DeFelice Bros Pizza - Martins Ferry

I called in the order it was supposed to be ready in half an hour got there after 20 minutes waited another 20-25 minutes for the pizza I ordered. They apologized for the wait. The pizza was tasty. On the website the toppings are on top of the cheese. The pizza i got had the cheese on the toppings. Strange i thought. Tasty but not great.

I have ordered from this location 2 times (online). The first time I ordered from here it took 2 hours to get my order to me and my home at most is only 2-3 miles from the pizza shop . I got my food and the food was good but it shouldn't take 2 hours just for pizza. My most recent order( again online ) was around 8pm and they closed at 9 pm, I placed the order, it was deducted from my card and message said it would be about an hour, which was fine but when I called the store a little time later to see if my order was completed, the worker said that she didn't receive my order. So I checked to see if my money had been refunded to my card , it showed that I got back all my refund except like a dollar and change. I have been told by several of my friends that ordered from this location that they will cancel the order if it's close to closing time especially if it's a big order. So for future reference if you decide to order from this location , do it a couple hours before closing or order from their competitors .

We order from this location often and never have any issues. Pizza, breadsticks, and pep rolls are all very good!! Service is always pleasant and on time.

Went in & ordered. Everyone was pleasant & friendly, actually great to see that! Pizza was really good as well. Great turn around guys!

Good pizza.

The delivery driver bill did a excellent job not only was my food hot but he was polite and professional, great work all around.

on valentines day my mother called and ordered a detroit pizza, she was starving and ready to eat, and told her coworkers she would feed them too. the pizza never came, my mother and multiple coworkers waited, called the restaurant and checked for the delivery man. also, she payed with a cashapp card so they stole her money. when i called for my mom asking to get the pizza we never got, they said they couldnt help. the nasally male manager i spoke with was rude and condescending, and i will be leaving more bad reviews. i will also be going to the restaurant to complain to his higher up too. defelice is no longer good food, its liars and theives. i gave multiple people the order name and number my mother used, they even confirmed that she made the order with her card, but they couldnt help. so they stole my mothers money on purpose, told my mother she could get the pizza when she wanted after they refused to deliver, and then when we tried to get what we payed for they said no. these employees and the “owner” make themselves look good in comments, and then lie and refuse to help in real life. i will be calling the number the “owner” left and making sure they know how low and disgusting this location and its employees are. honestly doubt the owner is really commenting… cant trust any of these liars anymore, will be complaining about the comment responding to this post too.

That heart shaped pizza was so disappointing, especially for the price. It was dry with very little cheese and paid extra for meat lovers pizza, still waiting to see the meat. Where's the meat?

Ordered the taco pizza. And I won't ever again. It's mediocre at best. The most plentiful topping is lettuce. Hardly any cheese . 2nd item was the sausage appetizer. Once again very basic and little flavor. I frequent the area often. And had wanted to give the place a try. I won't again. This an honest opinion post and not meant to bash the establishment.

My go to pizza place, however, I don't order there as much anymore service and taste falling off, Had a problem back few months ago w a pizza had waited to call til next day and got a cheeky manager who practically blamed me for the state of my pizza...needless to say I'll shop there less. Happy holidays.

There good is made fresh and it is delicious. The staff is friendly as is the delivery drivers. The kitchen, cooking and cleaning stations are very clean and the staff washes hands before handling food after waiting on a customer.
Very respectful crew.
Best pizza ever ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The best pizza in the valley

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good pizza and prices

Parking: Street parking in front of building or on the side of it is an open lot for parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always great food! The manager is always so great to work with and talk to. They donate a lot of time and food to the community. They really care about the city and especially the youth! You won't regret the taco pizza either. Its ones of a kind!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Club Salad, Pepperoni Roll, Taco Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza

Good pizza and prices

Parking: Street parking in front of building or on the side of it is an open lot for parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5