Fetter's Dairy Isle
471 W Church St, Newark
(740) 328-8713
Customers' Favorites
Oreo Disaster
Banana Split
Strawberry
Onion Rings
Hamburger
Twister
Brownie
Sundae
Coney
Fries
Menu
Photos
+27 photos
+26 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Love it. I went in there after ball practice with my grandson's ordered food and didn't realize I only had 100 bill. They couldn't brake. The girl Alexa I think her name was said don't worry about it she got it. She was the most polite and kind person I couldn't believe she did that. The boys was so happy. I just want to tell her thanks again. I went and broke the bill and brought her money back she said I didn't have to do that but I know she will...
Ice cream and fries were good. Coney does not include cheese for $5. Picture shows the 3 onion rings for $4.50 they serve. Next to the bucket of fries that we half ate in the photo for $4.90 this is a blatant rip off. Service was not at all apologetic when I asked if it was correct. Not sure if I’ll be going back.
I got 2 hot fudge cake no whip cream they put nuts on them they remade them the girls were nice and got a small coke and small ice water I had to go back in to get a butter finger twist they were out of that but I asked them about my first order being to high and they changed 3.00 for a ice water I said what for ice water I said was it bottled they said no I said do you have a manager they said no I can't tell no one
You May Also Like
The Newark Hub - 370 W Church St
![]()
Venues & Event Spaces, Pool Halls, Bar & Grill, Bar
Don & Sue's Pizza - 645 W Church St
![]()
Pizza, Salad, Chicken Wings