I’m very picky about cheesecake. This is by far the best cheesecake I’ve ever had! Amazing! And love the variety!
Sharon Cox
Have eaten dessert here twice. Excellent cheesecakes but they sell out fast! Even tried their candied yam cheesecake which I didn't think it sounded appetizing but it was really delicious. They are very nice and friendly and come up with some different options so if you like to try different flavors I suggest you give them a try. Honestly I haven't tried any other dessert here but if they are as good as the cheesecakes it's sure worth the trip!!
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake
Jamie Schutte
Everyone is very friendly and the cheesecakes are amazing!
Erin Hogg
Update: I was kicked out of the Chowdown Cincinnati group for this review, even though I didn’t post anything negatively on their FB page. If this doesn’t tell you they are getting a kickback from restaurants and bakeries such as this, I don’t know what will. And I was kicked out before this “update” and my original review said nothing about kickbacks or anything so the bakery obviously reported it. As a business you need to take the good with the bad. I’ll never post a dishonest review, this is my honest opinion and I’ll stand behind it.
We tried this bakery after seeing a rave review on Chowdown Cincinnati. Unfortunately like others, we were fooled. There are so many other bakeries that are far superior with better, quality products. We tried their cream puffs and four different cupcakes. The cream puff shells were hard and the amount of whipped cream in them was overkill. We both took a couple bites and pushed it to the side. The cupcakes were also a huge disappointment. They tasted store bought and baked from a box. Kind of bland and just didn’t taste fresh at all. The icing was also unpleasant. Waste of a trip and money. Nothing special, you can get better cupcakes at your local grocery store.
Food: 1
Laura Fitzer-Wright
Absolutely amazing! I ordered three cheesecakes for my wedding. They were beautiful, perfect, and incredibly delicious. I drove 40 minutes to get there the day of my wedding because it was so worth it! Thank you for making my wedding extra special! This is the best cheesecake I have ever had.
Kayla Paytes
Tastes DELICIOUS. And the price is low for the great quality your getting.
mbb6180
The friendly faces inside were just the icing on the cake(if you will)! Highly recommend cheesecake selection and the occassional bourbon glazed bread pudding is phenominal! Will be back for sure! Thank you Holston Family!
Laura Yablonsky
Came in on a whim, and loved it! The staff were extremely friendly! Lots to choose from, cookies were amazing and I’ll definitely be back to try some cheesecakes. Highly recommend!
Christa Zeigler
Your cheesecakes are the best! Best texture, best flavor, just the best cheesecake I've ever had! I have tried several different ones, and I have loved everyone of them! So glad you are here in Milford! Please don't leave!
Ashley Wagner
Delicious cheesecake and wonderful customer service!
We got the edible cookie dough and a canolli. The cookie dough tasted rancid. Like something in it went bad. Could not even swallow a taste.
The canolli was better then the cookie dough. Was heavy on the cheese flavor and wouldn't get again but was edible.
Birdie Juarez
I dare you to find better cheesecake anywhere in Cincinnati. So many options, you can’t leave with just one. The baked goods and cupcakes/cookies are also delicious and you can taste that everything is handmade with REAL INGREDIENTS (the buttercream is clearly made with actual butter, it’s delicious). However the cheesecakes just can’t help but steal the spotlight, they are 100% the reason I come back time and time again. Just a lovely bakery all around with lovely helpful staff.
Jennifer Valentine
We stopped in and got a few different pieces of cheesecake. The Cadbury Egg cheesecake is phenomenal!!!!!
Christina Varnum
We ate next door and on a whim got dessert here. It all looks good. I hope the next time we stop they have macadamia cookies.
Jackie Gray
First time visiting tonight and received excellent customer service. We were greeted with warmth and appreciation! The treats were delicious as well! Great experience all around!
I’m very picky about cheesecake. This is by far the best cheesecake I’ve ever had! Amazing! And love the variety!
Have eaten dessert here twice. Excellent cheesecakes but they sell out fast! Even tried their candied yam cheesecake which I didn't think it sounded appetizing but it was really delicious. They are very nice and friendly and come up with some different options so if you like to try different flavors I suggest you give them a try. Honestly I haven't tried any other dessert here but if they are as good as the cheesecakes it's sure worth the trip!!
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake
Everyone is very friendly and the cheesecakes are amazing!
Update: I was kicked out of the Chowdown Cincinnati group for this review, even though I didn’t post anything negatively on their FB page. If this doesn’t tell you they are getting a kickback from restaurants and bakeries such as this, I don’t know what will. And I was kicked out before this “update” and my original review said nothing about kickbacks or anything so the bakery obviously reported it. As a business you need to take the good with the bad. I’ll never post a dishonest review, this is my honest opinion and I’ll stand behind it.
We tried this bakery after seeing a rave review on Chowdown Cincinnati. Unfortunately like others, we were fooled. There are so many other bakeries that are far superior with better, quality products. We tried their cream puffs and four different cupcakes. The cream puff shells were hard and the amount of whipped cream in them was overkill. We both took a couple bites and pushed it to the side. The cupcakes were also a huge disappointment. They tasted store bought and baked from a box. Kind of bland and just didn’t taste fresh at all. The icing was also unpleasant. Waste of a trip and money. Nothing special, you can get better cupcakes at your local grocery store.
Food: 1
Absolutely amazing! I ordered three cheesecakes for my wedding. They were beautiful, perfect, and incredibly delicious. I drove 40 minutes to get there the day of my wedding because it was so worth it! Thank you for making my wedding extra special! This is the best cheesecake I have ever had.
Tastes DELICIOUS. And the price is low for the great quality your getting.
The friendly faces inside were just the icing on the cake(if you will)! Highly recommend cheesecake selection and the occassional bourbon glazed bread pudding is phenominal! Will be back for sure! Thank you Holston Family!
Came in on a whim, and loved it! The staff were extremely friendly! Lots to choose from, cookies were amazing and I’ll definitely be back to try some cheesecakes. Highly recommend!
Your cheesecakes are the best! Best texture, best flavor, just the best cheesecake I've ever had! I have tried several different ones, and I have loved everyone of them! So glad you are here in Milford! Please don't leave!
Delicious cheesecake and wonderful customer service!
Restaurantji Recommends
We got the edible cookie dough and a canolli. The cookie dough tasted rancid. Like something in it went bad. Could not even swallow a taste.
The canolli was better then the cookie dough. Was heavy on the cheese flavor and wouldn't get again but was edible.
I dare you to find better cheesecake anywhere in Cincinnati. So many options, you can’t leave with just one. The baked goods and cupcakes/cookies are also delicious and you can taste that everything is handmade with REAL INGREDIENTS (the buttercream is clearly made with actual butter, it’s delicious). However the cheesecakes just can’t help but steal the spotlight, they are 100% the reason I come back time and time again. Just a lovely bakery all around with lovely helpful staff.
We stopped in and got a few different pieces of cheesecake. The Cadbury Egg cheesecake is phenomenal!!!!!
We ate next door and on a whim got dessert here. It all looks good. I hope the next time we stop they have macadamia cookies.
First time visiting tonight and received excellent customer service. We were greeted with warmth and appreciation! The treats were delicious as well! Great experience all around!
Loading...