We ordered the donkey Kong, a cheesy bread and 2 cookies (raspberry and snickerdoodle)
The pizza wasn't my favorite for a classic cheeseburger pizza but it was a good introduction to this restaurant! I think it would be improved with a different sauce and maybe some lettuce & tomato toppings! The fries were fun but I just found myself taking them off and eating them separately. Definitely loved the crust style though and the ranch is great!
The show stopper was the raspberry cookie!! The cookies are huge and so soft and delicious. So delicious I forgot to get any pictures.
Employee at the front was very kind and helpful with all my questions!
Michael Raymond
Both the pizza we got and the cookies were fantastic.
Cody S
The first time we ordered pizza from here we got some type of Mexican pizza with corn & hot Cheeto dust - hands down best pizza I’ve ever had. Super sad they removed it from the menu. We just ordered 2 of the normal pizzas and they were good but no where near as good as the first pizza. Both of our pizzas could have used more sauce. The one pizza came with homemade ranch sauce (which was amazing) but they were so skimpy on the sauce it was like eating cheesy bread with garlic sauce, chicken, and bacon on it. Did not seem like pizza. The second order was slightly a let down when compared to the first but it was still good! If we order again we will ask for extra sauce. All of their sauce is on top and there was no sauce under the cheese. Super weird!
Kessashun Arthur
We tried this place for takeout one night. We ordered the Jazzy Jeff and Mario pizzas, and a BYO pizza with ranch, pepp, and pineapple (I know.. my friend who built this is crazy lol). The Mario was excellent and I'd go for it again anytime. The others were just decent. We went thick crust on all the pizzas and they had good crispy edges; it's Sicilian-style thick, so not quite deep dish. Their garlic bread was very good, I highly recommend it, and it comes free with any order of $35+. The cookies in the case looked pretty scrumptious, but we didn't try any. Overall, this is a solid pizza spot that's worth a try.
Anthony Terlecky
My husband and I are very picky when it comes to pizza. We both grew up in the Youngstown area, so pizza in Columbus is different to say the least. This place though, Columbus loves, and we can see why. We went this past week to check it out and ate the whole pizza in my car (no eat in at the restaurant) The whole vibe is cool if you're an 80s/90s kid. We loved the pizza and the owners seemed real nice! Now if they could open up in Powell area, we'd be so happy!
Nina Roberts
The atmosphere and service is great, very friendly people. I bought a pepperoni pizza deep dish and the taste was just not for me. It is definitely an acquired taste! The taste of the pizza kind of reminded me of Pizza Cottage. It’s got this very strong, off putting taste to it that made me feel kind of nauseous. I can’t put my finger on it, not sure how to describe that but definitely try for yourself and decide if ur taste buds are equipped for this. I sadly was disappointed after seeing so many amazing reviews. Take this into consideration, I suggest still trying the pizza for yourself! With all the great reviews I can imagine more people love it than not. This is just my personal opinion. Good luck to this company!
Amber Hendricks
Service was friendly and very quick, with text message updates on our order that were very appreciated. We got a cheese pizza and breadsticks and they were both delicious, the crust was chewy, crispy, and thicker, but not too dense. The sauce was flavorful without being too sweet or salty, we will definitely be back.
Derrick Bass
The employees were very polite and helpful. It was my first visit and I definitely will be coming back!! Great job guys!!!
Cyndi Adcock
Dang yall I really loved this pizza! Got the thin crust which was still a pan style, nice and soft with crisp edges. The cheese blend had depth of flavor and high quality toppings. So glad this is in Gahanna now, will be back!
Melissa Melissa
Perfectly cooked crust, plenty of cheese and sauce. And the cookies are delicious, baked through and soft. Staff was friendly, hopefully they get enough business being tucked in that spot.
My only complaint is that the cookie selection online only had 1 flavor - in store they had several. For delivery that would deter me from ordering if I don’t like that flavor.
Great pizza (Donkey Kong & Pepperoni w/Mushrooms), cookies were great, environment felt like my childhood! I’ll definitely be back!
Jens Dreams
I am not sure if they were just having a bad day but the pizza was not good. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, cheese sticks, and cookies. The pizza was burnt and actually tasted burnt cheese sticks hardly had a taste that ranch is nasty way too many green onions in it. The cookies weren't even great at least the ones I got. I even had my kids rate it and they gave it a 4, and 5 side note they are young kids and y'all know the young ones tell the truth. I was very disappointed because the reviews so far are good I don't know about other people's taste buds but it's a no for me. The atmosphere is a nice settings that was the best part for me. I will not be back.
John Berger
The pizza and cooookies were amazing!
Joe V Roh
The Mario was great along with each cookie we tried. Staff was friendly and the atmosphere was really cool!
The address on Tiktok needs updated!
Brandon Ondayko
This is the best darn pizza place in Gahanna! The only joint around here that can compete is Sextons, but they've got a whole other thing going on. Nerds is absolutely incredible and we are lucky to have them around. Give Pizza Nerds your money, and they'll give you some dope pizza 😤 (The Cheese and Chong is 🔥)
We ordered the donkey Kong, a cheesy bread and 2 cookies (raspberry and snickerdoodle)
The pizza wasn't my favorite for a classic cheeseburger pizza but it was a good introduction to this restaurant! I think it would be improved with a different sauce and maybe some lettuce & tomato toppings! The fries were fun but I just found myself taking them off and eating them separately. Definitely loved the crust style though and the ranch is great!
The show stopper was the raspberry cookie!! The cookies are huge and so soft and delicious. So delicious I forgot to get any pictures.
Employee at the front was very kind and helpful with all my questions!
Both the pizza we got and the cookies were fantastic.
The first time we ordered pizza from here we got some type of Mexican pizza with corn & hot Cheeto dust - hands down best pizza I’ve ever had. Super sad they removed it from the menu. We just ordered 2 of the normal pizzas and they were good but no where near as good as the first pizza. Both of our pizzas could have used more sauce. The one pizza came with homemade ranch sauce (which was amazing) but they were so skimpy on the sauce it was like eating cheesy bread with garlic sauce, chicken, and bacon on it. Did not seem like pizza. The second order was slightly a let down when compared to the first but it was still good! If we order again we will ask for extra sauce. All of their sauce is on top and there was no sauce under the cheese. Super weird!
We tried this place for takeout one night. We ordered the Jazzy Jeff and Mario pizzas, and a BYO pizza with ranch, pepp, and pineapple (I know.. my friend who built this is crazy lol). The Mario was excellent and I'd go for it again anytime. The others were just decent. We went thick crust on all the pizzas and they had good crispy edges; it's Sicilian-style thick, so not quite deep dish. Their garlic bread was very good, I highly recommend it, and it comes free with any order of $35+. The cookies in the case looked pretty scrumptious, but we didn't try any. Overall, this is a solid pizza spot that's worth a try.
My husband and I are very picky when it comes to pizza. We both grew up in the Youngstown area, so pizza in Columbus is different to say the least. This place though, Columbus loves, and we can see why. We went this past week to check it out and ate the whole pizza in my car (no eat in at the restaurant)
The whole vibe is cool if you're an 80s/90s kid. We loved the pizza and the owners seemed real nice! Now if they could open up in Powell area, we'd be so happy!
The atmosphere and service is great, very friendly people. I bought a pepperoni pizza deep dish and the taste was just not for me. It is definitely an acquired taste! The taste of the pizza kind of reminded me of Pizza Cottage. It’s got this very strong, off putting taste to it that made me feel kind of nauseous. I can’t put my finger on it, not sure how to describe that but definitely try for yourself and decide if ur taste buds are equipped for this. I sadly was disappointed after seeing so many amazing reviews. Take this into consideration, I suggest still trying the pizza for yourself! With all the great reviews I can imagine more people love it than not. This is just my personal opinion. Good luck to this company!
Service was friendly and very quick, with text message updates on our order that were very appreciated. We got a cheese pizza and breadsticks and they were both delicious, the crust was chewy, crispy, and thicker, but not too dense. The sauce was flavorful without being too sweet or salty, we will definitely be back.
The employees were very polite and helpful. It was my first visit and I definitely will be coming back!! Great job guys!!!
Dang yall I really loved this pizza! Got the thin crust which was still a pan style, nice and soft with crisp edges. The cheese blend had depth of flavor and high quality toppings. So glad this is in Gahanna now, will be back!
Perfectly cooked crust, plenty of cheese and sauce. And the cookies are delicious, baked through and soft. Staff was friendly, hopefully they get enough business being tucked in that spot.
My only complaint is that the cookie selection online only had 1 flavor - in store they had several. For delivery that would deter me from ordering if I don’t like that flavor.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza (Donkey Kong & Pepperoni w/Mushrooms), cookies were great, environment felt like my childhood! I’ll definitely be back!
I am not sure if they were just having a bad day but the pizza was not good. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, cheese sticks, and cookies. The pizza was burnt and actually tasted burnt cheese sticks hardly had a taste that ranch is nasty way too many green onions in it. The cookies weren't even great at least the ones I got. I even had my kids rate it and they gave it a 4, and 5 side note they are young kids and y'all know the young ones tell the truth. I was very disappointed because the reviews so far are good I don't know about other people's taste buds but it's a no for me. The atmosphere is a nice settings that was the best part for me. I will not be back.
The pizza and cooookies were amazing!
The Mario was great along with each cookie we tried. Staff was friendly and the atmosphere was really cool!
The address on Tiktok needs updated!
This is the best darn pizza place in Gahanna! The only joint around here that can compete is Sextons, but they've got a whole other thing going on. Nerds is absolutely incredible and we are lucky to have them around. Give Pizza Nerds your money, and they'll give you some dope pizza 😤 (The Cheese and Chong is 🔥)
Loading...