I was watching my son play baseball at the park next door and decided to order a pizza for me and the kids. We got the deep dish pizza pie, and I’m really impressed. First bite had a nice crunch to the soft outer crust followed by a slightly sweet sauce that immediately gave way to the salty garlic cheese sprinkle on top, and then the cheese and sausage and especially the bacon (nice chunks) rounded it off. This is great! I’ve had so many deep dishes in Chicago, and I wouldn’t call it one of those. This is a great pizza pie experience, though, and I wouldn’t call order a side of sauce to dip the edge crust, which is almost like focaccia. I’m telling you…this is on point, and I highly recommend it. And I called this $1-$10 per person because, even though I winced at the $29.99 price tag, it fed me and 4 of my kids.
Greg Eikenberry
The Robbo pizza is amazing!! As was the sausage! And the deluxe was just That. Phenomenal
Jennifer McCormick
Always a Friendly Place and excellent Pizza especially the Chicago deep dish 😋
D H
Best pizza in Licking Valley hands down.
Nicole C
Love this place and employees are amazing. They have local honey for sale which is delicious . I’ll always come back for their food and service which is to die for
Hailey Hofacker
The best pizza in the world in my opinion fluffy but crisp crust! The best pizza sauce ever! Perfect amount of cheese and they don’t skimp on the toppings! You have to try the garlic parmesan crust! I couldn’t Recommend Panther Pizza enough! My go to order is a traditional crust pizza with garlic parmesan crust, extra pizza sauce, pepperoni, bacon, and hot honey! And you have to try their BLT Stromboli at least once it’s heavenly!
Pam Bukala
Why do you even put a choice of how you want your pizza cut? The last 4 times we have ordered pizza, we have asked for pie cut. It comes square cut! You offer to make a new one but at that point we don’t care to wait any longer for our food.
Charles Kirkpatrick
Wonderful place. I especially love it for the flavor of their dough. Perfectly salted. Pizzas are fantastic but I warn you I haven't ventured away from a simple pepperoni and cheese. The Stromboli's are amazing - sausage specifically. Take some time and try their desserts as well. I went with the blueberry cheesecake and it was just what I needed!
Jennifer Trusdale
I love this place but it’s the most expensive pizza shop around! I’ve decided to stop going because the last 3 times they’ve messed up my order. This past time my BLT chicken salad had 4 pieces of chicken. We realized that my daughters 14 year old classmates work there so I’m assuming that’s why orders are getting messed up
AVon
I live in Newark and this has become my favorite pizza place! My boyfriend I get a thin garlic crust pizza with pepperoni, sausage, pineapple and jalapeno. Yumm! Every once in a while we will get just a classic pepp pizza, and they are just as delightful.
Heard from a friend that the deep dish is legit. Will definitely have to give it a try. As well as those desserts I always see while checking out. :)
Delicious. I live pretty far away so I rarely get Panther Pizza. Had a pepperoni pizza and a deluxe pizza tonight. Both were perfect. I sat and waited on my pizza and they brought out a full pizza as a sample. It was also excellent. The owner and employees were all very nice even though they were extremely busy. Can’t wait to try something else next time.
Scott Freese
Panther pizza was a charming little eat in pizza shop. We had just come off the licking river and we’re hungry. The pizza was very good !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Van
New to the area so trying all the local spots. All I can say is, "Wow!" I ordered the Margarite. The pesto instead of regular sauce was off the charts. My husband had a what I'll call meat lover, he said it was the best pizza he ever had. Fresh ingredients make all the difference.
Damn Good Popcorn
Delicious Pizza! So glad we finally got to try the chicago deep dish and mexican stromboli. Yum!
Jeanne Sampson
Delicious! Quality taste and ingredients. I don't live close so it's not often I get to visit. But it's well worth the stop. The employees are courteous and about pleasing the customer. The wings are nice size. The Stromboli was excellent. The dough and sauces are very good!
I was watching my son play baseball at the park next door and decided to order a pizza for me and the kids. We got the deep dish pizza pie, and I’m really impressed. First bite had a nice crunch to the soft outer crust followed by a slightly sweet sauce that immediately gave way to the salty garlic cheese sprinkle on top, and then the cheese and sausage and especially the bacon (nice chunks) rounded it off. This is great! I’ve had so many deep dishes in Chicago, and I wouldn’t call it one of those. This is a great pizza pie experience, though, and I wouldn’t call order a side of sauce to dip the edge crust, which is almost like focaccia. I’m telling you…this is on point, and I highly recommend it. And I called this $1-$10 per person because, even though I winced at the $29.99 price tag, it fed me and 4 of my kids.
The Robbo pizza is amazing!!
As was the sausage!
And the deluxe was just
That.
Phenomenal
Always a Friendly Place and excellent Pizza especially the Chicago deep dish 😋
Best pizza in Licking Valley hands down.
Love this place and employees are amazing. They have local honey for sale which is delicious . I’ll always come back for their food and service which is to die for
The best pizza in the world in my opinion fluffy but crisp crust! The best pizza sauce ever! Perfect amount of cheese and they don’t skimp on the toppings! You have to try the garlic parmesan crust! I couldn’t Recommend Panther Pizza enough! My go to order is a traditional crust pizza with garlic parmesan crust, extra pizza sauce, pepperoni, bacon, and hot honey! And you have to try their BLT Stromboli at least once it’s heavenly!
Why do you even put a choice of how you want your pizza cut? The last 4 times we have ordered pizza, we have asked for pie cut. It comes square cut! You offer to make a new one but at that point we don’t care to wait any longer for our food.
Wonderful place. I especially love it for the flavor of their dough. Perfectly salted. Pizzas are fantastic but I warn you I haven't ventured away from a simple pepperoni and cheese. The Stromboli's are amazing - sausage specifically. Take some time and try their desserts as well. I went with the blueberry cheesecake and it was just what I needed!
I love this place but it’s the most expensive pizza shop around! I’ve decided to stop going because the last 3 times they’ve messed up my order. This past time my BLT chicken salad had 4 pieces of chicken. We realized that my daughters 14 year old classmates work there so I’m assuming that’s why orders are getting messed up
I live in Newark and this has become my favorite pizza place! My boyfriend I get a thin garlic crust pizza with pepperoni, sausage, pineapple and jalapeno. Yumm! Every once in a while we will get just a classic pepp pizza, and they are just as delightful.
Heard from a friend that the deep dish is legit. Will definitely have to give it a try. As well as those desserts I always see while checking out. :)
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious. I live pretty far away so I rarely get Panther Pizza. Had a pepperoni pizza and a deluxe pizza tonight. Both were perfect. I sat and waited on my pizza and they brought out a full pizza as a sample. It was also excellent. The owner and employees were all very nice even though they were extremely busy. Can’t wait to try something else next time.
Panther pizza was a charming little eat in pizza shop. We had just come off the licking river and we’re hungry. The pizza was very good !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New to the area so trying all the local spots. All I can say is, "Wow!" I ordered the Margarite. The pesto instead of regular sauce was off the charts. My husband had a what I'll call meat lover, he said it was the best pizza he ever had. Fresh ingredients make all the difference.
Delicious Pizza! So glad we finally got to try the chicago deep dish and mexican stromboli. Yum!
Delicious! Quality taste and ingredients. I don't live close so it's not often I get to visit. But it's well worth the stop. The employees are courteous and about pleasing the customer. The wings are nice size. The Stromboli was excellent. The dough and sauces are very good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pizza
Loading...