Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly
145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia
(330) 343-1188
Customers' Favorites
Vinaigrette House Salad with Sour Dressings
Sweet House Salad with Sour Dressings
Meat Cheese gr Pepper & Mushrooms
Splash Meatball Sub with Cheese
Meat Cheese gr Pepper Pizza Sub
Meat & Cheese Pizza Sub
Meat Cheese & Mushrooms
Breadsticks with Cheese
Cheese & Green Peppers
Cheese Mushroom
Menu
Photos
+6 photos
+5 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Food was quick, delicious, and unique. The sauce is flavorful with a delightfully crunchy thick crust, the ingredients seemed fresh, and the cheddar cheese really did make it. I'm so glad we didn't ask if they had mozzarella. Staff was nice, service was quick, and this is clearly a popular place, because they had a steady stream of customers while we waited for our pizza, and it wasn't too long before closing.
I live in Cincinnati now, and have for 25 years. I was very pleasantly surprised to find the sauce tasted exactly the same as it did when I was growing up! The staff were also very pleasant! The food was STILL amazing 💝
This is still one of my favorite pizza places to frequent even after not living in New Philadelphia for almost 20 years.Cash or check only. Every pizza establishment I’ve been to with those options have been top tier good and Mary Zifer’s is in the the top tier of that top tier. I miss it already!
You May Also Like
What's Cooking Cafe - 139 2nd St NW
![]()
American, Bakery, Coffee & Tea, Gluten-Free, Cafe
Daily Grind Cafe - 153 W High Ave
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea
Ace nutrition - 127 W High Ave
![]()
Health Food, Nutritionists, Social Clubs, Specialty Food, Bubble Tea