Polly Anna's Tea Room-Effie's

1 S Main St, Milan
(419) 499-2491

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jasper3610

We stopped in for a quick breakfast. What a pleasant surprise. The food was delicious and very reasonably priced. The atmosphere was very “hometown.” Our server and our host were delightful. It would definitely be a must stop in the future.

F8122YOlaurac

Abbie is our new favorite server. The food was reasonably priced and very good! We shared the lunch special and had more than enough to eat We had some of the best pie there is anywhere. It is a few miles off the freeway, but well worth the trip.

Czaplicki

We grew up in Milan so love to return to this restaurant for fond memories. My husband had the meatloaf dinner. The salad.was impressive. I had the meat and cheese omelet. We left with enough food for another meal. Service was top notch.

KevinA_44857

Pie is amazing!!! Pull yourself up to the bar like a 50's dinner, or take a booth or table with the family. I ate there for lunch the other day and I couldn't say no to the mixed berry pie. It went well with the burger and fries. Perhaps an overkill for lunch, but oh well. It was worth it and affordable.

kmacandbt

Unassuming restaurant in the town square. We were welcomed with a friendly smile and hello as soon as we walked in. The service was excellent. The food was priced very reasonably, was delivered to our table fast and hot, and ot was delicious.

568jeffe

We went here for lunch after a hot morning at Summit Dragstrip. Arrived a little after Noon. The cafe was full but they were able to seat 5. Two of us had breakfast the others has sandwiches. The food was excellent. The service was outstanding. I would recommend this place to anyone coming to the birthplace of Edison (or Summit Motorsports Park).

Jennifer B

This is a cute little diner that you might just miss if you’re not paying attention.we ordered a wide variety of breakfast and everything was delicious! The portion sizes were generous and the prices made them a great value. I placed our order for pick up, and everything was ready when I arrived. To top it all off, they had excellent service!

O1065OBjasonw

Off the beaten path on the old town square of Milan. The restaurant appeared to be a local hangout. Thumbs up for the breakfast. Also just a couple of blocks from the birthplace of Thomas Edison .

Rustyiron1

A great little cafe with homemade food and plenty of it. Hand cut fries are great and a nice clean atmosphere. Prices reasonable for what you get. Defiantly will try to get back

juiceman2034

Big fan of their food. I come here way too often. Personally a big fan of trash hash or I also regularly order the breakfast sandwich. While I may agree with others that there really isn’t anything too unique about this place but that really doesn’t matter when the food is great. Support local.

Mark Wright

Beautiful cake for my wife's 40th Birthday. A real show-shopper for such a milestone day. Can't recommend enough!

RhondatheHonda

Cheap little diner in downtown Milan. For the price ur paying it’s totally worth it and has some of the best food in Milan. Quality restaurant that values there costumers with great service. Would recommend!

Andrea Greaves

Fabulous afternoon tea, gorgeous cakes and sandwiches. Definitely recommend x

Ash McGarry

I have now had various items from Pollyanna's most recently today with the boxes and can say every time the food has been beautiful. can't recommend enough. Thank you.

sanduskywiner

A must try, the portabella deep fried mushrooms. I'm not usually a fan, but these are tasty! Well worth the trip by itself. As long as you are there, check out the spicy trash potatoes a your mouth will be happy!

Loading...

Polly Anna's Tea Room-Effie's

1 S Main St, Milan, OH 44846
(419) 499-2491