Cappy's Pizza

225 Lafayette St, London
(740) 852-3984

Recent Reviews

Sort by
claire h

Food is pricy but the service makes it worth it. My husbands pizza was burnt and I came in to complain and honestly I was not going to be nice about it because this has happened before but girl named tristen took it upon herself to remake the pizza for me and man that was the best pizza ive had in a long time, not too crispy. I noticed she was the only one in the back running around to get crap done.everyone else just talking. She treated every customer with kindness and showed empathy for my husband. I left a a $10 tip

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Richard Welch

Awesome food and place to eat is all I can say

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Hickman

Awesome pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jordy Lee

Ordered food at 5:30 didn’t get it till 8:10 pm , cold wrong food & horrible service. DO NOT RECOMMEND

Irreverent Doctor

I will only ever eat pizza, fried mushrooms, garlic bread with cheese and pretzel bites from here. NO OTHER pizza establishment will receive my business. Legendary food never lasts long. Unfortunately, there are no pictures to prove it!!!!!

Neely Miller

We order from here 4-6 x’s a month. Sometimes more! We usually have good service and pizza but lately they have been way under cooked or no toppings on outside pieces! 🤦‍♀️. We have lived in London all our lives (57yrs old) Just wondering what is going on there????

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

ruth mccarty

A place that has, ABSOLUTELY NO REAL SERVICE should NOT BE ASKING FOR A TIP UP FRONT.

You must order at the counter and seat yourself. I think the only reason the pizza is brought to your table is because we can't get it from the kitchen ourselves.

The customer must get their own plates and silverware.

I ordered a meat specialty pizza. I ORDERED NO...NO...SAUSAGE BECAUSE IT HURTS MY STOMACH. Of course what I got had SAUSAGE ALL OVER IT. At least they did put the meatballs I requested on it.

Save your money and go anywhere else for pizza. In fact any gas station that sells pizza slices has the same customer service but you aren't asked for a tip.

Now I know why thetecwss only one other set of customers in the parking lot on a Saturday lunch hour. That should have been my sign to keep moving elsewhere.

Jillian Bolter

Tried out the Broad st location tonight. Pizza and sub were delicious!! Definitely coming back for our next pizza night!!

Patrick Dengerd

Love that old world pep

Zachariah Bernard

I first heard of Cappy's from The Racing Chef, Nicky Morse a few years ago. Living 40 miles away it's a little hard to justify a trip just for pizza but the pizza did not disappoint. Great crust, great sauce, great cheese and great toppings. Reminded me of Capuanos in Pataskala before they sold it. Solid pie be proud of your product.

Maggie David Haynes (Vid the Kid)

Good greasy pizza, delicious cheesy garlic bread, quick service by pleasant staff. Good classic rock music played the whole time, too, though I suppose that could vary depending on who uses the TouchTunes box.

Harry Oglesby

This place is pretty much run by High School kids. The service is freaking God awful. The knowledge that these guys have is horrible. For example– they can't tell you if the mushrooms are fresh, or canned or frozen etc. If you make anything over a medium sized Pizza the quality is horrible.

shawn alfrey

Best Pizza around.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

TK Mayo

Tastes a little like Dominoes to me.

Johnny Marion

Great Cappy Pizza. The boneless wings are chicken nuggets and way over priced. Not worth even with discount when getting a large.

Loading...