Mellow Mushroom New Albany
260 Market St Ste A, New Albany
(614) 245-4234
Customers' Favorites
Spinach Artichoke Dip
GF Kosmic Karma Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
Holy Shiitake Pie
BBQ Chicken Pizza
The Marley Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Pretzel Bites
Craft Beer
Bruschetta
Menu
Photos
+77 photos
+76 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This was our first visit and they made a minor mistake on our order. However, they definitely earned the five stars because the server caught it before it even got to our table, the manager fixed it immediately and apologized, and the food was excellent. We think we’ve found our new favorite pizza place.
Mellow mushroom is a great pizza shop. I am not a fan of thick crust pizza, but their thick crust pizza tasted impressive. The crust was topped with decent mozzarella. The red pepper and cream cheese improved the taste. There were many classic dishes and beverages in the menu. It could have more innovative and special dishes.
The vibe on game day was great. Service was excellent and WiFi was available. The dining room was filled with many lovely decorations. Definitely...
The vibe on game day was great. Service was excellent and WiFi was available. The dining room was filled with many lovely decorations. Definitely...
The decor and the ambiance in here is super cool and so much fun and groovy! The menu is not huge, but it has plenty of options. Four of us came in here, and three had pizzas and one got the new pepperoni rolls (which she said were delicious)! We all thought our pizzas were good. I don't quite understand the crust though. You can get thin crust or hand tossed. I got the thin crust, and it was exactly the same size and thickness as hand tossed. I'm not a crust fan, so...
You May Also Like
Peace Love Juice - 260 Market St suite b
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Hudson 29 Kitchen + Drink - 260 Market St D
![]()
Bar, American, Vegetarian
Johnson's Real Ice Cream, New Albany - 160 W Main St
![]()
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream