Pizza Nerds
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
2050 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark
(740) 281-3030
About Pizza Nerds
Pizza Nerds Reviews
If you like Hawaiian pizza and jalapeños, you NEED the Cosmo Kramer from pizza nerds in your life! hands down the best Hawaiian pizza I've ever had. I ordered through Doordash and selected extra cheese and extra pineapple, which can sometimes be hit or miss on doordash, and they DELIVERED. PACKED with flavor, I could write a poem about it. Haven't tried my almond cookies yet but very excited. Thank you for making my Friday night!
Dough was raw. When I called to let the owner know, they demanded pictures. I sent the photos of the uncooked dough and told I would be given a complimentary pizza. However when I called the next day my number was blocked! I was nothing but polite and cordial. Totally unprofessional. I want to support local businesses, but don't kill the messenger. Bad pizza and immature owner/operators.
Absolutely as expected, kinda a combo of jets and stadz, the best of both. very rarely does the food at a restaurant come out like it looks in pictures, but pizza nerds knocks this out of the park. the cookies are phenomenal as well, and pricing is very competitive. Well worth the but of a wait and it's understandable why there is one!!
Ratings
Menu
People in Newark Also Viewed
Pizza Nerds is a highly-recommended spot for pizza lovers. The atmosphere, people, and pizza are all "out of this world amazing!" This small pizza place offers incredible pizzas, as well as delicious cookies made with love and passion. The owners are super cool, friendly, and helpful, making customers feel welcome. Although there's no dine-in option, the space is wheelchair accessible for pickup, and the owners are accommodating. The decor is unique, and the food is exceptional, especially the cookies like the raspberry one, which is soft, huge, and so delicious it’s hard to forget. Customer service has been noted as kind and helpful. Recent reviews highlight that the restaurant has moved to Gahanna and only improved, with crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and amazing topping combinations on every pizza. Service remains kind and professional. Customers also praise the phenomenal pizza and cookies, with kids enjoying arcade games during pickup. The place offers a quirky yet gourmet experience, satisfying both those wanting something different and lovers of delicious baked ingredients. It’s considered a cure for the munchies and is highly recommended to add to any pizza rotation, especially for those who love creative flavors and tasty cookies.