Pizza Nerds
2050 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark
(740) 281-3030
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Large Tommy Pickles
Garlic Cheese Bread
Large Garlic Bread
Kenny Rogers Pizza
Large Donkey Kong
Medium Big Daddy
Homemade Cookies
Specialty Pizza
L Tommy Pickles
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The first time we ordered pizza from here we got some type of Mexican pizza with corn & hot Cheeto dust - hands down best pizza I’ve ever had. Super sad they removed it from the menu. We just ordered 2 of the normal pizzas and they were good but no where near as good as the first pizza. Both of our pizzas could have used more sauce. The one pizza came with homemade ranch sauce (which was amazing) but they were so skimpy on the sauce it was like eating cheesy bread with garlic...
We tried this place for takeout one night. We ordered the Jazzy Jeff and Mario pizzas, and a BYO pizza with ranch, pepp, and pineapple (I know.. my friend who built this is crazy lol). The Mario was excellent and I'd go for it again anytime. The others were just decent. We went thick crust on all the pizzas and they had good crispy edges; it's Sicilian-style thick, so not quite deep dish. Their garlic bread was very good, I highly recommend it, and it comes free with...
The pizza wasn't my favorite for a classic cheeseburger pizza but it was a good introduction to this restaurant! I think it would be improved with a different sauce and maybe some lettuce & tomato toppings! The fries were fun but I just found myself taking them off and eating them separately. Definitely loved the crust style though and the ranch is great!
The...