Fetter's Dairy Isle
471 W Church St, Newark
(740) 328-8713
Customers' Favorites
Oreo Disaster
Banana Split
Strawberry
Onion Rings
Hamburger
Twister
Brownie
Sundae
Coney
Fries
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I got 2 hot fudge cake no whip cream they put nuts on them they remade them the girls were nice and got a small coke and small ice water I had to go back in to get a butter finger twist they were out of that but I asked them about my first order being to high and they changed 3.00 for a ice water I said what for ice water I said was it bottled they said no I said do you have a manager they said no I can't tell no one
The day we were there the lobby where you order was completely full and there was only one person working. They quit making my wife's favorite a Sunday cone which I understand that most people don't even know what it is. And the lobby was really dirty I hope the rest of it wasn't. I've been going there for 40 plus years to that location whether he this is the original owner or not. Great location. Right by the ball field. Right across from the Y. There is no...
Best place to go in the summer for ice cream treats and coneys. Unfortunately, just like everything else, their prices are going up. It's not really a cheap place to go anymore for a meal of milkshakes, coneys and mushrooms. ?
You May Also Like
The Newark Hub - 370 W Church St
![]()
Venues & Event Spaces, Pool Halls, Bar & Grill, Bar
Don & Sue's Pizza - 645 W Church St
![]()
Pizza, Salad, Chicken Wings
Bummie's On Main - 400 W Main St
![]()
Pubs, American, Burgers, Pizza