Karen's Bakery and Custom Cakes

Karen and her bakery deserve more than 5 stars. This little shop offers the dreamiest, creamiest treats. The cakes are unbelievably moist and flavorful. The decorating is delightful. The Saturday donuts are fantastic. And her signature Devil Dogs are just too good to be true. Worth the drive to Millersport alone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen made a 50th Anniversary cake for my parents. It was absolutely beautiful and tasted amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Boston cream donut is way better then Tim hortons and my daughter graduation cake was so delicious everyone wanted a fourth plate of it plus she is very sweet n nice n the store is clean and she just welcomes u when u walk in n very well manners i will just order my cakes at Karen’s bakery &custom cakes it’s way better then walmart and Krogers

I ordered a small buckeye cake, and it was very good! And Karen is a really nice lady!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and n I went in to try her baked good fresh.We have them as she delivers to our Post.I had my first ever cream puff and it was amazing! Husband has a berry scone.He said it was the moistest scone he has ever had

What a treasure! Gorgeous and tasty treats. The Devil Dogs are heavenly!

One word: Yum.
First visit. We had the carrot cupcake, a chocolate chip cookie and an apple turnover. Everything was good. I thought the cookie a bit rich. Hub loved it. Cupcake was really moist. Karen is super friendly. We will visit again next time we're in the area!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen and Debbie are the best!

you and Debbie do such wonderful decorating on the cakes and cookies.... as well as being delicious! I hope to get back to your bakery soon for some frosted sugar cookies!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wonderfully delicious desserts and fantastic customer service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Highly amazing work! I ordered a half sheet cake, half chocolate and half white. Art work and frosting were beautiful! I ordered her duck and fish shaped cookies for the kids! The kids loved them. Amazing decorating skills on the cookies and they were delicious. This will definitely be our go to bakery!

Karen has worked her magic on 5 birthday cakes for us. She’s wonderful!! They’re as tasty as they are pretty!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cream Puff, Chocolate Cake with Whipped Icing

Yummy!! Last minute I called to check the chances of any cake being available, there was and it was beautiful and delicious! Highly recommend ?

Ordered my mom’s birthday cake from here last fall and it came out perfect ! (Wish I’d have got a better pic)Completely forgot to leave a review until now because I was googling the number to order from them again .

Beautiful work and quick turnaround.