for a pizza that needed to be put back inside the oven anyways. Was not worth the $15 I paid and definitely not worth the $5 tip I left. Save your time and go to Fox’s Den if you want COOKED pizza in Lisbon. I can’t help but think the pizza from Mary’s was undercooked because we got there too early for their liking. Or they genuinely didn’t care what they sell out the door. Either way, they saw what they put in that box. Really disappointed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I married into an Ohio family and quickly Mary’s pizza became a favorite stop with every visit. This one of my favorite pizza’s in the country!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just ask Keith to make his special pizza and don't ask questions just order it and you won't be disappointed in his special pizza. It's very well worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pepperoni rolls I've ever purchased! Super generous size, and great flavor, with lots of filling.
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best of the best pizza! Also has amazing focaccia sandwiches!! And my personal opinion the best wings around hands down!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always awesome pizza and service!!
Wonderful staff with delicious pizza!
Drove 45 minutes and dined in. Mary’s is carry out oriented but there is limited seating to eat there. If you need a drink dining in they have a limited selection of 2-liter sodas.
When dining in they will serve you your pizza in a box, which is fine since most will eat out of the box when taking it home anyway. Cook time is usually 40 minutes for a pizza 12” or larger so we ordered 8” pizzas that were done in under 15 minutes, and they were great. Thick, cheesy and quality ingredients. Toppings are under the cheese, sauce is on the sweeter side but I still liked it.
Mary’s Pizza is as good as the best in the immediate Youngstown area, great quality made in their own original way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible pizza like no other. We now live in MI, and whenever I visit family in Lisbon, it's strongly suggested I bring Mary's Pizza home with me. I buy it frozen and bake it at home. The sauce is delicious. The crust is delicious. It never disappoints. You won't be sorry! They're always busy. Allow some time and place your order about an hour before you want to eat.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always has been and always will be the best pizza ever! Meaty, slightly sweet sauce, tons of toppings and cheese. Thick crust that I could eat plain the flavor is so good. Always baked to perfection. Staff is fantastic. 10 stars if I could!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
2nd to none!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pizza around!!
This is hands down the best pizza place in Lisbon their meaty pizza sauce is iconic the shop uses a traditional Italian family recipe and it's worth it in every way Their prices are fantastic for the size of the pizzas and the staff are always great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drove from Florida with this pizza in mind the whole way! I literally buy a couple to take along and my whole family has been obsessed all our lives <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hey we just had Mary’s pizza for supper tonight and we bought a different one today, it’s called “Don’t Tell Grandma” and it’s amazing. Probably the best pizza I’ve ever had from there!! And we have been going to Mary’s for many years and tonight was amazing. Thanks for doing such an awesome job.
Loading...