We got the lunch calzones and they were AMAZING. And the lunch special is such a good price.
My son loved the soft pretzel he got as well.
They’re a great small business and do great for rhe community
10/10 recommend.
Alex Waddell
My new favorite pizza place for sure. the quality of the pizza was SO good. the portion sizes are also generous. not to mention the pretzels are also delicious!
RICK Johnson
Pizza is tuff we all like what we like..Kay Jack Pizza is good in an area that has more pizza shops than anything else lol. Seems fresh well assembled and care put into the pie which is all ya can ask for. I would rate as good if not better than rest in area. You will pay for the quality as well so be prepared it is more than competitors, yet better so no argument..We get what we pay for. So I understand building that pie is more costly than competitors as well.Great job, Great place. Welcome pizza shop in our area already growing to 2 locations MADISON, Perry. Try them out I believe u will like their pizza....
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tiffany K
Oh. My. God. First timer, but let me tell you, the best pizza I’ve had in a while. We got Detroit style mac n’ cheese and a Detroit pulled pork pizza. Both were incredible. Toppings were plentiful and fresh. Crust was out of this world. Definitely going to be added to our rotation.
Food: 5
Kirsty Slagle
Love this pizza place! If they don’t think your pizza looks perfect, they cook another one for you and give you the pizza they might think they messed up on. Very good customer service. Never any complaints - they stop them before they can even arise! Love love love!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark K
We were out at Geneva lodge for the weekend and stopped in kayjack on the way home. The staff was amazing, the owner Bill was there and explained the entire menu and their process. He was a great guy and takes pride in his food...and it shows!! Possibly the best pretzel I've ever had...and the pizzas were all fantastic!! I highly recommend this place, next time we are out that way we will definitely stop again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sherry
Got the full Caesar salad and it was a bit small for the price. The romaine was fresh. The pecorino Romano was finally grated which left a grainy texture on the lettuce. The biggest disappointment was the packaged dressing that didn’t taste all that good. I had high hopes for homemade Caesar dressing. The lady at the counter was very welcoming and the shop looked exceptionally clean.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Dan Cottrell
I got the pepperoni rolls with a side of the BAYO sauce very yummy.
My daughter brought some pizza and pepperoni logs home the other day and OH MY! amazing soft flavorful crust and great sauce! I'm pretty picky with sauce and you guys killed it! cannot wait to try the stuffed pretzels
Jackie Bowman
Amazing food and great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cassandra Lucci
I am by no means a pizza snob, but I love pizza and I love well-made pizza that is NOT your typical chain restaurant-style pizza. There's nothing more disappointing than hearing "Pizza for Dinner!" then getting Dominoes. That being said, I will go back to Kay Jack Pizza time and time again. Pricey? Sure, if you're comparing it to Dominoes, but the prices, in my opinion, were appropriate, and frankly quite affordable for what you get.
For context, my husband and I are staying with family in Madison after our home and everything we own burned to the ground, so we're new to the food scene here. Where we're staying, there are several bar-restaurants specializing in fried food, burgers, wings, etc., but none of them have acceptable pizza. When we stay in places long term, a dependable pizza joint is necessary. We tried another spot in Madison that was sort of non-traditional but the pizza didn't quite hit the mark.
At 8 PM on a Friday night, I told my husband to find somewhere to get food and when he picked a pizza place, I was a little annoyed, considering the disappointment I felt from the past place. I opened the online ordering window for pizza, scrolled to the bottom, saw the "Brisket Pizza," and was sold. We also snagged a garlic cheesy bread and a full chipotle chicken salad.
Let me tell you that everything we got was wonderful. We did get the Brisket pizza with stuffed crust. That alone was well worth the up-charge. The pizza itself had BBQ sauce, white BBQ, caramelized onions, and corn. Say what you want about corn on pizza, but I will never turn my nose up to it! But to the point: the pizza literally turned my bad mood completely around. The dough was delicious, the toppings delicious, and the Brisket was so moist and flavorful!
Honorable mention to the sides, too! The garlic cheesy bread was excellent, actually had spices on it, and the sauce it came with was delicious. The chipotle chicken salad was huge and reasonable for the price and the chipotle sauce is to die for. I like a kick and wow did it kick me right in the face because it was spicy, and that's how I like it! It also took my husband and me two days to eat it.
Long story short - get yourself into Kay Jack Pizza and give it a try. If you don't like it, then you're probably just picky and don't like flavor :)
We got the lunch calzones and they were AMAZING. And the lunch special is such a good price. My son loved the soft pretzel he got as well. They’re a great small business and do great for rhe community 10/10 recommend.
My new favorite pizza place for sure. the quality of the pizza was SO good. the portion sizes are also generous. not to mention the pretzels are also delicious!
Pizza is tuff we all like what we like..Kay Jack Pizza is good in an area that has more pizza shops than anything else lol. Seems fresh well assembled and care put into the pie which is all ya can ask for. I would rate as good if not better than rest in area. You will pay for the quality as well so be prepared it is more than competitors, yet better so no argument..We get what we pay for. So I understand building that pie is more costly than competitors as well.Great job, Great place. Welcome pizza shop in our area already growing to 2 locations MADISON, Perry. Try them out I believe u will like their pizza....
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Oh. My. God. First timer, but let me tell you, the best pizza I’ve had in a while. We got Detroit style mac n’ cheese and a Detroit pulled pork pizza. Both were incredible. Toppings were plentiful and fresh. Crust was out of this world. Definitely going to be added to our rotation.
Food: 5
Love this pizza place! If they don’t think your pizza looks perfect, they cook another one for you and give you the pizza they might think they messed up on. Very good customer service. Never any complaints - they stop them before they can even arise! Love love love!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were out at Geneva lodge for the weekend and stopped in kayjack on the way home. The staff was amazing, the owner Bill was there and explained the entire menu and their process. He was a great guy and takes pride in his food...and it shows!! Possibly the best pretzel I've ever had...and the pizzas were all fantastic!! I highly recommend this place, next time we are out that way we will definitely stop again!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the full Caesar salad and it was a bit small for the price. The romaine was fresh. The pecorino Romano was finally grated which left a grainy texture on the lettuce. The biggest disappointment was the packaged dressing that didn’t taste all that good. I had high hopes for homemade Caesar dressing.
The lady at the counter was very welcoming and the shop looked exceptionally clean.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
I got the pepperoni rolls with a side of the BAYO sauce very yummy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Pepperoni Logs, Buffalo Chicken, Peppers, The Meat Pizza
Great customer service, great food! :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We are from out of town - We were very impressed with this pizza place 😊 Fast - Fresh - & Tasty ✨
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is delish! Highly recommend!!
My daughter brought some pizza and pepperoni logs home the other day and OH MY! amazing soft flavorful crust and great sauce! I'm pretty picky with sauce and you guys killed it! cannot wait to try the stuffed pretzels
Amazing food and great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am by no means a pizza snob, but I love pizza and I love well-made pizza that is NOT your typical chain restaurant-style pizza. There's nothing more disappointing than hearing "Pizza for Dinner!" then getting Dominoes. That being said, I will go back to Kay Jack Pizza time and time again. Pricey? Sure, if you're comparing it to Dominoes, but the prices, in my opinion, were appropriate, and frankly quite affordable for what you get.
For context, my husband and I are staying with family in Madison after our home and everything we own burned to the ground, so we're new to the food scene here. Where we're staying, there are several bar-restaurants specializing in fried food, burgers, wings, etc., but none of them have acceptable pizza. When we stay in places long term, a dependable pizza joint is necessary. We tried another spot in Madison that was sort of non-traditional but the pizza didn't quite hit the mark.
At 8 PM on a Friday night, I told my husband to find somewhere to get food and when he picked a pizza place, I was a little annoyed, considering the disappointment I felt from the past place. I opened the online ordering window for pizza, scrolled to the bottom, saw the "Brisket Pizza," and was sold. We also snagged a garlic cheesy bread and a full chipotle chicken salad.
Let me tell you that everything we got was wonderful. We did get the Brisket pizza with stuffed crust. That alone was well worth the up-charge. The pizza itself had BBQ sauce, white BBQ, caramelized onions, and corn. Say what you want about corn on pizza, but I will never turn my nose up to it! But to the point: the pizza literally turned my bad mood completely around. The dough was delicious, the toppings delicious, and the Brisket was so moist and flavorful!
Honorable mention to the sides, too! The garlic cheesy bread was excellent, actually had spices on it, and the sauce it came with was delicious. The chipotle chicken salad was huge and reasonable for the price and the chipotle sauce is to die for. I like a kick and wow did it kick me right in the face because it was spicy, and that's how I like it! It also took my husband and me two days to eat it.
Long story short - get yourself into Kay Jack Pizza and give it a try. If you don't like it, then you're probably just picky and don't like flavor :)
Food: 5
Everything is delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...