My wife got a hollow. Some got they managed to get the ice cream on the brim of the cone. I was delighted when I got my twister. I said to myself wow... They really put a lot of butterfinger in this thing!! Turns out they only blended the top 1/4 and the rest was just vanilla ice cream
Shana Blackstone
Every time I come here we are standing around forever for our order not only are we paying double the prices now but kids that work there are gonna screw around while we’ve been standing outside for 40 minutes waiting on our food and they said oh I’m sorry they must not have made your order while they called everybody else’s name out that had not even been there that long But I guess them screwing around at work is more important than the people that are actually waiting for their orders
Tyson Sparks
The only place in town that serves true coney dogs, not chili dogs. Love this little place.
3pune3 Corey
Used to be better
Christelin Hursey
Apparently they close the kitchen down an hour and a half before the actual closing time...unless you're friends with one of the girls working there. I couldn't get a shredded chicken sandwich at 7:15 with a 9pm closing time but the young girl that ordered while I was waiting on my shake got her chicken sandwich. I guess it's all about who you know.
Service: 1
Fred Fuchs
I remember stopping here when I was maybe 4 or 5 years old. On our way back from Buckeye Lake. Great Ice Cream and
Every time I have been there it was great. Perfect cheeseburgers and we love our "fair fries" as we call them. Some vinegar and ketchup reminds me of our county fairs back in the day down south. The ice cream is great and worth the price.
Sherri Lansing
Love this place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge Cake, Coney
Jay Catron
One of my favorite places in Newark and one of the reasons I'm glad we moved here last year. Affordable, friendly service and close to my home. Always better than the big chains!
0/10 for service. My family and I showed up Saturday night, 5/11/24, to get ice cream. My husband grew up in Newark and wanted to show our kids his favorite ice cream place. Coming from 45 mins away we got there at 8:58pm. Thinking they would be open longer than 9pm on a Saturday we didn’t check time (that’s our fault). When we got there and saw the sign my husband got out and asked the blonde worker if they were still taking orders she said yes so we got out of the car. We approached the window and the brunette worker said..AND I QUOTE “we close in 2 minutes, get what you’re gonna get and go”. I was in awe of the fact she said it and turned to my husband and told him “no, we are leaving”. I understand it was closing time, but we specifically asked if it was ok and was told yes. The uncalled and rude comment was not needed. He wanted to show his kids his favorite childhood place.We will not be returning.
Service: 1
Liz Love
Best ice cream in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerome Gillett
Everything was great except the flavor of the purple cow ice cream. The original purple cow was blackberry with chunks of chocolate in it, not grape. Other than that, they have some of the best ice cream around. Service was awesome as well as the atmosphere. Good job Dairy Isle!
Kid-friendliness: They are very kid friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge Cake, Onion Rings, Banana Split
Phantom 87
Great ice cream for the price. Food is similar to fair food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
elaina myers
Y’all need to change your hours on here if they aren’t correct. Showed up at 8:50 and they where closed but on here it said 10.
Food is good but the coney sauce is always cold.
My wife got a hollow. Some got they managed to get the ice cream on the brim of the cone. I was delighted when I got my twister. I said to myself wow... They really put a lot of butterfinger in this thing!! Turns out they only blended the top 1/4 and the rest was just vanilla ice cream
Every time I come here we are standing around forever for our order not only are we paying double the prices now but kids that work there are gonna screw around while we’ve been standing outside for 40 minutes waiting on our food and they said oh I’m sorry they must not have made your order while they called everybody else’s name out that had not even been there that long But I guess them screwing around at work is more important than the people that are actually waiting for their orders
The only place in town that serves true coney dogs, not chili dogs. Love this little place.
Used to be better
Apparently they close the kitchen down an hour and a half before the actual closing time...unless you're friends with one of the girls working there. I couldn't get a shredded chicken sandwich at 7:15 with a 9pm closing time but the young girl that ordered while I was waiting on my shake got her chicken sandwich. I guess it's all about who you know.
Service: 1
I remember stopping here when I was maybe 4 or 5 years old. On our way back from Buckeye Lake.
Great Ice Cream and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Pickles, Footlong Coney Dog, Strawberry Shortcake, Reeses Sundae, Hot Fudge Cake, Onion Rings, Banana Split, Papa Smurf Ice Cream Cone, Coney
Every time I have been there it was great. Perfect cheeseburgers and we love our "fair fries" as we call them. Some vinegar and ketchup reminds me of our county fairs back in the day down south. The ice cream is great and worth the price.
Love this place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge Cake, Coney
One of my favorite places in Newark and one of the reasons I'm glad we moved here last year. Affordable, friendly service and close to my home. Always better than the big chains!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
0/10 for service. My family and I showed up Saturday night, 5/11/24, to get ice cream. My husband grew up in Newark and wanted to show our kids his favorite ice cream place. Coming from 45 mins away we got there at 8:58pm. Thinking they would be open longer than 9pm on a Saturday we didn’t check time (that’s our fault). When we got there and saw the sign my husband got out and asked the blonde worker if they were still taking orders she said yes so we got out of the car. We approached the window and the brunette worker said..AND I QUOTE “we close in 2 minutes, get what you’re gonna get and go”. I was in awe of the fact she said it and turned to my husband and told him “no, we are leaving”. I understand it was closing time, but we specifically asked if it was ok and was told yes. The uncalled and rude comment was not needed. He wanted to show his kids his favorite childhood place.We will not be returning.
Service: 1
Best ice cream in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was great except the flavor of the purple cow ice cream. The original purple cow was blackberry with chunks of chocolate in it, not grape. Other than that, they have some of the best ice cream around. Service was awesome as well as the atmosphere. Good job Dairy Isle!
Kid-friendliness: They are very kid friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge Cake, Onion Rings, Banana Split
Great ice cream for the price. Food is similar to fair food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Y’all need to change your hours on here if they aren’t correct. Showed up at 8:50 and they where closed but on here it said 10.
Loading...