Smitty's Tavern

55 N Main St, New Holland
(740) 495-5928

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dingle Dangle Ding Dong

Smitty's is a very friendly neighborhood bar & tavern in New Holland, Ohio. We are a small Village located on the border of Pickaway County & Fayette County. Smitty's did a 50/50 drawing for our upcoming 'COPS & KIDS Fishing' event to be held at the Village Park & Pond July 19th. Raised a nice chunk of change for the kids. Shout out & THANKS to Sabrina Colburn! What a nice lady. Smitty's is an integral part of our small community & they put on fundraisers for charity all the time. GREAT folks!!! Recommended AAA+++

Mark Bellamy

Smitty's is a very friendly neighborhood bar & tavern in New Holland, Ohio. We are a small Village located on the border of Pickaway County & Fayette County. Smitty's did a 50/50 drawing for our upcoming 'COPS & KIDS Fishing' event to be held at the Village Park & Pond July 19th. Raised a nice chunk of change for the kids. Shout out & THANKS to Sabrina Colburn! What a nice lady. Smitty's is an integral part of our small community & they put on fundraisers for charity all the time. GREAT folks!!! Recommended AAA+++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Looney Tune

Had the cat extra crispy and a couple of kitten nuggets was delish

Linda Muck

Heard from Cat rescues who want to help some strays the bar owner is threatening to kill the cats. Authorities have been notified. DONT support inhumane business owners. It is against the law to hurt a companion animal per Ohio Humane laws.

Atmosphere: 1

Free Guy

Keep hurting cats and see what happens.

Service: 1

Kl Mystic

⚠️ WARNING LISTEN UP the owner harm's kittens and cats I'm talking NEWBORN kittens let me find out who you are lady ?. DO NOT do business with them!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Brit J

The owner threw rocks at defenseless feral cats and kittens for doing their business on the patio. She didn't stop there; she threatened to kill them! Maybe instead of reacting to nature with violence, she could look into community resources to ask for help. Kindness and humanity are free!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Victoria Adams

Some taverns would welcome patio cats. This bar owner wants to kill them instead of doing a single thing to shelter them or find a home. Pathetic.

Steve Clarkson

Always good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Abel

Great place to have a great time .. Owners are top notch people ... Awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Matthew Warner

Small menu but nice small town watering hole.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Rachel Imler

Love this place!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Karl Butts

Great place good people

David Seitz

Awesome place

Terry Haughn

Home town dive that has great bar tender! She's the cook also!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...