I just ordered from there and this is the website that pops up so the prices you have up are not accurate. I ordered way more than I needed for 3 kids because the prices listed on this page are so low. Just to get a call back from the manager saying she has nothing to do with this site and no control over it. I suggest you update your prices. I understand this is a small town and don’t get many visits but I have not lived here my whole life and to me these prices seem accurate to a small town menu price. Unfortunately I paid for donatos quality and this is def not that. I am a pizza sub expert and have eaten great quality food all over the United States and the prices for what you get do not reflect the quality. Atlanta and New Jersey and small town Donatos are worth what I paid but not this small town pizza shop. I will end up throwing out half of what I bought because my kids don’t eat left overs l. So to me the $36 I had in mind versus the $52 is way different to waste. I could have made the same subs at home better quality for that price. The fries also suck they were very dry and my kids didn’t touch them. They shouldn’t be sold in my opinion and 3 boy’s opinions. Say no to the fries and the mushrooms that come on the Italian sun. So disgusting make sure you tell them no mushrooms because they are canned mushrooms and don’t belong on a true Italian sub. Half my family are italian so we all Laughed at the fact they put mushrooms on their subs. Overall the people are nice and that’s what makes the place okay and convenient when your trapped in a small town and have 2 pizza places as options.
Chris Overmire
I know this might seem a little weird to do a review but I just want to let them know. I lived in Marengo as a child from late 70’s to 1987. My happiest food memories were getting a large pepperoni pizza from pizza to go on Friday nights. I still have not to this day that was as good as pizza to go. Thank you .
Joe Hoepfner
Quick and easy carry out pizza. Always love getting their pep and meat lover pizza.
john shindel
Always good pizza and subs
William W
Pizza is ok. not great, but not horrible. It's your stranded small town pizza business. The wings are a joke. The wings are extremely small. 12 wings? The 12 wings only really added up to 5, maybe 6, normal size wings. I dont know why these small town pizza places think they can give you the smallest and or lowest quality food and charge you more than other places. I won't do it again. I'll happily drive out of my way to get better pizza and bigger wings for cheaper then small town pizza places like this.
Brent Chism
It could be better but, the company can't afford good help
L R
Everyone working here have great attitudes and are friendly. Awesome pizza!
Marsha Welle
Kim was super friendly, and the pizza was yummy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza
shannon magill
Always wonderful service and great pizza
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Halpin
Wow! Customer since 1987. Had the typical hair on the pizza over the years. Tonight, ordered a thick crust, crunchy Hawaiian pizza. Got it home, and opened the box, and the outer 1/3 was black. I called, and was told by a young female, that I ordered a crispy crust. I said but not black. She said they were very busy tonight, and she would make another one and hung up. So, do I now want a pizza that she would probably sabotage in some manner. No, we ate the inner half, then gave the rest to the dog.
I just ordered from there and this is the website that pops up so the prices you have up are not accurate. I ordered way more than I needed for 3 kids because the prices listed on this page are so low. Just to get a call back from the manager saying she has nothing to do with this site and no control over it. I suggest you update your prices. I understand this is a small town and don’t get many visits but I have not lived here my whole life and to me these prices seem accurate to a small town menu price. Unfortunately I paid for donatos quality and this is def not that. I am a pizza sub expert and have eaten great quality food all over the United States and the prices for what you get do not reflect the quality. Atlanta and New Jersey and small town Donatos are worth what I paid but not this small town pizza shop. I will end up throwing out half of what I bought because my kids don’t eat left overs l. So to me the $36 I had in mind versus the $52 is way different to waste. I could have made the same subs at home better quality for that price. The fries also suck they were very dry and my kids didn’t touch them. They shouldn’t be sold in my opinion and 3 boy’s opinions. Say no to the fries and the mushrooms that come on the Italian sun. So disgusting make sure you tell them no mushrooms because they are canned mushrooms and don’t belong on a true Italian sub. Half my family are italian so we all
Laughed at the fact they put mushrooms on their subs. Overall the people are nice and that’s what makes the place okay and convenient when your trapped in a small town and have 2 pizza places as options.
I know this might seem a little weird to do a review but I just want to let them know. I lived in Marengo as a child from late 70’s to 1987. My happiest food memories were getting a large pepperoni pizza from pizza to go on Friday nights. I still have not to this day that was as good as pizza to go. Thank you .
Quick and easy carry out pizza. Always love getting their pep and meat lover pizza.
Always good pizza and subs
Pizza is ok. not great, but not horrible. It's your stranded small town pizza business. The wings are a joke. The wings are extremely small. 12 wings? The 12 wings only really added up to 5, maybe 6, normal size wings. I dont know why these small town pizza places think they can give you the smallest and or lowest quality food and charge you more than other places. I won't do it again. I'll happily drive out of my way to get better pizza and bigger wings for cheaper then small town pizza places like this.
It could be better but, the company can't afford good help
Everyone working here have great attitudes and are friendly. Awesome pizza!
Kim was super friendly, and the pizza was yummy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco Pizza
Always wonderful service and great pizza
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow! Customer since 1987. Had the typical hair on the pizza over the years. Tonight, ordered a thick crust, crunchy Hawaiian pizza. Got it home, and opened the box, and the outer 1/3 was black. I called, and was told by a young female, that I ordered a crispy crust. I said but not black. She said they were very busy tonight, and she would make another one and hung up. So, do I now want a pizza that she would probably sabotage in some manner. No, we ate the inner half, then gave the rest to the dog.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Very friendly service and great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fries, Italian Sub, First Topping Pizza
Ordered a sub,it was baked perfectly,and service was fast and friendly. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub
You gotta love this place!
The best pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...