Very cute little locally owned shop. There are table games inside to play while you get a sweet treat. The house made chocolate chip cookies were really good, moist and chewy. Better than CRUMBL cookies. The affogato we had was also really good. We choose the coffee ice (would highly recommend yum!) And topped with a shot of espresso. They have bottled sodas you can make lots of different flavored floats with. I loved the interior. It felt very welcoming and had a cute outdoors indoors esthetic!
Megan Wheeler
Delicious cookies. Great customer service! Highly recommend.
Caleb Britton
Amazing service, homemade cookies paired with ice cream is unbeatable! This is not a chain, so come and support this amazing local business! I was not paid for this review, I am a highschool senior who fell in love with this shop.
Laura Phillips
Delicious! Also, wonderful gluten free options.
Sundos Abdoh
So delicious and fresh.
Angie Bender
I’ve only gotten to enjoy this little gem once, but next time I come through the area I will be back. The sweets are fresh and delicious, the service is spectacular, and the store has charm. Don’t change a thing!
Brielle Maynor
I feel so lucky that we have CincySammys close by!
Love the inventive weekly features, as well as the standby chocolate chip and confetti flavors. The cooler of specialty sodas is a nice touch. They also have locally produced dog treats to bring home to your pup!
Everything is super fresh and utterly delicious!
The owners are the loveliest family of local residents you could meet.
I have eaten in and ordered for pickup, as well as placed a large order for birthday treats. Service is always friendly and prompt.
Just go already! You’ll be glad you did!
Debra Braun
Best chocolate chip cookies! They are so good, I crave them & need to stop often 🤣
Joy Bennett
This is such a creative bakery! I love their themed cookies each week and that they offer gluten free desserts. My waistline wishes their cookies weren’t so good!
Michael Downs (Clay)
So glad to find this place! Very charming, tastes amazing, and such sociable staff!
Good dessert stop. Did not know what Cincy Sammy's was...just happened to talking to my wife about going out for ice cream and she knew about the place. Had driven by there many times and had no clue?
Love the concept of cookies with ice cream.. my wife and I share one Sammy . About 7.75 each.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jill P
A must go place! We drive over 15 mins to go! Always worth it!
Parking: Over 10 spots of free parking lot.
Kid-friendliness: Cute games and huge picnic tables! Outside seating is very nice too!!
Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking and direct access to store
Recommended dishes: Big a Stuffed Cookie, Ice Cream Sandwich
James Milliron (Jei)
I have a lot of food allergies including a wheat intolerance and they were so helpful with finding me not just one but two safe options to share with my partner. The gluten free cookies were soft and held up well as sandwiches. The flavors in both the cookies and the ice cream were delicious and it was nice to be able to enjoy something without having to worry about it. Definitely will be back if we come up this was again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Ames
Super friendly, took great care of me even though I was the last customer of the day and showed up near closing time. They had three different gluten free cookie options (chocolate chip, confetti, and Oreo flavored) and all but one of their ice creams were gluten free. I got an ice cream sandwich with the confetti cookie and strawberry ice cream and I got my partner an Oreo one with raspberry ice cream. Everything was delicious and it made for a perfect end to our day. Thanks for being so welcoming and making such good food!
Dietary restrictions: Lots of gluten free options and knowledgeable staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich
Tyler Bauer
This place rules, all of the cookies were so good but my favorite was the Tanner cookie. Also the sweetest staff ever! Thank you so much
Very cute little locally owned shop. There are table games inside to play while you get a sweet treat. The house made chocolate chip cookies were really good, moist and chewy. Better than CRUMBL cookies. The affogato we had was also really good. We choose the coffee ice (would highly recommend yum!) And topped with a shot of espresso. They have bottled sodas you can make lots of different flavored floats with. I loved the interior. It felt very welcoming and had a cute outdoors indoors esthetic!
Delicious cookies. Great customer service! Highly recommend.
Amazing service, homemade cookies paired with ice cream is unbeatable! This is not a chain, so come and support this amazing local business! I was not paid for this review, I am a highschool senior who fell in love with this shop.
Delicious! Also, wonderful gluten free options.
So delicious and fresh.
I’ve only gotten to enjoy this little gem once, but next time I come through the area I will be back. The sweets are fresh and delicious, the service is spectacular, and the store has charm. Don’t change a thing!
I feel so lucky that we have CincySammys close by!
Love the inventive weekly features, as well as the standby chocolate chip and confetti flavors. The cooler of specialty sodas is a nice touch. They also have locally produced dog treats to bring home to your pup!
Everything is super fresh and utterly delicious!
The owners are the loveliest family of local residents you could meet.
I have eaten in and ordered for pickup, as well as placed a large order for birthday treats. Service is always friendly and prompt.
Just go already! You’ll be glad you did!
Best chocolate chip cookies! They are so good, I crave them & need to stop often 🤣
This is such a creative bakery! I love their themed cookies each week and that they offer gluten free desserts. My waistline wishes their cookies weren’t so good!
So glad to find this place! Very charming, tastes amazing, and such sociable staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Big a Stuffed Cookie
Restaurantji Recommends
Good dessert stop. Did not know what Cincy Sammy's was...just happened to talking to my wife about going out for ice cream and she knew about the place. Had driven by there many times and had no clue?
Love the concept of cookies with ice cream.. my wife and I share one Sammy . About 7.75 each.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
A must go place! We drive over 15 mins to go! Always worth it!
Parking: Over 10 spots of free parking lot.
Kid-friendliness: Cute games and huge picnic tables! Outside seating is very nice too!!
Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking and direct access to store
Recommended dishes: Big a Stuffed Cookie, Ice Cream Sandwich
I have a lot of food allergies including a wheat intolerance and they were so helpful with finding me not just one but two safe options to share with my partner. The gluten free cookies were soft and held up well as sandwiches. The flavors in both the cookies and the ice cream were delicious and it was nice to be able to enjoy something without having to worry about it. Definitely will be back if we come up this was again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super friendly, took great care of me even though I was the last customer of the day and showed up near closing time. They had three different gluten free cookie options (chocolate chip, confetti, and Oreo flavored) and all but one of their ice creams were gluten free. I got an ice cream sandwich with the confetti cookie and strawberry ice cream and I got my partner an Oreo one with raspberry ice cream. Everything was delicious and it made for a perfect end to our day. Thanks for being so welcoming and making such good food!
Dietary restrictions: Lots of gluten free options and knowledgeable staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwich
This place rules, all of the cookies were so good but my favorite was the Tanner cookie. Also the sweetest staff ever! Thank you so much
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...