Cincy Sammys

119 Reading Rd, Mason
(513) 307-3314

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Sandwich
Create Your Own Sammy
Chocolate Ice Cream
Big a Stuffed Cookie
Scoop of Ice Cream
Dozen Cookies
GF Samson
Sundae

Menu

Featured items
4 Pack
Individual cookies are approximately 4" in diameter. Our cookies are mixed fresh daily in batches of only 3 dozen and hand scooped, the way you would at home...if you were good at baking cookies!
Shake
A 16 oz shake made from our hand dipped ice cream topped with whipped cream. Want to add some flavor? Two toppings for an additional charge.
Big A** Stuffed Cookie
More than a half-pound of cookie! These stuffed cookies rotate with a special flavor each week.
Half-Dozen Cookies
A half dozen cookies each approximately 4" in diameter. Our cookies are mixed fresh daily in batches of only 3 dozen and hand scooped, the way you would at home...if you were good at baking cookies!
Dozen Cookies
A dozen cookies each approximately 4" in diameter. Our cookies are mixed fresh daily in batches of only 3 dozen and hand scooped, the way you would at home...if you were good at baking cookies!

Cookies
4 Pack
Individual cookies are approximately 4" in diameter. Our cookies are mixed fresh daily in batches of only 3 dozen and hand scooped, the way you would at home...if you were good at baking cookies!
Half-Dozen Cookies
A half dozen cookies each approximately 4" in diameter. Our cookies are mixed fresh daily in batches of only 3 dozen and hand scooped, the way you would at home...if you were good at baking cookies!
Dozen Cookies
A dozen cookies each approximately 4" in diameter. Our cookies are mixed fresh daily in batches of only 3 dozen and hand scooped, the way you would at home...if you were good at baking cookies!

Our Sammys
Big A** Stuffed Cookie
More than a half-pound of cookie! These stuffed cookies rotate with a special flavor each week.
Create Your Own Sammy!
Create your own Sammy. It's like a tasty version of a DIY project!
Samson
Chocolate chip cookie, vanilla ice cream, fudge drizzle.
Charlie
Chocolate chip cookie, chocolate ice cream, peanut butter drizzle and crushed peanuts.
Gotcha Day
Confetti cookie, vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles.
GF Samson
Gluten free. Gluten friendly chocolate chip cookie, vanilla ice cream, fudge drizzle.

Ice Cream Treats
Shake
A 16 oz shake made from our hand dipped ice cream topped with whipped cream. Want to add some flavor? Two toppings for an additional charge.
Sundae
One of our small-batch cookies of your choice, paired with one of our eight ice cream options. As always, two toppings are on the house!
Scoop of Ice Cream
A hearty scoop of hard dipped ice cream, we'll even include 2 toppings!
Float
Root beer, coca cola, sunkist, or sprite with the ice cream of your choice!

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+18 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+17 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I love the idea but I probably wouldn't go out of my way to stop in here again. They had a great teacher theme for their cookies as I got a Mr Feeny. So the cookie are delicious yet slightly too rich for my daughter and me. I would still get one. The ice cream is slightly more icy than creamy for my taste. The price of $7.25 or $6.25 seems a bit steep for a scoop of ice cream and a cookie. I always like this idea but think it could be done for cheaper. I also would...
August 2025
Celebrated chocolate chip cookie day with the BEST!! We love love loved the chocolate chip cookie day box ranking them was such a fun date night. Thank you for recreating the classics ✌🏼 ❤️ 🍪
August 2025
First time here. We tried the peanut butter, chocolate chip and molasses tonight. The molasses was by far our favorite. We both found the peanut butter a little dry and the chocolate chip, while decadent, too much. But we look forward to trying the other ones we got tomorrow and will be back!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Quatman Cafe - 224 W Main St
Cafe, American, Soup, Beer Bar, Burgers
Tony's Corner Deli & Pizzeria - 216 W Main St
Pizza
Domino's Pizza - 311 Reading Rd
Pizza, Chicken Wings

Cincy Sammys

119 Reading Rd, Mason, OH 45040
(513) 307-3314