Cake Creations

11983 W National Rd, New Carlisle
(937) 845-9710

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Mixed Cupcakes Peanut Butter Red Velvet Reeses Lots of Choices When You Go In

1 4 Chocolate Sheet Cake with Whipped Icing

Hand Made Power Ranger Birthday Cake

The Bomb Apple Fritter

Chocolate Cupcake

Photos

+28 photos

+27 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Recent Reviews

Out of town of New Carlise just a bit. Farm and event location. Bakery has a selection of other treats. Specialty Cupcakes ready for selection and cake ordering available. Good cake and specialty cupcakes 🧁

September 2025

I was quite impressed that they were able to make old fashioned white icing (using almond extract) I am 63 yrs old and was ordering a cake for an 85 year old friend of mine. We were just wishing they made bakery cakes like they used to...They said YES! Not only was the cake wonderfully moist & delicious but the ICING was even better than either of us could recall!
There was a very nice selection of cookies and cakes to carry out! I bought myself a cotton candy cupcake...

January 2025

We used them for our wedding back in October 2024 and was absolutely delicious! We did a small round cake and cupcakes and was a huge hit, amazingly priced and seriously the best cake and cupcakes I've ever had! 100000% recommend them!

January 2025

More Reviews