Papa Johns Pizza

5707 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights
(440) 461-1963

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Leslie Williams

Worst papa John's I've had. It's about the location clearly. It's like I got this food from a dumpster. My food it's cold and ugly.

Food: 1

Gm Blvd

We live 3 miles away and system says it is not in delivery zone. I called and get a call center . A freaking call center for local pizza.... Give address to her and she states there is no Papa Johns in my delivery zone. We wanted to try it but looks like we never will. No problem!

Suzanne Kisley

I would NEVER recommend going into, calling or ordering from THIS PAPA JOHNS! Whomever the manager is (MARY), she is extremely unprofessional and rude. My pizza is never correct, never cooked thoroughly and always late. I refuse to step foot in that location because of her and the employees that need to dress the part. What happened to this place? It used to be our go to and now I'd rather eat store bought pizza. They should really give out the corporate phone number so people can voice their opinion and actually be heard.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

J. Coz

Bunch of crabby women that hate their job. Food is never the same twice. Medium pizza in a large box.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Charlene Wallace

Pizza was terrible

Parking: Lot is shared with about 4 other business

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza

Salliese

This was my first time ordering from this location, and unfortunately, it will probably be my last. I placed an order for a pizza through the app and arrived with about 10 minutes left before it was supposed to be ready. I waited in my car until the app notified me that my order was complete.

When I went inside, the male associate at the counter was helping another customer and seemed visibly frustrated. He called the manager to take over and went back to making orders, but he did not wash his hands after handling the register and money.

A woman came in behind me, and the manager chose to address her after finishing with the previous customer, completely ignoring me even though I was next in line. After helping her, he finally asked for the name on my order. I told him, and he claimed it was still in the oven, despite the app stating it was ready. I waited patiently as he served three more people before the female associate noticed a box sitting on the counter and realized my order wasn’t in the oven at all.

The manager then began to make my order, also without washing his hands after handling money. I decided to cancel my order at that point. Not only was the service unorganized and frustrating, but the lack of cleanliness was also concerning.

While the prices at this location are better compared to others, the service and hygiene standards are definitely lacking. I’d rather drive a bit further for better service and consistent cleanliness.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

mehmet canli

I just came to get pizza, there was a middle-aged blonde lady who scolded me because I didn't know English, the employees next to her laughed at me, it made me very upset, be careful with your information, if you go, you may experience the same situation.

Andrew Barnes

Ordered $100 worth of pizzas guy at the shop was rude and pizzas did not get delivered. When I called back he put the phone down on me. Great service will use them again ?

Food: 1

Service: 1

Candy Owen

I had to deal with an automated selection to get to a person to place an order, then I couldn't hardly understand her, but I did eventually get the food. Who puts all the toppings in the center? Not happy Papa

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie

coleman2608

Terrible service. Waste of time. Pizzas are too expensive to be making them however they want.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Van

I forgot to take a picture.I really had a craving for pizza. My former favorite pizza came from Angela Mia's in Richmond Hts until they changed their pepperoni. It's now my least fave.Well, I can't call PJ'S my new fave, but it was very good. This was my 1st PJ pizza, and it won't be the last. I ordered the regular pepperoni stuffed crust pizza and an order of cheese sticks. The cheese sticks were straight trash ? but the pizza was just what I needed! The little pepper they placed in the box looked sun-dried, so it went straight to the garbage, but again, the pizza was great! Bottom line, I will definitely order pizza from here again and I will never order the cheese sticks again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheesesticks

JAY WHITE

My pizza taste like a Digiorno’s pizza!! Not good, doesn’t taste the same. I could’ve bought a frozen pizza!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Juan

Terrible service. Waste of time. Pizzas are too expensive to be making them however they want.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tish Tigz

Wow what trash! You literally can’t order online and you call their phone number and it disconnects! I guess they don’t want any

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Leon S Goatedy

Great prices and good pizza. ? not too greasy.

Loading...