Cake Creations

11983 W National Rd, New Carlisle
(937) 845-9710

Recent Reviews

Sort by
tracey fisher

This is my go to place for cakes as well as cupcakes such a Great place to pop into for a treat anytime 😊 with so many options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Helen Roth

I was quite impressed that they were able to make old fashioned white icing (using almond extract) I am 63 yrs old and was ordering a cake for an 85 year old friend of mine. We were just wishing they made bakery cakes like they used to...They said YES! Not only was the cake wonderfully moist & delicious but the ICING was even better than either of us could recall!
There was a very nice selection of cookies and cakes to carry out! I bought myself a cotton candy cupcake for breakfast! What an awesome start to a Blessed Day

Amanda Panda Perkins

We used them for our wedding back in October 2024 and was absolutely delicious! We did a small round cake and cupcakes and was a huge hit, amazingly priced and seriously the best cake and cupcakes I've ever had! 100000% recommend them!

Charles Pytel

Bought a birthday cake for my wife last Friday. Staff was friendly, the cake was beautifully decorated and it was delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lynda Truman

Very friendly staff and wonderful cookies, cupcakes, & cakes.

Emmett Jarvis II

Great food, great selection, good prices, and extremely friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cupcake, Cookie

Amanda Collins

Best cakes and bakery around. Our family always order specialty cakes we need from them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Katrina Richards

Cake creations for the score again! 24 hours before my sons birthday party I realized I hadn't gotten arrangements done for a cake yet. Well I called cake creations and in less than 24 hours these wonderful people put out the cake my son absolutely loved. Cake is always yummy service is always fabulous and timing was impeccable. Grateful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dawn

I own my own cleaning business so when I have clients this direction I always pass this place, So today I decided to see what it's all about and let me tell you the cupcakes ? I purchased were delicious and the lady that waited on me was so nice and welcoming!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cupcake

Janet Woodyard

An absolutely adorable bakery!! Their Strawberry Cream cupcake was so amazing and their Cranberry Oatmeal cookies were so so good!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rene Warner

It is my opinion that when someone is looking to celebrate a once in a lifetime event, they should support an establishment that will set with you and show you just exactly what you are going to get for your money. I did not get what I was expecting nor did it compare to what I have gotten elsewhere. I asked for a white cake with white icing." Like a wedding cake" I said. The cupcakes( 24 also on the order) tasted fine, but guests stated that the cake was heavy with almond flavor. The cupcakes were not. Cake Creations said it was the same batter for the cake as well as the cupcakes . Clearly, they tasted differently. I have seen, bought, and eaten white cakes with WHITE buttercream icing many times in my life and this is the very first time the white buttercream icing was yellow. When asked (per phone conversation) why didn't you say it wasn't what you wanted when you came to pick up? " I answered "my daughter(was with me) paid for it because she wanted to support a small business instead of a big box store or chain" "I was not about to break her heart" and mind you, this was one hour before close on Saturday. Our celebration was the next day. They are closed on Sunday. And it was paid for long before it was made. I am 100% certain that my daughter's money would not be returned. And there was no time to remake the cake even if they cared. I don't expect to have a 75th celebration, but if I do, my cake will come from a supermarket where they have a customer satisfaction policy.
On the phone, I could hear the baker saying "you go ahead and give a review I don't care" it was made very clear to me that I (the customer) was wrong... end of discussion.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dawn Gunsauley

First time customer!!!Bought a birthday cake from here today and that has to be the most delicious cake I have had in a long time. I have to say that Mama Miss Nancy loved it as well. Thank you for the beautiful cake and helping make her 76th as wonderful as she is. We will for sure be ordering again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ernie Hardin

Great tasting cakes. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tausha Metz

Place is great sooo many options!!

Jeremiah Kelly

Great little bakery! And definitely budget friendly! Would recommend for sure!!!

Parking: There are a few parking spots but also a gravel lot next to parking with a little additional parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cupcake, Mixed Cupcakes Peanut Butter Red Velvet Reeses Lots of Choices When You Go In

Loading...