Cake Creations

11983 W National Rd, New Carlisle
(937) 845-9710

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Mixed Cupcakes Peanut Butter Red Velvet Reeses Lots of Choices When You Go In

1 4 Chocolate Sheet Cake with Whipped Icing

Hand Made Power Ranger Birthday Cake

The Bomb Apple Fritter

Chocolate Cupcake

Photos

+21 photos

+20 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Recent Reviews

I was quite impressed that they were able to make old fashioned white icing (using almond extract) I am 63 yrs old and was ordering a cake for an 85 year old friend of mine. We were just wishing they made bakery cakes like they used to...They said YES! Not only was the cake wonderfully moist & delicious but the ICING was even better than either of us could recall!
There was a very nice selection of cookies and cakes to carry out! I bought myself a cotton candy cupcake...

January 2025

We used them for our wedding back in October 2024 and was absolutely delicious! We did a small round cake and cupcakes and was a huge hit, amazingly priced and seriously the best cake and cupcakes I've ever had! 100000% recommend them!

January 2025

Cake creations for the score again! 24 hours before my sons birthday party I realized I hadn't gotten arrangements done for a cake yet. Well I called cake creations and in less than 24 hours these wonderful people put out the cake my son absolutely loved. Cake is always yummy service is always fabulous and timing was impeccable. Grateful!

September 2024

More Reviews