Average, nothing more. Our order was 6 Traditional Buffalo wings, a BLT sub and a Chicken Parm sub. For my wing order I got 6 flats, no drumettes. I was stiffed the meatier drumettes! Both subs were ok. They were heated but not toasted so they were a little soggy. Everything tasted fine but nothing special about it.
Graham Gibson
Pizza is great here. Always consistent and the workers are friendly.
Cozy Collectors
Everybody in the reviews thinks they got a golden pallet or some shit.
This pizza is fire and will always be because the Owner.
Brian Grove
Ordered online for delivery at the Cherry valley hotel. They arrived very quickly even during the snow and the driver was very nice! The pizza was very flavorful with quality ingredients used. I highly recommend this great pizzeria!
Lorraine Carpenter
Not sure what changed but not good like it use to be. Several pieces of my cheese pizza had no cheese on it. Other half only had a few pepperoni. Probably won't order from here again. Unfortunate because I like to support local restaurants.
Brendan C
Called and they said they are no longer delivering for the evening because there was an inch of fresh snow im guessing.. Well, don't offer delivery at all. The individual on the phone basically hung up on me. I will never recommend this place or order from them in the future. The food is only mediocre by the way.
jim hill
What is that flavor? I swear I’ve never tasted a pizza like this. There is a unique flavor I can’t figure out what it is. Kind of reminds me of the difference when you have a burger on a flat top and one on a gas grill. This has a gas grill flavor to me. It’s amazing. is the best tasting pizza I’ve ever had. I’ve ordered here 3 different times, and everytime it’s consistently delicious. Delivery doesn’t take long and the drivers are cool. This is my go to pizza place from now on. Ignore the bad reviews, those people have no tastebuds.
Haylee Stollings
10/10 best pizza in town 😍
Wes Ogle
Pepperoni pizza was legit. Nicely burnt crust with crispy pepperoni, both tiny circled ones and thinly sliced ones on this pizza. Spicy BBQ chicken sub was very good. The romas are a nice compliment. It's not that spicy, but still tasty.
Andrew Schirtzinger
Honestly really disappointed got an Italian sub and Stromboli. The sub came with basically a tossed salad on it. Also small pieces of salami and pepperoni ??. The Stromboli is a small pizza folded … I’m not coming back.
Got a 3 meat pizza ? it was some of the best pizza I've ever eaten and I've eaten pizza in every location from heath too newark .this place is absolutely amazing great staff and they get the food done with the quickness. Definitely will be getting food from there again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbi Pond
I cannot speak of the atmosphere so I left 2 stars. We ordered delivery to our favorite watering hole 3 doors down and the delivery driver called and said he couldn't come in to deliver our food. The establishment we are sitting in that the driver couldn't come in to deliver our food to has ordered MULTIPLE times from them for parties and events.
I gave them another chance after 2 years of shunning them for the same reason. 2 years ago I walked to their place, ordered dinner and was told "they don't deliver here" so I agreed to come pick up my food. Then watched them deliver here 10 minutes later to someone else.
Throwing $ away by turning away delivery to customers 50 steps away.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Brit J
Visit Newark frequently. Ordered a pizza, garlic bread and a sub to a business. Guess I should have learned my lesson in December when I called the manager about his delivery people actually calling when they arrived. I was promised they would call. At one point, they had a young lady who called when she was in the parking lot. Not sure what happened to her, but the guy will just leave it. Everytime. And his manager has an excuse for him - Everytime. This was another large order he left to sit cold for anyone to pick up from the front desk. They claim my phone didn't work - the same phone I used to complain. Even if someone's phone "doesn't work" - you have a customers email. You can let the business know you have arrived. After speaking with the front desk staff, of course, he just left it!
Biting into what I knew would be the last piece of Bellvellies, knowing it would be the last piece to devour, there was a straight, long blonde strand not just on the pizza but COOKED INTO THE CHEESE. Not on top, cooked into the pie! Disgusting.
I won't bother with the current, immature management. Hair in your food is hair in your food- unsanitary and disgusting. Tossed the rest of the $50 meal out.
If you're seeking a good pizza place in Newark, Delfelice Bros calls you when they arrive, are of comparable price and absolutely delicious! No negative customer service and no hair.
Loved this place once when they were slightly better managed. Only returned because the food was good. Won't be returning now. And like any ill managed place, they don't care about loss.
Spend the extra couple bucks and get a place that has great food, communicates and is sans hair.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
James Wyant
Great food but delivery service is terrible!!!!! We stay at Cherry Valley Hotel which is awesome, and order Bevellies at every stay .
Don't order delivery, the one guy always leaves your food at the front desk and doesn't call you. Pizza was cold when we got it. Who ever delivered last night should be FIRED!!!
Food: 5
Service: 1
Brian Diggle
Really good pizza crust. Not too thick not to thin
Average, nothing more. Our order was 6 Traditional Buffalo wings, a BLT sub and a Chicken Parm sub. For my wing order I got 6 flats, no drumettes. I was stiffed the meatier drumettes! Both subs were ok. They were heated but not toasted so they were a little soggy. Everything tasted fine but nothing special about it.
Pizza is great here. Always consistent and the workers are friendly.
Everybody in the reviews thinks they got a golden pallet or some shit.
This pizza is fire and will always be because the Owner.
Ordered online for delivery at the Cherry valley hotel. They arrived very quickly even during the snow and the driver was very nice! The pizza was very flavorful with quality ingredients used. I highly recommend this great pizzeria!
Not sure what changed but not good like it use to be. Several pieces of my cheese pizza had no cheese on it. Other half only had a few pepperoni. Probably won't order from here again. Unfortunate because I like to support local restaurants.
Called and they said they are no longer delivering for the evening because there was an inch of fresh snow im guessing.. Well, don't offer delivery at all. The individual on the phone basically hung up on me. I will never recommend this place or order from them in the future. The food is only mediocre by the way.
What is that flavor? I swear I’ve never tasted a pizza like this. There is a unique flavor I can’t figure out what it is. Kind of reminds me of the difference when you have a burger on a flat top and one on a gas grill. This has a gas grill flavor to me. It’s amazing. is the best tasting pizza I’ve ever had. I’ve ordered here 3 different times, and everytime it’s consistently delicious. Delivery doesn’t take long and the drivers are cool. This is my go to pizza place from now on. Ignore the bad reviews, those people have no tastebuds.
10/10 best pizza in town 😍
Pepperoni pizza was legit. Nicely burnt crust with crispy pepperoni, both tiny circled ones and thinly sliced ones on this pizza. Spicy BBQ chicken sub was very good. The romas are a nice compliment. It's not that spicy, but still tasty.
Honestly really disappointed got an Italian sub and Stromboli. The sub came with basically a tossed salad on it. Also small pieces of salami and pepperoni ??. The Stromboli is a small pizza folded … I’m not coming back.
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Got a 3 meat pizza ? it was some of the best pizza I've ever eaten and I've eaten pizza in every location from heath too newark .this place is absolutely amazing great staff and they get the food done with the quickness. Definitely will be getting food from there again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I cannot speak of the atmosphere so I left 2 stars.
We ordered delivery to our favorite watering hole 3 doors down and the delivery driver called and said he couldn't come in to deliver our food.
The establishment we are sitting in that the driver couldn't come in to deliver our food to has ordered MULTIPLE times from them for parties and events.
I gave them another chance after 2 years of shunning them for the same reason. 2 years ago I walked to their place, ordered dinner and was told "they don't deliver here" so I agreed to come pick up my food. Then watched them deliver here 10 minutes later to someone else.
Throwing $ away by turning away delivery to customers 50 steps away.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Visit Newark frequently. Ordered a pizza, garlic bread and a sub to a business. Guess I should have learned my lesson in December when I called the manager about his delivery people actually calling when they arrived. I was promised they would call. At one point, they had a young lady who called when she was in the parking lot. Not sure what happened to her, but the guy will just leave it. Everytime. And his manager has an excuse for him - Everytime. This was another large order he left to sit cold for anyone to pick up from the front desk. They claim my phone didn't work - the same phone I used to complain. Even if someone's phone "doesn't work" - you have a customers email. You can let the business know you have arrived. After speaking with the front desk staff, of course, he just left it!
Biting into what I knew would be the last piece of Bellvellies, knowing it would be the last piece to devour, there was a straight, long blonde strand not just on the pizza but COOKED INTO THE CHEESE. Not on top, cooked into the pie! Disgusting.
I won't bother with the current, immature management. Hair in your food is hair in your food- unsanitary and disgusting. Tossed the rest of the $50 meal out.
If you're seeking a good pizza place in Newark, Delfelice Bros calls you when they arrive, are of comparable price and absolutely delicious! No negative customer service and no hair.
Loved this place once when they were slightly better managed. Only returned because the food was good. Won't be returning now. And like any ill managed place, they don't care about loss.
Spend the extra couple bucks and get a place that has great food, communicates and is sans hair.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great food but delivery service is terrible!!!!! We stay at Cherry Valley Hotel which is awesome, and order Bevellies at every stay .
Don't order delivery, the one guy always leaves your food at the front desk and doesn't call you. Pizza was cold when we got it. Who ever delivered last night should be FIRED!!!
Food: 5
Service: 1
Really good pizza crust. Not too thick not to thin
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Loading...