Carmelas Pizzeria
2015 S Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle
(937) 849-1112
Recent Reviews
Sort by
2015 S Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle
(937) 849-1112
Tried it again after a couple year break. Still not good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Very gross pizza. Soggy, wet, and overall just not good. Zero crisp. Just bad.
Food: 1
ELITE service from bartenders and servers. The special extra care taken by Savannah for a comment I made was insane and so caring. Take care of your people there you have bad ass ones. Gang gang.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not a fan of the pizza
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
website menu pricings must be old, charged different when calling in order. rude employee when we tried to asked questions ⁉️. okay food, great ranch! but overpriced, long delivery times
Pizza was alright. Service was good.
Good locAtion off Rte 235 ample parking West side Park Layne area .
Big fan of the pizza one of my top 3 lately
Amazing subs and pizza.
I walked into this restaurant and it felt like very old school atmosphere very quaint had good music playing on the jukebox just a very nice atmosphere when you walk into this place
Restaurantji Recommends
Service is great the food needs improved
Good food and less expensive than I thought it would be. On second visit was at bar very friendly was not busy cuz it was late sat with most of employees and they are so much fun.
If it was possible to give negative starts I would do that. We used to be regulars there for years and have t been back we went tonight and it was absolutely awful… my tea tasted like literal mildew and we ordered nachos as an appetizer 40 minutes later they come out and tell us they don’t have meat for them. Then they come back and say they don’t have chips, waiters super rude kitchen manager was even worse. They need to just close the doors and start over completely… over all super dirty rude and id say bar rescue might even have hard time bringing this place back.
The food was amazing!!! This was our first time ordering other food besides pizza. We got 2 of the chicken tender meals and they was very good portion size. We also got the wings and chef salad and a Philly steak sub. The Philly cheesesteak sub was amazing!!!! Great food for the price!!! We will definitely order from there again!!!
Honestly the pizza bar for the price is mine blowing was super impressed
Loading...