Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe

I go 1-2x weekly now that I’m in school to start my studying with a coffee and maybe a meal or treat. I got the Banana Pudding Latte over ice and the B.E.L.T. Panini for breakfast. I will 100% recommend these over and over again! The coffee is an acquired taste I thought I wouldn’t like, but I’ve gotten it 3 weeks in a row now! Highly recommend this place!

I don't know how they squeeze 5 to 7 people behind thr counter and yet get so much done, but they do!! I don't get out to New Carlisle too often but when I do I'll make sure I stop in. The no-bake cookies are legit. Each cookie probably weighs half a pound and they taste fantastic. The vibe check here is good.

Great coffee and great food. The staff was friendly and inviting.

The staff was fast, friendly, and efficient. I had a special request since I was in a hurry and Nikki accommodated me nicely. Both Ollie and Sky were talkative and engaging.

My best friend brought me here when I came to visit and I fell in love. Now that I have moved here, we go at least once a week, sometimes more.

Omg!!! Hidden gem!!!! This restaurant was recommended by a friend. So I had to check it out. Zero complaints! Excellent food. Excellent atmosphere. Excellent service! I will be going back!!!

Fantastic little spot in the downtown strip in New Carlisle.

The sandwiches are hand prepared with fresh ingredients. They don't skimp & the combinations are Fantastic.

Daily Soups / Drink Specials.

Usually a seasonally themed beverage or two available.

Order To-Go or enjoy the atmosphere of the in house Art Galley (most of the art work is for sale)

Gives a very similar vibe to what I'm use to in Downtown Tipp City.

Very classy place with plenty of parking in the rear.

Would highly recommend as a morning spot of you're a coffee advocate!

I look forward to every month with new seasonal flavors and food! Hands down the best place for coffee and food

Love Penny Lane! I've been enjoying coming here for years and am so glad that such a great coffee shop and cafe is in my hometown.

Cute little spot for a quick bite and some coffee. Downtown location is a little busy and parking was kinda stressful but worth it! So nice for a small town place with gluten free options as well.

Poor management skills. I inquired about an art peice, and was ignored.

Came here on a mildly busy Saturday during lunch hours for some coffee. I got a caramel latte and some others got a flight. The cafe is of a decent size with a nice artsy atmosphere, but it can get rather loud with the crowd. Service is good with friendly staff. Many unique and seasonal flavors to choose from including a tasting flight. Although for my taste, the coffee tends to be on the sweeter side, somewhat overpowering the espresso. Recommend if you are looking for a place to have some fun chatting and trying out flavors, rather than the quality of the coffee itself.

Wonderful little place.

Truly a gem! The atmosphere is incredibly delightful and chill, making it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal. The food was absolutely delicious with plenty of options to satisfy every craving. And let’s not forget about the coffee menu – it was chef’s kiss! Great balance of coffee and flavors. This place exceeded all of my expectations in terms of atmosphere, food, and friendly customer service. My only regret is not having come here sooner. I’m already looking forward to my next visit!

Great sandwiches all with their own unique twist. Pastries were incredible